Since she came 35th in the shadow cabinet poll and this is the first junior post to be made public, it is an important signal that Ed Miliband (unlike much of the PLP who
elected the shadow cabinet) wants -LSB-...]
The fact is that the parliamentary party
elected a shadow cabinet that has failed to give Ed the support he deserves and the backing for change for which he has a mandate.
Under the proposals of an unelected committee chaired by Margaret Beckett, the PLP looks set to abandon a requirement that an incoming Labour PM include
elected shadow cabinet members in the new cabinet.
In the event, the PLP voted to retain elections for all shadow cabinet members and to elect the Chief Whip separately (a post previously appointed from amongst
elected shadow cabinet members).
With a new leader and a freshly
elected shadow cabinet, it would be natural to draw a line under past actions and concentrate all our attentions on future policy.
Labour sources said that Winterton was sacked at the start of a meeting to discuss a deal that would allow the party's MPs to
elect some shadow cabinet posts.
By voting to
elect all shadow cabinet members against the advice of former Ministers like Jack Straw and Phil Woolas and most speakers at the PLP meeting other than Frank Dobson, Labour MPs voted to be treated as more than just voting fodder.
Allowing MPs to
elect the shadow cabinet has huge support among the Parliamentary Labour Party, and the idea will be debated at their weekly meeting when the Commons returns on Monday.
But when it is in opposition, Labour MPs
elect the shadow cabinet ministers, which may allow for some unexpected figures to reach the front rank.
Who
elects the shadow cabinet currently?
MPs have a duty to show this is not the view of PLP and act before its too late by reinstating the rule by which the MPs
elect the shadow cabinet.
Not exact matches
Yes, he has an interesting biography but he was only
elected in 2010, has never held even a
shadow cabinet post and has no big following in the party or union backing.
Despite only getting
elected last year Sheppard has become one of the most recognisable SNP faces in SW1, his role as
shadow cabinet minister giving him license to roam across the broadcast studios.
In September 2015, the newly
elected Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn appointed Turley as
shadow civil society minister in his first
shadow cabinet.
When Jeremy was
elected he invited everybody who was in the existing
shadow cabinet to come and play a role including people like Caroline Flint and others.
He is expected to use the membership to help him shape policy and perhaps even contribute to
electing people to the
shadow cabinet.
11 of the 47
elected Chairs were previously, or subsequently, members of the
Cabinet or
shadow Cabinet which suggests they may not be quite the maverick outsiders that some analyses of the select committee system have suggested.
Tim Collins A former press secretary to John Major and member of the Downing Street Policy Unit, he was
elected MP for Westmorland and Lonsdale in 1997 and held a number of frontbench posts, including a series of roles in the
shadow cabinet under three party leaders.
Could you elaborate on why having the members
electing part of the
shadow cabinet is a bad idea?
A crunch meeting of Labour chiefs broke up tonight with no decision on whether the
shadow cabinet should be
elected by MPs.
Ahead of a leadership hustings debate at the Local Government Association conference this week, Mr Miliband even pledged to invite Labour's local government leader, at present David Sparks, into the
shadow cabinet if he is
elected party leader.
So does the number of women
elected or appointed to positions of responsibility within Parliament, whether as
Cabinet members,
shadow ministers or select committee chairs.
But we're intensely relaxed about the presence of David Miliband in the
shadow cabinet, we believe in an inclusive leadership, provided that it's in a
shadow cabinet committed to change — the basis on which Ed was
elected.
As a result, many ministers had been in place not just since the government was
elected in 2010, but had covered the portfolio in Cameron's
shadow cabinet or even earlier; Andrew Lansley had covered the health brief since 2004, when Michael Howard led the Conservatives in opposition.
Mr Corbyn's team do not want to being back wholesale
shadow cabinet elections but are considering allowing a small number of
shadow cabinet posts to be
elected as a peace offering to their divided party.
But senior frontbenchers say the price of working with Mr Corbyn would be the return of
shadow cabinet elections, giving MPs the power to
elect a substantial number of Labour's top team.
«There's been too much internal focus here on whether the
shadow cabinet is
elected or appointed by the leader and so on,» the former
shadow Europe minister told Sky News.
Peace offerings being discussed include allowing Labour MPs to
elect several members of the
shadow cabinet, and appointing staffers to the leader's office who are respected by rebel MPs in an effort to improve relations.
Many will argue that keeping the post but abolishing elections represents a reduction in accountability — Labour's leaders (though not, it seems, its
shadow cabinet or
cabinet) should be directly
elected.
Given that Corbyn wants party members to have more seats on the NEC (to extend his power there), and MPs want at least some
shadow cabinet members to be
elected, it is not hard to see how some sort of deal could be struck.
Corbyn has proposed that the
shadow cabinet be selected on a tripartite basis: a third
elected by members, a third by MPs and a third appointed by the leader.
Labour prime ministers don't have
cabinets elected in that way: so by what logic should the
shadow cabinet?
As a spin doctor he was combative and loyal and, after being
elected as an MP in 2010, one of his jobs in Ed Miliband's
shadow cabinet involved coordinating party presentation.
His ideas for rebuilding the Labour movement include an
elected party chair and a voice for Labour councillors in the
shadow cabinet.
The
shadow cabinet may be wholly
elected, or have all, half or one - third of its members appointed by the leader;
Notwithstanding the many qualities of Jon Cruddas and the excellent work carried out by other MPs — for example Gisela Stuart and Stella Creasy — in being effective voices for their members and communities and outstanding campaigners, it is, after all, only MPs who currently have the opportunity to be
elected to the
shadow cabinet.
Evans was originally
elected to parliament in 1992 and served in the
shadow Cabinet before becoming deputy Speaker in 2010.
Johnson's assessment came as the chairman of the parliamentary party, John Cryer, condemned Corbyn's controversial shake - up of his top team during a period when the leader's office had been in talks about the
shadow cabinet being
elected in part by MPs.
Newsnight has learnt from more than one source that Liam Byrne claims to have approached all but nine of the 256 MPs of the Parliamentary Labour Party in his efforts to get
elected to the
shadow cabinet.