Of those educators whose districts currently use these measures, half of the districts base 31 — 50 percent of their teacher
evaluation on student achievement or data, with an equal percent selecting 31 — 40 percent or 41 — 50 percent.
Very few districts place more than 50 percent of a teacher's
evaluation on student achievement data.
In April, the Texas State Teachers Association (TSTA) sued the Texas Education Agency (TEA) and its Commissioner Mike Morath, alleging that the scheduled July 1 implementation of the new Texas Teacher Evaluation and Support System (T - TESS) violates state law by requiring that school districts base 20 % of each teacher's
evaluation on student achievement growth measures -LSB-...]
Not exact matches
The Obama agenda has focused almost exclusively
on systemic school reform to address the
achievement deficits of disadvantaged
students: standards, testing, teacher
evaluations, and a continued, if different, focus
on accountability.
Charter school leader Deborah Kenny's op - ed in today's The New York Times argues against the move by many states toward teacher
evaluations based
on multiple measures, including both
student progress
on achievement tests and the reviews of principals.
Betty Rosa, the Regents chancellor and a former New York City school administrator, noted the current
evaluation law has created a situation under which teachers in fields not covered by state tests, such as physical education, often find themselves rated
on the basis of
student achievement in areas that are tested, such as English and math.
Then the unions fed the paranoid «opt out» movement, with hundreds of thousands of parents (mostly middle - class Long Islanders) refusing to let their kids take the state exams that measure
student achievement — and Cuomo waved the white flag
on using exams as part of teacher
evaluations.
The new
evaluation system will provide clear standards and significant guidance to local school districts for implementation of teacher
evaluations based
on multiple measures of performance including
student achievement and rigorous classroom observations.
For instance, the opportunity gap would force us to look more at how all
students should have access to early education versus the
achievement gap which has focused more
on developing standards, accountability, and
evaluation.
The 60 charter schools operating in New York City have provided a unique opportunity for the New York City Charter Schools
Evaluation Project, of which we are a part, to conduct a randomized field trial of the impact of charter schools
on student achievement.
Anyone participating in the education policy debate for five years or more probably staked out their position
on the use of value - added (or
student achievement growth) in teacher
evaluations long ago.
The absence of ReadNet Bronx from our
evaluation is likely to have only a small impact
on our assessment of
student achievement because the school had only two years of test - taking
students before it closed.
But you'll also need hard data
on such issues as
student and staff mobility, numbers of staff
evaluations, and the number of efforts you, as principal, make to increase
student achievement.
Ofsted's guidance
on effective self -
evaluation highlights that it needs to be able to capture the impact of the school's actions
on the quality of teaching,
students»
achievement, behaviour and safety.
A teacher's contribution to a school's community, as assessed by the principal, was worth 10 percent of the overall
evaluation score, while the final 5 percent was based
on a measure of the value - added to
student achievement for the school as a whole.
Numerous
evaluations of KIPP schools have found that
students show larger - than - expected gains
on various measures of
achievement.
Consistent with the prior studies, in this objective
evaluation, KIPP
students outperformed the comparison children
on numerous measures of
achievement, across a range of subject areas.
Among the reform milestones they achieved were a new requirement that 40 percent of a teacher's
evaluation be based
on student achievement; raising the charter school cap from 200 to 460; and higher
student achievement goals
on the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) 4th grade and 8th grade reading tests and Regents exams.
The purpose of this project is to perform the
evaluation portion of a randomized control trial designed to assess the impact of The Match School Foundation, Inc.'s teacher training program for novice teachers
on outcomes such as
achievement growth of teachers»
students, principal ratings, and retention with the ultimate goal of improving K - 12 education.
Only one - third of the programs had well - developed
evaluations that produced measurable effects
on student achievement or change in instructional practices.
Performance
on the sample lesson was related to both value - added contributions that teachers make to
student achievement and to their own
evaluation outcomes.
Even so, despite the urgings of the caucus and the local chapters of E4E and Teach Plus, UTLA refused to endorse the Los Angeles district's application for a $ 40 million Race to the Top grant, because it required the adoption of a teacher -
evaluation system based in part
on student achievement.
But it's also increasingly clear that the new generation of teacher
evaluations have the potential to strengthen instruction, make teaching more attractive work, and raise
student achievement on a wide scale — if states and school districts stay the course
on reform.
Despite the need to keep the focus
on academic
achievement, the Teacher Advancement Program acknowledges that research has identified pedagogical methods that help
students learn, so it includes
evaluation of classroom skills as part of its teacher compensation system.
, American Economic Review, 2005; Anna Egalite, Brian Kisida, and Marcus Winters, «Representation in the Classroom: The Effect of Own - Race Teachers
on Student Achievement», Economics of Education Review, 2015; Stephen Holt and Seth Gershenson, «The Impact of Teacher Demographic Representation
on Student Attendance and Suspensions», IZA discussion paper 9554, 2015; and Constance Lindsay and Cassandra Hart, «Exposure to Same - Race Teachers and
Student Disciplinary Outcomes for Black
Students in North Carolina», Educational
Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 2017.
Tilles raises legitimate concerns about the use of these tests — the quality of the tests, their snapshot nature, the unintended consequences of their being high stakes — but seems to forget that 20 % of the teacher score comes from «locally - selected measures of
student achievement» and that 60 % of
evaluation is based
on «other measures.»
The Commission, chaired by Dr. Paul Hill of the University of Washington, carefully reviewed the research
on the impact of school choice
on student achievement and included in its report the following statement: «The most rigorous school choice
evaluations that used random assignment... found that academic gains from vouchers were largely limited to the African - American
students in their studies.»
When they insist that ideas like school choice, performance pay, and teacher
evaluations based
on value - added measures will themselves boost
student achievement, would - be reformers stifle creativity, encourage their allies to lock elbows and march forward rather than engage in useful debate and reflection, turn every reform proposal into an us - against - them steel - cage match, and push researchers into the awkward position of studying whether reforms «work» rather than when, why, and how they make it easier to improve schooling.
Since a teacher had to score at least 64 points to avoid the «ineffective» rating, according to the Regents» plan, it was conceivable, as the judge noted, that «the regulation allows for an «ineffective» rating based solely
on poor
student achievement results (the first 40 % category) without regard to the 60 %
evaluation category.»
We contend, however, that
evaluations based
on observations of classroom practice are valuable, even if they do not predict
student achievement gains considerably better than more subjective methods like principal ratings of teachers.
Patrick Wolf, who conducted the
evaluation of the impact of the D.C. voucher program
on student achievement, talks with Education Next about that study in a video available here.
According to the National Council
on Teacher Quality (NCTQ), the number of states requiring objective measures of
student achievement to be included in teacher
evaluations nearly tripled from 2009 to 2015, from 15 to 43 states nationwide (see Figure 1).
As a consequence,
students» performances
on this type of instructionally insensitive test often become dependent
on the very same SES factors that compromise the utility of nationally standardized
achievement tests when used for school
evaluation.
Teachers» scores
on the classroom observation components of Cincinnati's
evaluation system reliably predict the
achievement gains made by their
students in both math and reading.
Perhaps the most valuable byproduct of the No Child Left Behind Act (NCLB) has been the resurgence of research
on the effects of teachers
on student achievement, which has informed the redesign of teacher
evaluation systems.
A back - end check that the
evaluation results corresponded with evidence of impact
on student achievement, where available, could have accomplished our purposes more effectively.
The new incentive, called the Race to the Top Fund, aims «to reverse the pervasive dumbing - down of academic standards and assessments by states,» the secretary said, and to punish states «that explicitly prohibit linking data
on achievement or
student growth to principal and teacher
evaluations.»
SCSF asked an independent research team to conduct an experimental
evaluation of the impact of the intervention
on student achievement and other outcomes, such as school climate and school quality, as reported by the
students» parents or other guardians.
Montgomery County's school district and union are focusing
on standards - based professional development and the
evaluation of teachers by principals, with the goal of improving
student achievement.
In a January special session, lawmakers approved new education policies, including the requirement that half of teacher
evaluations be based
on student achievement data.
A good teacher is now recognized as someone whose
students learn and grow, with 38 states revising their policies
on educator effectiveness to include measures of
student growth or
achievement as one of multiple factors in teacher
evaluations.
Moreover, school districts need to use that time productively, to assemble data
on student achievement, classroom observations, and, ideally,
student evaluations.
School leaders will be able to make retention decisions based
on valid measures such as
student -
achievement growth and classroom observations and
student evaluations.
This relationship suggests that Cincinnati's
evaluation program provides feedback
on teaching skills that are associated with larger gains in
student achievement.
It will provide
evaluation and assessment support to help schools strengthen
student achievement and accountability, and work to develop a clearinghouse of research and information
on small schools.
[xi] Teacher associations, for their part, continue to push back against teacher
evaluation systems that focus
on objective measures of
student achievement and provide any meaningful differentiation between teachers.
Studies
on evaluation reform efforts in Cincinnati, Chicago, Denver, New York City, and Washington, D.C. have found that comprehensive
evaluation systems can help identify teachers who need to improve their practice, nudge low - performing teachers out of the profession, and, ultimately, boost
student achievement.
Teacher and classroom context effects
on student achievement: Implications for teacher
evaluation.
AIR is conducting a three - year
evaluation focusing
on a variety of outcomes (e.g., educator perceptions, teacher retention, teacher effectiveness, and
student achievement) associated with the contract and associated initiatives.
Professor Masters has served
on a range of bodies, including terms as Chair of the Technical Advisory Committee for the International Association for the
Evaluation of Educational
Achievement (IEA) and Chair of the Technical Advisory Group for the OECD's Programme for International
Student Assessment (PISA).