Although the moral standards and
ethical judgments of this country have long been permeated by Christian teaching, there is a widespread ignorance both of the actual history of the Christian Faith and of its revolutionary character.
It was
the ethical judgments of Charlie's physicians that kept Charlie from getting treatment when there was a reasonable chance it could benefit him.
What made the Charlie Gard case different is that the UK medical team, hospital, and courts insisted that he be taken off his ventilator — despite
the ethical judgment of his parents, and despite the willingness of medical teams in the US and Rome to provide an experimental treatment.
Not exact matches
Just as one can usually distinguish, according to their purposes, a good from a bad saddle or a good from a bad cavalry officer, so too the
judgment of good and bad in the
ethical sense should be eminently adjudicable if moral behavior is goal - determined.
What is really at stake is a fair
judgment on modernity, an assessment, a fine discrimination
of both its nobility and
ethical allure, on the one hand, and its self - destructiveness, and self - flattening and demeaning tendencies, on the other.
The ethics committee at the Hurley Medical Center in Flint, Michigan weighed in on August 9, 1993, opining that to honor the parents» desire to continue Baby Terry's treatment «would be contrary to medical
judgment and to moral and
ethical beliefs
of physicians caring for the patient» (my emphasis).
Part
of the problem the way the question is posed is by assuming that we can abstract an
ethical ideal from one part
of scripture and use it to judge the actions
of God in another part
of scripture, as though scripture were given us so we could form such dehistoricized abstract
ethical judgments!
What is remarkable is how quickly the need
of the church to make
ethical judgments on many problems entered into the shaping
of the tradition, as appears to have happened with the modification
of Jesus» word about marriage and the injunctions concerning the handling
of disputes (Matthew 19: 7ff.
A fortiori the church's moral and
ethical judgments are always in via and share the messy, unfinished and perfectible character
of the church itself
Yet to begin
ethical reflection at this point invariably seems to result in arbitrarily separating the moral
judgment of an action from the kind
of person who performs it.
Also, once we have recognized that our way
of dealing with other types
of creatures is subject to
ethical judgment through and through, should our concern be more with species, with ecosystems, or with individual animals.
In the Ladies Home Journal poll above referred to almost three quarters
of the respondents failed to connect religion with their adult
ethical judgments.
There are
judgments of style,
of logical cogency, and
of ethical purpose, for example, which can not possibly be summed up in a single grade.
On a philosophical level we can use the relationship
of the tree and the boy as a way to remind ourselves
of the very different
judgments produced by utilitarian and deontological
ethical systems.
For if my
ethical response to the sorrows
of another precedes my exercise
of judgment, I respond in the same way to all ostensible sorrows, whether authentic or not, self - indulgent or not, self - caused or not.
The highest task for health education in a society devoted to excellence is to discover and introduce into the cultural stream modes
of living that will fully employ bodily energies in ways that are at the same time consonant with the ideals
of reason, qualitative
judgment, and
ethical concern.
Making
judgments and taking actions can be pretty tricky, and no doubt even unpleasant from that context, but like Shawn noted in his «invasion» analogy, they may be entirely necessary (maybe that's a tool to employ in unpacking
ethical / cultural aspects
of Biblical history).
As transhumanism becomes more prevalent, as the sexual revolution identifies more perversions as «rights,» as technocracy overtakes
ethical reasoning and truth is more frequently confused with power, believers will find themselves ever more frequently in the position
of explaining that some realities are not contingent on the prevailing ethos
of culture, or on our
judgments, or on the fleeting whims
of self - definition.
The moral importance
of Christianity follows from its truth claims; otherwise its
ethical judgments have no power.
This public would expand in social inclusiveness as its
ethical level rose, gradually elevating the minds
of commercial men toward the standard
of judgment summed up in Smith's idea
of the «Impartial Spectator,» the quintessentially public citizen.
At least among those untutored in the rarefied mountain air
of meta «
ethical theory, ethics usually denotes that range
of human behavior that can be subsumed under the rubric
of judgments about inherent good and evil.
«Hence there is a place for
ethical teaching, not as «interim ethics,» but as a moral ideal for men who have «accepted the Kingdom
of God,» and live their lives in the presence
of his
judgment and His grace, now decisively revealed.»
In other quarters it is the specifically
ethical aspect which commands almost exclusive attention — conduct, moral
judgments, philanthropy, the Christian social order, and the like, The advocates
of the respective views are often severe with one another.
Browning's emphasis on ethics reflects his
judgment that contemporary churches are disposed to avoid the
ethical import
of the Christian message, offering care without accountability.
For it would rather seem that because
of Whitehead's recognition
of the thoroughgoing importance
of feelings as the initiation
of all
judgment and action that he is in a uniquely perceptive position to discuss ethics, if and once, the critic recognizes the centrality
of feelings for
ethical life.
The perfect love - ethic, while it remains the ultimate criterion
of ethical judgment, is impossible to fulfill in the natural state.
When, therefore, God passes his
judgment, it is on the occasion
of this social choice, but at the level
of its deepest motive (the attitude to God) and not the more superficial and secondary
ethical motive.
Value
judgments and
ethical preoccupations motivate societal planning, and it is under the guise
of the search for order and «the good» that societies with their political and economic components are established.
The more serious effort to concern itself primarily with
ethical rather than theological problems, as the followers
of Bonhoeffer have done, has led them outside the framework
of biblical language and
judgment, and has tended to dissolve their religious answers either into personal morality or social activism which, while serious in its intention, has made them weathercocks turning freely in the cultural winds.
Similarly all
judgments which are made on the conduct
of persons, either ourselves or others, require some
ethical measure.
The possible advent
of autonomous drones operated by «
ethical governors», however, would entail such a separation
of action from
judgment.
Thus, the near advent
of autonomous drones operated by «
ethical governors» would not solve any
ethical problem, it would dissolve a constitutive component
of ethics itself:
judgment.
The weight
of ethical judgment arises not only out
of the possibility
of fallibility, but equally out
of the responsibility for a correct
judgment.
Powell insisted his drunk driving arrest was just one night
of bad
judgment, compared to Rangel's long - standing
ethical lapses.
He said that Lord Ashcroft's tax status was a matter for him, that new rules regarding the conduct
of Tory MEPs would be published within weeks and he promised decisive but fair
judgment against anyone found guilty
of ethical lapses.
It has been many years since New York State had a governor with the vision,
judgment and authority that it needs now to turn Albany's budget from obesity, to resist powerful interests, to plot a course out
of an
ethical netherworld in which state the government has become a national embarrassment.
Weighing our own prosperity against the chances that climate change will diminish the well - being
of our grandchildren calls on economists to make hard
ethical judgments
Indeed, in a 2012 English High Court
judgment, Mr Justice Mitting endorsed the findings
of my own investigation which discovered that a claim, published in the Lancet in February 1998 by Wakefield, Walker - Smith and others that «Investigations were approved by the
Ethical Practices Committee
of the Royal Free Hospital NHS Trust, and parents gave informed consent» was false.
Like Mr. Baker's earlier features «Starlet» and «Tangerine,» this movie insists on meeting people on both sides
of the screen where they are, on suspending
judgment and extending compassion without abandoning its
ethical grounding.
«I kept thinking
of the Goya painting because it seemed detached from
ethical judgment.
Our goals will be to deepen our own understandings
of educational justice, to engage with others about complex
ethical judgments across multiple lines
of difference, and to learn how to enhance educators» and policymakers» capacities to make
ethical decisions under challenging conditions.»
This work includes looking at existing school culture and «hidden curriculum,» the importance
of establishing core
ethical values used to guide
judgment and decision - making, and understanding how character is formed.
If nothing else, their presence among Wal - Mart shareholders indicates how difficult it is to arrive at a uniform
judgment of what's
ethical and what's not.
Lauber, T.B., et al., The Role
of Ethical Judgments Related to Wildlife Fertility Control.
«Items» makes no
ethical judgments, but portrays instead the many paradoxes
of authorship in contemporary fashion, pointing to the way in which the origins
of a design are increasingly obscured by its global circulation and corporate ownership.
Also, the justifiability
of the views driving your act is part
of the
ethical judgment we pass on it.
Third, it focuses on our attempt the ground specific, and pragmatically critical quantitative choices — e.g. the value
of the «development threshold» — on
ethical judgments.
Although we can not predict specific impacts
of geoengineering with much confidence, we can fruitfully consider the conditions under which geoengineering research would be justified (or not), and
ethical theory provides a wealth
of resources to sift through the value
judgments that arguments for (or against) research inevitably involve.
In the remainder
of this post, I will outline the
ethical considerations and value
judgments that are relevant to determining the discount rate.
Determination
of the other two quantities, by contrast, involves
ethical value
judgments that are necessarily subjective.