«The bottom line from our study is that it adds validation to the claim that Board - certified teachers are, on average, more
effective than other teachers.
The evidence continues to mount that teachers who earn national - board certification are more
effective than other teachers, both at the high school and elementary levels.
Not exact matches
In contrast, the alternative pathway that requires prospective
teachers to take courses that are not transferable to
other fields yields
teachers who are less
effective at boosting student test scores
than either traditional - route
teachers or
teachers who entered the profession through
other alternative pathways.
In
other words,
teachers under threat of dismissal were more likely to voluntarily leave
than teachers not subject to this threat, and those who scored furthest from the «
effective» threshold were even more likely to go.
Regardless of the approach, all of the groups unabashedly acknowledge that some
teachers are more
effective than others and that even the best
teachers want to keep improving their practice.
In
other words, the fact that
teachers who received layoff notices were, on average, somewhat less
effective than their peers is an artifact of the relationship between effectiveness and seniority.
Our efforts to determine which students gain more
than others — and thus which
teachers and schools are more
effective — turn out to depend on conventions (arbitrary choices) that make some educators look better
than others.
If I had to summarize the current state of affairs, I'd say this: We know that
teachers matter and that some
teachers are better
than others, but we don't know the specific attributes that make some
teachers effective and
others ineffective.
For instance, writing in Education Next, economist Jake Vigdor showed that
teacher take - home salaries are more heavily backloaded late into one's career
than is the case for
other professionals, despite little evidence that more experienced
teachers were more
effective in the classroom.
Teachers entering the profession during recessions — and those entering when unemployment rates were high — were significantly more effective in raising student test scores than teachers entering at othe
Teachers entering the profession during recessions — and those entering when unemployment rates were high — were significantly more
effective in raising student test scores
than teachers entering at othe
teachers entering at
other times.
But preliminary new research focusing on Denver's residency program showed that
teachers trained through the program were less
effective at improving student achievement in math
than other novice
teachers in Denver.
According to Hattie,
teacher subject - matter knowledge had an effect size of 0.19, meaning that it was far less
effective than other factors like classroom management (0.52) or
effective teacher feedback (0.75).
He recently partnered with the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation on the «Measures of
Effective Teaching» (or MET) project, which was intended to develop metrics capable of determining which
teachers are faring better
than others, and to determine what factors help determine success.
Best Practices essays should be no longer
than 1,000 words and should describe your experiences with an
effective lesson plan idea or instructional method, along with tips for
other teachers.
If MET had found classroom observations to be strong predictors of
other indicators of
effective teaching and if the combination of measures were a significantly better predictor
than any one measure alone, then Gates could have offered evidence for the merits of a particular mixing formula or range of mixing formulas for evaluating
teachers.
The research consensus suggests TFA corps members are about equally
effective at raising students» test scores as
teachers from all
other pathways, though better in math
than in reading and writing.
Each year, TFA contracts with an external researcher to survey these principals, and year after year the majority of principals rate TFA
teachers» preparation and performance as at least as
effective as that of
other beginning
teachers, and in many cases as even better
than the overall teaching faculty.
Looking at both
teacher and school factors, the analysis of links to families suggests that personnel in the most
effective schools made a more concerted effort
than personnel in
other schools to reach out to parents.
Teachers in the most effective schools were more likely to send a letter or newsletter home weekly and call home regularly than teachers in the other
Teachers in the most
effective schools were more likely to send a letter or newsletter home weekly and call home regularly
than teachers in the other
teachers in the
other schools.
Kids taught by Teach for America corps members show growth among the top quartile of Indiana students, and 90 percent of TNTP's
teachers are rated by supervisors to be as or more
effective than other first - year
teachers.
The analyses of instructional practices within levels of school effectiveness document the fact that, on average,
teachers within
effective schools operate differently
than do
teachers in
other schools.
While all studies in this set reported positive effects due to various
teacher leaders practices in support of the implementation of instructional materials, Gigante and Firestone (2007) suggests that support provided within
teachers» classroom was more
effective than other forms of support.
This year, administrators fired 75 of those
teachers with poor appraisals and gave more
than 700
others rated minimally
effective one year to improve.
Despite ample research indicating that
teachers matter more to student achievement
than any
other in - school factor, 32 both the Trump - DeVos budget and the House appropriations bill proposed eliminating the Supporting
Effective Instruction State Grant program, often referred to as Title II grants after the section of the Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA), a reauthorization of the Elementary and Secondary Education Act, that authorizes the funding.
Improvements to how schools evaluate educators» effectiveness include assessing students in subject
other than math and language arts to identify
effective teachers in those non-standards areas.
That is,
teachers are more
effective some years
than others, and using one year's measure to predict future years will lead to further error.
On average,
teachers who are
effective in math are also
effective in reading, although some
teachers are better at one
than the
other.
North Carolina, Louisiana, and Tennessee all independently concluded that TFA corps members were the most
effective out of recent graduates from
other teacher preparation programs with which they had worked.151 A controlled study conducted by Mathematica found that students taught by TFA
teachers earned higher math scores
than students taught by non-TFA
teachers with similar years of experience; the TFA - taught students learned approximately 2.6 months of additional material in math during the school year.152 Similarly, another study found that TFA first to third grade
teachers» students grew 1.3 additional months in reading compared with their peers who had non-TFA
teachers.153
However, is this a sign that
teachers across the state could be joining the ranks of teaching professionals in some
other states and countries which pay more
than lip service to the importance of education and the influence of highly
effective teachers in the lives of children Maybe, but probably not.
A school - based
teacher preparation program in which a prospective
teacher, for not less
than one academic year, teaches alongside an
effective teacher, as determined by the state or local educational agency, who is the
teacher of record for the classroom, receives concurrent instruction during the year, through courses that may be taught by local educational agency personnel or by faculty of the
teacher preparation program; and in the teaching of the content area in which the
teacher will become certified or licensed; and acquires
effective teaching skills, as demonstrated through completion of a residency program, or
other measure determined by the state, which may include a
teacher performance assessment.»
Leaving my school building the
other day, I had an unexpected realization: Perhaps a computer was a more
effective teacher than I currently was.
The author estimates measures of value added for a subset of elementary
teachers and show that charter movers were less
effective than other mobile
teachers and colleagues within their sending schools, by 3 to 4 percent of a student - level standard deviation in achievement.
Some of the options
other than academies that are available to fund are
teacher residency programs, induction programs, improving equitable access to a diverse teaching staff and
effective teachers, integrating technology into the curriculum and instruction, and — yes — even establishing, expanding, or improving alternative routes to certification.
A growing body of rigorous research demonstrates that TFA corps members are as
effective as — and in some cases more
effective than —
other teachers.
The report also highlights the previous NNSTOY study's findings that adjunct or clinical faculty with recent PK - 12 teaching experience were seen as more
effective at connecting research to practice
than other professors; this report notes that serving in this key connecting role may be an important career path to consider for
teacher leaders.
The research suggests another way that we can and should enrich data on
effective teaching: examining the value that
teachers add to outcomes
other than standardized test scores.
«But at the same time we need to recognize that there are differences, and some people are more
effective than others... This is something any
teacher can have an opportunity to move into.»
A number of studies have found that the National Board Certification assessment process identifies
teachers who are more
effective in raising student achievement
than other teachers.
Illinois, on the
other hand, uses student and
teacher data from the 5Essentials Survey to differentiate schools.65 A 10 - year Chicago study found that schools that were strong in at least three of the five survey elements — which include
effective leaders, collaborative
teachers, supportive environment, involved families, and ambitious instruction — were significantly more likely to improve student learning
than schools that were weaker in these domains.66
We consider the limited empirical research on the potential for systematic errors in value - added for these
teachers, either because the models do not adequately account for the likely achievement growth of their students, or because they do not account for
teachers being more or less
effective for students with disabilities
than they are for
other students.
But instead of leaving
teacher effectiveness completely up to local educators, its Encouraging Innovation and
Effective Teachers Act (PDF) surprisingly requires states and districts to develop teacher evaluation systems that use multiple measures of evaluation; incorporate student achievement data; include more than two rating categories; are tied to personnel decisions; and are developed with input from parents, teachers, and othe
Teachers Act (PDF) surprisingly requires states and districts to develop
teacher evaluation systems that use multiple measures of evaluation; incorporate student achievement data; include more
than two rating categories; are tied to personnel decisions; and are developed with input from parents,
teachers, and othe
teachers, and
other staff.
Rather
than use the event to congratulate each
other on the destruction of our public schools, Connecticut's elected officials should be explaining to Duncan that the Common Core and Common Core Testing scheme is a fiasco that needs to be repealed and that Connecticut must be allowed to develop its own
effective teacher evaluation system that doesn't rely on the use of unfair, inappropriate and faulty standardized test scores.
Some schools are more
effective than others by virtue of their favorable resources, leadership, or organization; we can expect that
teachers of similar skill will perform better in these more
effective schools.
It stems from research showing schools that are rated highly on measures of
effective leaders, collaborative
teachers, involved families, supportive environment, and ambitious instruction are far more likely
than others to show improvements in students» learning gains.»
It provides some evidence that these
teachers are no more
effective than other new
teachers, and, in fact, they appear to be less
effective at raising math scores of elementary and middle school students.
Shana Frazin, who taught elementary school in California before becoming a staff developer with the Reading and Writing Project at
Teachers College, says the best principals find ways to reward teachers who work harder and are more effective than
Teachers College, says the best principals find ways to reward
teachers who work harder and are more effective than
teachers who work harder and are more
effective than others.
The current evidence base of
teacher quality across certification pathways does not point to one route as being more
effective than the
other.
Although the jury is still out on whether flipped classrooms are more
effective than other forms of teaching, intuitively, it would seem that those students who are most likely to fall behind or who need the most time on a topic would benefit from having more time with the
teacher.
Although research shows that BTR graduates are initially not more
effective at raising student test scores
than other new
teachers, the effectiveness of BTR graduates improves rapidly over time, and by their fourth and fifth years in the classroom, BTR graduates outperform
other veteran
teachers.70 Further, principals are very satisfied with the performance of former residents in their building: A recent survey conducted by BTR found that 97 percent of principals who employ
teachers who are alumni of BTR «would recommend hiring a BTR graduate to a colleague.»
In follow - up surveys from the earliest cohorts of the program, principals reported that nearly 9 in 10 iTeachAZ graduates scored «
effective» or «highly
effective» on their evaluation and that the achievement scores of graduates were significantly higher in both reading and math
than those of students whose
teachers graduated from
other programs.60