Still, as with Buck, a victory for Tharpe would not have a broad
effect on capital punishment as a whole.
Not exact matches
However, the evidence
on the deterring
effect of
capital punishment is not very persuasive, nor is it implausible to suppose that an innocent person could be convicted and executed, despite our extensive appeal system.
So for the means of
capital punishment which could actually be used, we probably could not count
on a deterrent
effect.
For many reasons — among them the example which
capital punishment sets, its
effect on those who must carry out death sentences and, above all, its violation of a basic moral principle — the state ought not to kill people.
«Medical ethicists challenge court ruling
on lethal injection in Alabama case: Ruling in death penalty case would have a chilling
effect on physicians» willingness to serve as experts in
capital punishment trials.»
Countless comparative studies have been done demonstrating that
capital punishment has no discernible
effect on general deterrence in conventional criminal cases.