Restorative Practices: Righting the Wrongs of
Exclusionary School Discipline by Dr. Marilyn Armour
Students with behavioral health needs are disproportionately subject to
exclusionary school discipline and school - based arrests.
The presence of police officers, guns, handcuffs, and metal detectors in schools creates hostile teaching and learning environments that are reinforced by harsh, punitive, and
exclusionary school discipline policies.
But while much has been said about the potential negative effects of
exclusionary school punishment, little is known about what policymakers can do to address it.
Not exact matches
Liberal MLA Mary Polak (Langley) was instrumental as a Surrey
School Board trustee in banning gay - positive books from Surrey Schools: The book ban was later struck down by the Supreme Court of Canada which said «instead of proceeding on the basis of respect for all types of families, the Board proceeded on an exclusionary philosophy, acting on the concern of certain parents about the morality of same - sex relationships, without considering the interest of same - sex parented families and the children who belong to them in receiving equal recognition and respect in the school system.&
School Board trustee in banning gay - positive books from Surrey
Schools: The book ban was later struck down by the Supreme Court of Canada which said «instead of proceeding on the basis of respect for all types of families, the Board proceeded on an
exclusionary philosophy, acting on the concern of certain parents about the morality of same - sex relationships, without considering the interest of same - sex parented families and the children who belong to them in receiving equal recognition and respect in the
school system.&
school system.»
Williams says many believe that ultimately this use of
exclusionary discipline pushed children out of the
schools.
The scholars write, «Across the state, black students are about 2.4 times as likely to receive
exclusionary discipline (conditional on reported infractions and other student characteristics), whereas within
school, this same conditional disparity is not statistically significant.»
They assess the evidence on critiques of
exclusionary discipline and in support of alternative strategies, and discuss areas where additional research is necessary to understand the consequences of both for
schools and students.
Of the program - and policy - based alternatives to
exclusionary discipline, Steinberg and Lacoe report the most evidence for, and positive effects from, the Schoolwide Positive Behavioral Interventions and Supports (SWPBIS) program, a strategy that aims to change a
school culture by setting clear behavioral expectations, laying out a continuum of consequences for infractions, and reinforcing positive behavior.
Further, they note that researchers have not yet established a causal relationship between the use of
exclusionary discipline and either
school climate or students» later lives — such as the
school - to - prison pipeline.
Steinberg and Lacoe note an increase in the use of
exclusionary discipline to address nonviolent offenses, such as
school uniform violations or refusal to turn off a cellphone.
We also found that there was a subset of
schools that could be labeled as «persistently
exclusionary.»
Because the Civil Rights Data Collection quantifies the use of
exclusionary discipline, it becomes a salient metric for researchers, advocates, and policymakers — but on its own, it does not paint a complete picture of a
school's approach to discipline or, more importantly, its overall climate.
In particular,
schools will need to adopt alternative practices, rather than eliminating or dramatically reducing the use of
exclusionary discipline in a policy void.
[11] They find black students in North Carolina were less likely to be subject to
exclusionary discipline when they had black teachers rather than white teachers, even within the same
school.
Moreover, reform advocates note, basing admissions on geographical boundaries is an
exclusionary practice, all too redolent of the days when low - income students of minority background desperately sought to escape from «slum» or «ghetto»
schools and gain access to the generally superior
schools in «good» neighborhoods from which they had been barred.
In a new study, Steinberg and Lacoe use data from Philadelphia
schools, relative to counterparts elsewhere in Pennsylvania over the same time period, to study a 2012 district reform restricting the use of
exclusionary discipline and emphasizing positive approaches.
Finally, the letter contains a significant appendix of «illustrative» specific suggestions for policy and practice that could serve to help states and districts avoid violations, urging
schools to reduce the use of suspension and other forms of
exclusionary discipline, focusing instead on positive approaches.
Such
schools need massive amounts of help in order to transform into orderly learning environments that don't have to resort so much to
exclusionary discipline.
The 2014 letter declares that «Studies have suggested a correlation between
exclusionary discipline policies and practices and an array of serious educational, economic, and social problems, including
school avoidance... decreased academic achievement... increased likelihood of dropping out; substance abuse; and involvement with juvenile justice systems.»
A
school's willingness to define its boundaries, however
exclusionary they may seem to outsiders, can have clear benefits for education.
As of May 2015, 22 states and the District of Columbia had revised their laws in order to require or encourage
schools to: limit the use of
exclusionary discipline practices; implement supportive (that is, nonpunitive) discipline strategies that rely on behavioral interventions; and provide support services such as counseling, dropout prevention, and guidance services for at - risk students.
According to the American Psychological Association's Zero Tolerance Task Force, there is no hard evidence that
exclusionary policies reduce
school violence.
And even if
schools reduce their use of
exclusionary practices, it doesn't necessarily follow that they will cease to mete out these punishments disproportionately by race.
Changes to district policies guiding
school discipline and student conduct constitute a direct approach to reducing
exclusionary discipline.
Restorative practices are a burgeoning alternative to traditional punitive justice such as suspensions (both in
school and out of
school) and other
exclusionary forms of discipline.
We don't know whether the use of
exclusionary discipline causes
school climates to deteriorate, or if administrators respond to unruly climates by clamping down on
school discipline.
In a separate study, Russell Skiba and Natasha Williams further revealed that black students in the same
schools or districts were not engaged in levels of disruptive behavior that would warrant higher rates of
exclusionary discipline than white peers.
While the evidence does suggest that
school climate is worse when
exclusionary discipline practices are more widespread, this evidence is not causal.
(
Exclusionary magnet
schools don't seem to bother ELC or Save Our Schools
schools don't seem to bother ELC or Save Our
SchoolsSchools - NJ).
Advo - cates of discipline reform contend that
exclusionary discipline may have adverse consequences for
school climate.
Fourth, even as our quality improves, our
schools have made remarkable progress reducing
exclusionary discipline.
Eliminating
exclusionary zoning in a metro area would, by reducing its housing cost gap, lower its
school test - score gap by an estimated 4 to 7 percentiles — a significant share of the observed gap between
schools serving the average low - income versus middle / higher - income student.
Effective remedies to improve instruction, learning and
school climate (including, e.g., decreases in bullying and harassment, use of
exclusionary discipline practices, use of police in
schools, and student referrals to law enforcement) for students enrolled are implemented in any
school where the
school as a whole, or any subgroup of students, has not met the annual achievement and graduation targets or where achievement gaps persist.
These evidence - based approaches help
schools support students with challenging behaviors and were recommended by the Mayoral Leadership Team on
School Climate and Discipline to keep students in school learning instead of punishing them through exclusionary discipline practices, which do not address the underlying causes of the beh
School Climate and Discipline to keep students in
school learning instead of punishing them through exclusionary discipline practices, which do not address the underlying causes of the beh
school learning instead of punishing them through
exclusionary discipline practices, which do not address the underlying causes of the behavior.
As many of you know, Black students are disproportionately referred to law enforcement and
school - related arrests, as well as subjected to
exclusionary discipline.
Exclusionary punishments, those that remove students from
schools, have come under fire in recent years.
We find clear evidence that elementary
school students are less likely to be subjected to
exclusionary discipline when their race matches that of their teacher.
The State of New Jersey sought review in this Court, first arguing that the
exclusionary rule is wholly inapplicable to searches conducted by
school officials, and then contending that the Fourth Amendment itself provides no protection at all to the student's privacy.
In an October article for the periodical Education Next, researchers Matthew Steinberg and Johanna Lacoe argued that current evidence is inconclusive on whether disproportionate discipline is actually the result of bias, and researchers have been unable to show how
exclusionary discipline affects
school climate or students» future lives.
On average, a black student with a black teacher in a
school where more than two - thirds of the student - body is black is still more likely to experience
exclusionary discipline, compared to a black student assigned to a white teacher in a
school where black students accounted for less than a third of the student population.
In fact, a handful of studies have shown that black and Latino students are less likely to receive
exclusionary discipline in
schools with higher concentrations of black and Latino teachers.
Our primary outcome of interest is whether a student received an
exclusionary disciplinary consequence — that is, one that removed him or her from the classroom as punishment, including detention, in -
school suspension, out - of -
school suspension, or expulsion.
For the past several years, state education leaders in California have encouraged
schools to reduce these
exclusionary punishments.
Some cities are addressing inequity, by finding ways to give more students access to challenging curriculum, reducing the use of disproportionate
exclusionary discipline, and improving access to the best
schools.
Indeed, a 2014 analysis of
school discipline data by the U.S. Commission on Civil Rights found these students are overrepresented among students who experience
exclusionary discipline across the country.
However, because
schools with larger populations of black students have higher average
exclusionary discipline rates overall, race - matched students at those
schools are not necessarily less likely to experience such measures.
Sixteen percent of black male elementary
school students in the classrooms of white female teachers received
exclusionary discipline in North Carolina during our study period.
Consequently, it is hard to assess how today's public
schools compare with their predecessors (with their stratified, segregated, often
exclusionary educational structures), with contemporary Catholic
schools (that sometimes abandon problem students), or with experiments in
school choice and vouchers (all still relatively new and limited).
Any faith
school is to a degree
exclusionary.