• The benefits provided by
existing voucher programs are sometimes large, but are usually more modest in size.
The position of the Democratic nominee for governor is to allow
the existing voucher programs in Milwaukee and Racine but to block statewide expansion of the program.
With both the House and Senate having passed their respective education bills, NSBA remains steadfast in working with lawmakers on both sides of the aisle to pass a final bill that restores community ownership to local school boards, maximizes federal funding for Title I, and excludes private vouchers, tuition tax credits, or
existing voucher programs.
«Many
existing voucher programs are limited in the number and type of students they're allowed to serve and the amount of choice they're allowed to offer.
First, does the actual documented track record of
existing voucher programs demonstrate that those programs in fact achieved the desired goal of enhancing student achievement?
Meanwhile, also on Monday, studies of two
existing voucher programs in Louisiana and Indiana were released showing that after an initial backslide, students receiving vouchers make up ground and perform roughly as well as their public school peers after a few years.
Indiana Governor Mitch Daniels has pushed the hardest, enacting a law that removes the cap on the number of charter schools in his state, authorizes all universities to register charters and expands
an existing voucher program in the state for students to attend private and charter schools (in some cases managed by for - profit companies).
Not exact matches
Trying to compare poverty in the 1960s to poverty today using the official measure yields misleading results; it implies that
programs like SNAP, the EITC, and rental
vouchers — all of which were either small in the 1960s or didn't yet
exist — have no effect in reducing poverty, which clearly is not the case.
While
voucher, tuition tax credit, and education savings - account
programs have been successful in filling excess capacity in
existing private schools, they have not led to widespread scaling of high - quality school models or to the creation of new, high - quality schools.
Research on the effect of
existing private school
voucher programs has not shown significant achievements for students in those
programs, the report asserts.
In addition to legal challenges, opponents of special education
vouchers are beginning to advance political and educational arguments against the idea as new
programs are being considered in states such as Texas, Pennsylvania, North Carolina, and South Carolina, and the
existing Ohio
program is poised to expand.
A useful opportunity
exists here to explore differences between «long stayers» and «short stayers,» which may improve our understanding of which kinds of students benefit from
voucher programs.
Even if most of the private schools participating in a
voucher program are religious, as long as some viable options
exist within the public school system, the genuine choice requirement should be satisfied.
The problem, at least for policymakers who might be looking to
existing programs as they consider instituting
vouchers, is that White and Blaufuss might both be right.
Both the Louisiana and Indiana
voucher programs exist with strong school accountability environments, but that doesn't necessarily mean accountability is the key.
For example, research on a privately funded school
voucher program in New York City provides some evidence in favor of a link
existing between test scores and longer - term outcomes, where
vouchers raised test score gains and increased the likelihood of graduating from high school and enrolling in college.
Furthermore, by dismantling the Title I funding formula, not only would public schools and students in poverty be harmed, but portability would also allow the dollars to be more easily transferred to private schools to either create a
voucher or to be combined with
existing state
voucher programs.
Most
voucher programs lack accountability measures, and according to studies of
voucher programs, many also lack proper oversight to ensure they meet even the minimal standards that do
exist.
Existing research on other conventional school
voucher programs point to a number of problems, including: lower student performance, less accountability, reduced access and increased segregation.
One might expect special education
voucher programs — as
exist in Florida, Ohio, and Wisconsin — to provide the best guarantees for students with disabilities.
This report is based on a «meta - analysis» — a study that examines all of the
existing research and examines the overall findings — of the research literature on private school choice
programs, including
vouchers and tax credit scholarships, from around the world.
The missions of NCPE's member organizations greatly vary, yet we are united in our position that Congress should not expand
existing or create new federal
voucher programs.
One of the sole pillars of the public education plan from President Donald Trump and Secretary of Education nominee Betsy DeVos is to divert $ 20 billion from
existing federal education
programs to create a nationwide school
voucher program.
Liz Hill, a DeVos spokeswoman, said later Wednesday that panel members had asked questions about a
voucher program that doesn't
exist yet and about topics not covered under federal law.
It doesn't make sense to start a new
program at taxpayer expense (
vouchers) when the
existing system is hemmoraging.
The GI Bill, Pell Grants, student loans, both Presidents Bush, President Trump, the 25 states that allow parents to choose among public and private schools, Congress with its passage of the Washington, D.C.
voucher program, 45 U.S. senators who voted in 2015 to allow states to use
existing federal dollars for
vouchers, Betsy DeVos — or her senate critics?
We must speak out and end these
existing creationist
voucher programs.
Informing parents about how and when they can enroll their children in
voucher schools seems like a pretty «legitimate educational purpose» given that
voucher programs have
existed in Milwaukee since 1990, in Racine since 2011 and statewide since 2013, and the Republicans who control state government are thinking about expanding
voucher availability again.
In reality,
voucher programs expand and supplement
existing rights under IDEA and result in greater accountability to students and increased parental satisfaction (Greene & Forster, 2003).
They want to cut $ 10.6 billion from
existing programs and divert $ 1.4 billion to charter schools and to
vouchers for private and religious schools.
Daniels also expanded the already
existing Scholarship Tax Credit
Program that gives tax credits to companies and individuals who make donations to «scholarship» organizations that, in turn, provide
vouchers.
Title I «portability» proposals want to dismantle the
existing program and turn it into a private school
voucher: the money to help these public schools would instead «follow the child» to private schools.
A variety of school choice options
exist today including tuition
vouchers, private scholarship
programs, and charter schools, which provide an alternative to the cookie - cutter district school model.
«The argument is that if we take monies by way of
vouchers from the
existing school corporations then we hurt their
programs.
Mychal Thom, head of Concordia Lutheran High School in Fort Wayne, estimated that at least half of his school's 366
voucher recipients last year would have enrolled at Concordia even if the
voucher program did not
exist.
IES's study of the D.C.
voucher program is an important addition to
existing voucher research.
In other states, the launch and expansion of
voucher programs should be used by school choice supporters as an opportunity to team up with school data quality activists such as the Data Quality Campaign to push for the overhaul of
existing data systems and the launch of new, more - comprehensive systems.
Most
voucher programs lack accountability measures, and according to studies of
voucher programs, many also lack proper oversight to ensure they meet the minimal standards that do
exist.
The proposal would change the
existing voucher funding system, which Vos proposed and was implemented for the first time this year after lawmakers revamped the system and removed the
program's enrollment cap in the 2015 - 17 budget.