JUSTICE STEVENS also observes that several amici curiae address
the equal protection argument.
And the New Jersey court's
equal protection argument begins, Volokh notes, by citing similar non-marriage-related gay rights laws.
With respect to
the equal protection argument, the Court noted, â $ œ [P] it bull attacks, unlike attacks by other dogs, occur more often, are more severe, and are more likely to result in fatalities.
Not exact matches
The Fourteenth Amendment accepts that
argument and endows it with constitutional
protection giving new meaning to the phrase that «all men are created
equal.»
Cuomo said there are a number of strong
arguments the legislation is unconstitutional, pointing to states» rights to tax, citizens» rights not to be double taxed, and the
Equal Protection Clause.
The governor said there's a «strong
argument» that it violates the
Equal Protection Clause because 12 Democratic - led states are harmed while other states gain by the tax changes.
Scalia, as mentioned above, sometimes seemed to accept this
argument and agreed that the original understanding of the
equal protection clause could not justify the outcome in Brown.
And now, in going back and doing it again, they are still using the public trust
argument but also, explicitly, the idea of
equal protection of the law and due process, that young people are being deprived of life, liberty, and property.
There's an
argument to be made that this is an
Equal Protection violation, but the government would be able to defeat it just by establishing that there was a rational basis for the difference.
Her
arguments were based in part on the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms that guarantees the right of individuals to
equal protection and
equal benefit of the law without discrimination.
1; Redish, Preferential Law School Admissions and the
Equal Protection Clause: An Analysis of the Competing
Arguments, 22 UCLA L.Rev.
Robertson's ruling came hours after a military judge rejected Hamdan's
arguments that the military tribunals violate the Constitution's
equal -
protection clause because detainees are not afforded the same rights as civilians or as they would be in a traditional military trial.