We do not think that it is proper, we do not think that it is the proper
exercise of the discretion given to him under the constitution.»
Not exact matches
Witnesses repeatedly criticized IFRS for stripping auditors
of their ability to «
exercise prudent judgment» — which is another way
of saying it
gives management wide
discretion when reporting financials.
In the event
of a change
of control (as defined in the plan), the compensation committee may, in its
discretion, provide for any or all
of the following actions: (i) awards may be continued, assumed, or substituted with new rights, (ii) awards may be purchased for cash equal to the excess (if any)
of the highest price per share
of common stock paid in the change in control transaction over the aggregate
exercise price
of such awards, (iii) outstanding and unexercised stock options and stock appreciation rights may be terminated, prior to the change in control (in which case holders
of such unvested awards would be
given notice and the opportunity to
exercise such awards), or (iv) vesting or lapse
of restrictions may be accelerated.
«
Given the unusual combination
of facts — as well as the fact that nothing in the existing Rules or Decisions specifically addressed such circumstances
of simultaneous competitor error and Committee error — the Committee reasonably
exercised its
discretion under Rule 33 - 7 to waive the penalty
of disqualification under Rule 6 - 6d, while still penalizing Woods two strokes under Rules 26 - 1a and 20 - 7c for playing from a wrong place.»
The DPP urged the court to
exercise its
discretion in favour
of the state because Aluko had
given evidence under cross examination that the election which brought Fayose into power was free, fair and credible devoid
of military harassment.
It's all very subjective, and a great deal
of leeway is
given to the
exercise of prosecutorial
discretion.
If we understood the consequences
of any
given action, we could
exercise discretion, thus restructuring our fate.
For example, in the recent Liden v Burton [2016] EWCA Civ 275, [2016] Fam Law 687 (proprietary estoppel: see next article) Hamblen LJ characterised the issues on appeal as: «(i) whether the judge wrongly applied the law to the facts as found; (ii) whether the judge erred in the
exercise of his
discretion in
giving effect to the equity» in the particular case.
In particular, the court noted [at paragraph 29] the established principle that «though discretionary decisions will generally be
given considerable respect, that
discretion must be
exercised in accordance with the boundaries imposed in the statute, the principles
of the rule
of law, the principles
of administrative law, the fundamental values
of Canadian society, and the principles
of the Charter.»
The CPS should: «Set out in advance how it intends to approach the
exercise of discretion in any
given category
of case... Explain how any
given decision has been reached.
«Although the Court
of Appeal states that an interim order is to be used only in extraordinary cases, significant
discretion is
given to the Inquiries Committee in making the determination, which if
exercised, is almost impossible for a health professional to challenge,» he says.
The same factors are likely to be relevant when consideration is being
given to the
exercise of this
discretion in civil or family proceedings.
It shrinks the broad, unfettered
discretion [the prior framework
gave] the relevant regulatory authorities to conduct a compliance audit
of an ILP, albeit only
of an ILP, to a
discretion which is properly
exercised only in response to conduct which has or is alleged to have occurred in the past — and conduct which inevitably comes to attention only haphazardly, in ways which underreport conduct which ought attract regulatory scrutiny by many tens, if not hundreds
of times.
The district court
gave thoughtful attention to factors recognized in § 3553 (a) and
exercised sound
discretion to ensure that the punishment fit the crime and the circumstances
of the appellants.
For five years she was a member
of the BC provincial court, time and time again, when serious criminals — including sex offenders — appeared before her court, she
exercised her
discretion to
give them a lenient sentence.
For the court to
exercise its
discretion so as to leave the Claimants without the possibility
of a determination on the merits in either jurisdiction does not seem to me to be what Parliament intended when it
gave Claimants a jurisdictional choice.
Given the significant impact
of that change, the Court
exercised its
discretion to quash the resolution.
MYSTERY # 1 Answer: Isn't the presumption - on - appeal just another way
of saying that abuse
of discretion review applies — per Stevens — and that sentencing within the guidelines is presumptively a reasoned
exercise of discretion,
given all the reasoning behind the guidelines, at least where all the proper procedural steps were taken by the district court at sentencing?
The weight that the court, in the
exercise of its
discretion under Rule 12 (6),
gives to the loss
of insurance coverage as a potential disadvantage that the other spouse may suffer as a result
of the early severing
of the claim for divorce depends on the evidence in the particular case.
Given the keen interest
of the diverse parties following this litigation closely, and the potential learning value
of this case to a broad audience beyond, this case presents an ideal instance in which judicial
discretion should be
exercised under the auspices
of the rule to admit Internet to the courtroom.
«This is one
of those exceptional cases in which the interests
of justice demand that Al - Enzi be
given a new trial so that he can be defended throughout by his own counsel... the trial judge
exercised his
discretion unreasonably by denying Al - Enzi a severance or a mistrial so that he could retain a lawyer to represent him at a new trial.
'' (T) he question whether fresh evidence is admitted or not is to be decided by an
exercise of discretion... (T) he question is largely a matter
of decree and there is no precise formula which
gives a ready answer.
• the Council was entitled to deference in the
exercise of its
discretion as to whether Mr. Black should be
given an opportunity to make representations orally or in writing.
The Court stated: «even
given the degree
of deference due to an adjudicator's
exercise of the broad remedial
discretion conferred by the Code, the reasons
given in this case do not..., provide a cogent justification for the decision to order reinstatement» (para. 87).
Given these exceptional circumstances and the nature
of this legal issue, the Prosecutor has
exercised her independent
discretion under articles 19 (3) and 42 to seek a ruling on the question from the Pre-Trial Chamber.
The proper approach is more consistent with the goals
of s. 25 (1)
of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act and focuses more on the equitable underlying purpose
of the humanitarian and compassionate relief application process, seeing the words in the Guidelines as being helpful in assessing when relief should be granted in a
given case, but without treating them as the only possible formulation
of when there are humanitarian and compassionate grounds justifying the
exercise of discretion.
The court has
given guidance on the
exercise of its
discretion to release a party who has obtained a freezing order from his undertaking not to use information obtained thereby in contempt proceedings against the other party.
«For five years she was a member
of the B.C. provincial court, time and time again, when serious criminals — including sex offenders — appeared before her court, she
exercised her
discretion to
give them a lenient sentence,» the web site states.
Instead, the trial judge
exercised the
discretion he was
given by s. 130
of the Courts
of Justice Act and set the prejudgment interest rate at three percent.
The first
of these was that the trial judge had not carried out an adequate balancing
exercise before
exercising his
discretion, in particular in failing to take account
of the potential risk to L
of giving evidence reliving the abuse if, in fact, it had occurred.
There is bound to be an element
of uncertainty in the use
of the wide discretionary powers
given to the court under the 1973 Act, and no doubt there always will be, because as social circumstances change so the court will have to adapt the ways in which it
exercises discretion.»
(a) Title 38 U.S.C. § 3107 (a)(2), which
gives the VA discretionary authority to apportion disability compensation on behalf
of a veteran's children, is not an exclusive grant
of authority to the VA to order that child support be paid from disability benefits, and does not indicate that
exercise of the VA's
discretion could yield independent child support determinations in conflict with existing state court orders.
In the case
of Watson & Ors v Watchfinder.co.uk Ltd, the High Court considered a provision in an option agreement which purported to
give the board complete
discretion over whether an option could be
exercised.
If this amendment is to
give the Minister any
discretion not to issue an invitation to apply for recognition to the incumbent representative body, the
exercise of that
discretion should be equivalent to, and require the same procedure as, the
discretion to withdraw recognition;