Trump's billionaire nominee for secretary of education has stirred up debate about
the effectiveness of school choice.
Such regulations are always a threat to
the effectiveness of school choice policies, but when a particular state adopts harmful regulations, the negative effects are localized.
But she also stood by
the effectiveness of school choice.
The Win - Win report recently released by EdChoice covers
the effectiveness of school choice by using methods new to education policy.
These favorable decisions and new programs, plus overwhelming academic proof documenting
the effectiveness of school choice, have bolstered efforts to secure greater parental choice in Pennsylvania and across the country.
«
Effectiveness of School Choice: The Milwaukee Experiment.»
Three factors have contributed to the muddled view regarding
the effectiveness of school choice: ideology, the limitations of individual studies, and flawed prior reviews of the evidence.
Not exact matches
Recent federal recommendations against offering the inhaled nasal influenza vaccine due to lack
of effectiveness could lead to more flu illness in the U.S. if the inhaled vaccine becomes effective again or if not having the
choice of the needle-less vaccine substantially reduces immunization rates, according to a new analysis led by University
of Pittsburgh
School of Medicine scientists.
Some organizations direct their activities only to district and / or charter
school issues, such as improving teacher quality and
effectiveness, developing new public charter
schools, or closing and transforming failing district
schools to create new high - quality
schools of choice.
On the second day, Thursday 19, workshops will include: «Managing honest conversations with employees», delivered by
Schools»
Choice; «Making
school meals count» by the Children's Food Trust; and «Operational
Effectiveness», by Chris Hallmark
of OEE Consulting.
To many in the media, both studies sound like they are estimating the
effectiveness of charter
schools or maybe even the impact
of school choice — so shouldn't the answer be the same?
It is a systematic and scientific way to summarize what we know about the
effectiveness of a program like private
school choice.
Mike Petrilli and Rick Kahlenberg are among my favorite people (I don't know Sam Chaltain, although I might like him, too), but their piece in Sunday's Washington Post smacks
of nanny - statism rather than
school choice and educational
effectiveness.
A second source
of disputes over the
effectiveness of choice are the limits
of each individual empirical study
of school choice.
For much
of the past few years, reflecting general concerns about the quality
of public
schooling, discussions
of magnet
schools have centered on their potential for providing intensive instruction in such subjects as science and mathematics, serving as models
of effectiveness, and increasing family
choice within the public system.
Regardless
of the reform strategy — whether new standards, or accountability, or small
schools, or parental
choice, or teacher
effectiveness — there is an underlying weakness in the U.S. education system which has hampered every effort up to now: most consequential decisions are made by district and state leaders, yet these leaders lack the infrastructure to learn quickly what's working and what's not.
Given the statute's scope, today's debate could include countless issues, such as possible changes to Title II rules on educator
effectiveness, the expansion
of the charter
school grant program, the introduction
of a private
school choice initiative, reconsideration
of competitive grant programs (RTTT, TIF, i3), and much more.
On the second day, Thursday 19, workshops included: «Managing honest conversations with employees», delivered by
Schools»
Choice; «Making
school meals count» by the Children's Food Trust; and «Operational
Effectiveness», by Chris Hallmark
of OEE Consulting.
A few major areas I hope will receive attention during reauthorization are college / workplace readiness, including the promotion
of more rigorous standards; greater accountability at the secondary level; more sophisticated policy and greater accountability for improving teacher
effectiveness, particularly at the late elementary and secondary levels; a broadening
of attention to math and science as well as to history; and refinements in AYP to focus greater attention and improvement on the persistently failing
schools by offering real
choices to parents
of students stuck in such
schools.
But if Strauss is inclined to introduce professors fulsomely, she might let her readers know that I am the Henry Lee Shattuck Professor
of Government and Director
of the Program on Education Policy and Governance at Harvard University, who has spent years researching
school governance,
school choice,
school accountability, and teacher
effectiveness rather than referring to me as «Harvard's Paul E. Petersen.»
They should continue to support funding for the replication and expansion
of high - quality charter
schools, and they should make new investments in research and support for parent information, equitable funding and facilities, and innovative, low - regulation approaches to equity and
effectiveness in
schools of choice.
«Using
School Choice Lotteries to Test Measures
of School Effectiveness.»
Charter
Schools, Achievers Early College Charter School, Camden, Coffee Break, growth, Individualized Education Program, Laura Waters, learning growth, local education agency, Mark Rynone, National Center for Special Education in Charter Schools, New Jersey, New Jersey Left Behind, New Jersey Special Education Collaborative, Newark, Newark Charter School Fund, NJ Left Behind, Paterson, Plainfield, School Choice, Special Education Medicaid Initiative, student achievement, student growth, student success, teacher effectiveness, teacher quality, The College of New Jersey, traditional public
Schools, Achievers Early College Charter
School, Camden, Coffee Break, growth, Individualized Education Program, Laura Waters, learning growth, local education agency, Mark Rynone, National Center for Special Education in Charter
Schools, New Jersey, New Jersey Left Behind, New Jersey Special Education Collaborative, Newark, Newark Charter School Fund, NJ Left Behind, Paterson, Plainfield, School Choice, Special Education Medicaid Initiative, student achievement, student growth, student success, teacher effectiveness, teacher quality, The College of New Jersey, traditional public
Schools, New Jersey, New Jersey Left Behind, New Jersey Special Education Collaborative, Newark, Newark Charter
School Fund, NJ Left Behind, Paterson, Plainfield,
School Choice, Special Education Medicaid Initiative, student achievement, student growth, student success, teacher
effectiveness, teacher quality, The College
of New Jersey, traditional public
schoolsschools
Recent work has included several studies related to value - added measures
of teacher performance, teacher
effectiveness in the early grades,
school choice, teacher mobility and special needs identification.
New Findings About the
Effectiveness and Operation
of Small Public High
Schools of Choice in New York City
3) «
School choice realists» like us, who want to empower parents to make decisions about their own kids» education, but are skeptical about the
effectiveness of distant bureaucrats.
As I have shown in the journals Educational Policy and the Journal
of School Choice: International Research and Reform, licensure exams are very loosely related to teacher
effectiveness.
Lead author
of Rhetoric vs. Reality: What We Know and What We Need to Know About Vouchers and Charter
Schools, he has published in the Journal
of Research on Educational
Effectiveness, Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, Behavioral Science and Policy, Statistics and Public Policy, the Journal
of Labor Economics, Economics
of Education Review, Education Finance and Policy, American Journal
of Education, Teachers College Record, Peabody Journal
of Education, Education Next, the Handbook
of Research on
School Choice, and the Encyclopedia
of Education Economics and Finance.
In the 2013 - 2015 state budget, money for districts will be tight again, creating a new round
of challenges, which D'Andrea says will probably include merit pay, a teacher
effectiveness program, the expansion
of school choice, and maybe the creation
of a statewide charter authorizer.
For all
of the authors» talk
of creating efficiency,
effectiveness, and equity in
schools through market - based reforms, they ignore the issues that have been found with
school choice policies.
The article notes the 2013 report «Sustained Progress: New Findings About the
Effectiveness and Operation
of Small Public High
Schools of Choice in New York City» by the group MDRC, which studies the causes of high graduation rates at small high schools in New Yor
Schools of Choice in New York City» by the group MDRC, which studies the causes
of high graduation rates at small high
schools in New Yor
schools in New York City.
Imagine Andrews is part
of the national Imagine
Schools network, 70 charter schools serving 38,000 students in 12 states and the District of Columbia, which use five Measures of Excellence to evaluate the effectiveness of each school, including academic growth, character development, economic sustainability, parent choice, and shared
Schools network, 70 charter
schools serving 38,000 students in 12 states and the District of Columbia, which use five Measures of Excellence to evaluate the effectiveness of each school, including academic growth, character development, economic sustainability, parent choice, and shared
schools serving 38,000 students in 12 states and the District
of Columbia, which use five Measures
of Excellence to evaluate the
effectiveness of each
school, including academic growth, character development, economic sustainability, parent
choice, and shared values.
Bender argued that targeted charter
schools can help students
of color who have been failed by the public
school system, while Slekar said that
school choice undermines the
effectiveness of public
schools, including their ability to address racial disparities.
How much proof
of its
effectiveness does
school choice need to show before it finally takes hold?
School «reform» in this country is well down a specific road, one that seeks to view the public school system as something of a business rather than a civic institution and that promotes choice in the form of charter schools, vouchers, etc., as well as standardized tests as the key measurement of student achievement and teacher effectiv
School «reform» in this country is well down a specific road, one that seeks to view the public
school system as something of a business rather than a civic institution and that promotes choice in the form of charter schools, vouchers, etc., as well as standardized tests as the key measurement of student achievement and teacher effectiv
school system as something
of a business rather than a civic institution and that promotes
choice in the form
of charter
schools, vouchers, etc., as well as standardized tests as the key measurement
of student achievement and teacher
effectiveness.
As a board member
of the Los Angeles Unified
School District (LAUSD), she authored the controversial Public
School Choice Resolution, which created an annual process to identify and address the lowest performing
schools in LAUSD, as well as the Teacher
Effectiveness resolution to ensure that all students have access to an excellent teacher.
With ever - increasing competition for students (
school choice, home
schooling, online classes), the success and
effectiveness of your district site and each
of your
school sites is critical.
But teachers» unions and their allies opposed magnets, charters, home
schooling, religious
schooling, and virtual
schools long before data about the
effectiveness of these
choices was collected.
The Centennial state has some
of the «best»
school choice, charter and teacher
effectiveness laws along with a strong set
of rigorous standards and assessments (though some need to be fixed).
U.S. Secretary
of Education Arne Duncan will waive 10 NCLB provisions — including the 2013 — 14 100 percent proficiency deadline, sanctions for low - performing
schools, the 20 percent set - aside for
school choice and tutoring, and highly qualified teacher improvement plans — for states that establish higher standards, create differentiated accountability systems, promote teacher
effectiveness, and reduce paperwork burdens.
She argues that
school reformers assume that
schools can do more to address poverty than is realistic, that accountability policies encourage narrowing
of the curriculum and teaching to the test, that vouchers have accumulated no significant evidence
of effectiveness, that «virtual charter
schools» are a ripoff
of taxpayers, and that there are more effective policy solutions that are far from test - based accountability and «
school choice» policies: social services for poor families, early childhood education, protecting the autonomy
of teachers and elected
school boards, reducing class sizes, eliminating for - profit companies and chains from operating charter
schools, and aggressively fighting racial and socioeconomic segregation in
schools.
See Martin Carnoy and Patrick J. McEwan, «The
Effectiveness and Efficiency
of Private
Schools in Chile's Voucher System,» Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis 22, no. 3 (Fall 2000), pp. 213 - 39, Chang - Tai Hsieh and Miguel Urquiola, «The Effects
of Generalized
School Choice on Achievement and Stratification: Evidence from Chile's Voucher Program,» Journal
of Public Economics 90, no. 8 - 9 (Sept. 2006), pp. 1477 - 1503.
We are not suggesting that district personnel policies, or policies governing
school choice, should be regarded as additional dimensions
of district
effectiveness, as per the district conditions identified in Anderson «s review (Anderson, 2006); it is simply the case that that they emerged in our analysis
of principal interview data as additional sources
of district influence on principal efficacy.
Our evidence also suggested the need to add two district conditions not included in our original list
of conditions associated with district
effectiveness: District personnel policies and District policies governing
school choice.
Qualitative research studies suggest numerous ways to improve access — defined as the opportunity for children and families to participate and fully experience the benefits
of a programme, affordability, suitability and sufficient quality — to early childhood services for Aboriginal children and their families.24 Some examples include: provision
of transport; locating services in areas where other daily activities occur (eg,
schools); provision
of low - cost or no - cost services; employing, training and retaining Aboriginal staff; provision
of culturally competent and secure services; community involvement in the planning and delivery
of services; and provision
of flexible, comprehensive and continuous services.24 Although some Aboriginal families prefer to use mainstream instead
of Aboriginal - specific services,
choice is another facilitator
of access.24 Furthermore, it remains unknown as to whether mainstream early childhood services with proven
effectiveness in non-Aboriginal populations confer the same benefits to Aboriginal children.