With that background, I'll take you quickly through my ratings of the internal and
external validity of the studies that have been most frequently cited in the debate on the Obama administration's proposal for Preschool for All and related efforts.
However, purposive selection of study site does leave a question on
the external validity of the study for whole Nepal.
Not exact matches
We matched ResQu items to domains identified by these authors as critical to
study quality, internal and
external validity, and standard
of reporting.
The authors say: «It is possible that either AET, RT or CT may be easier to perform effectively without supervision, thus affecting the
external validity of these results since only
studies with supervised training were included.»
The
studies [xi]
of the Georgia and Oklahoma universal pre-k programs get the highest grade for
external validity because the programs in these two states have been held up by President Obama and others as models to be replicated across the nation.
This
study provides the strongest evidence available on the greater return on investment
of targeted preschool interventions in contrast to universal programs in which money is spent on all children, with the limitations on
external validity I've described.
These
studies also are weak with regards to
external validity because the research design does not permit a determination
of whether the pre-k program improves performance in elementary school — the control group begins to receive the pre-k program just after the children are initially tested, which means there is no untreated control group with which to benchmark performance in kindergarten and thereafter.
The
studies of the Georgia and Oklahoma universal pre-k programs get the highest grade for
external validity because the programs in these two states have been held up by President Obama and others as models to be replicated across the nation.
Not one
of the
studies that has suggested long - term positive impacts
of center - based early childhood programs has been based on a well - implemented and appropriately analyzed randomized trial, and nearly all have serious limitations in
external validity.
In contrast, the only two
studies in the list with both high internal and
external validity (Head Start Impact and Tennessee) find null or negative impacts, and all
of the
studies that point to very small, null, or negative effects have high
external validity.
The
study has very little
external validity, which is a polite way
of saying its findings shouldn't be generalized to other contexts.
The researchers acknowledge three specific limitations in this
study: challenges with
validity and
external reliability
of the authentic instruction rating scale, missing data due to fluctuations in teacher participation during the duration
of the
study, and the inability to account for a variety
of variables that may impact
study outcomes due to the limited time frame and scope
of the program in which the
study took place
The purpose
of this paper is to review the evidence base for three widely - used home visiting programs that have met the federal criteria for evidence - based to highlight the limits to both the internal and
external validity of the evidence and to provide a case
study as a point
of comparison using data from a large, statewide implementation effort.
This article presents three
studies examining the internal and
external validity of GOALS and the stability
of life goals over a period
of two years.
The results
of the three
studies confirm that the life goal questionnaire GOALS possesses high internal und
external validity.
Second, only 17 %
of applicants could be included in the
study, which might limit the
external validity of the present findings.
An analysis
of the mall
study shows that beyond the
external misrepresentations, internal scientific methodological errors cast doubt on the
validity of the claims that have been attributed to the mall
study within scholarly and legal arenas.
Interestingly, the promising
external validity of the FEEL - KJ has now also received support from two other
studies in which relations were shown with binge eating [15], depressive symptoms [14,15], and with the DSM symptom clusters affective problems, somatic problems, conduct problems, and ADHD problems [14].
The strengths
of the
study include: a naturalistic setting, which increases the
external validity of the findings, a multimethod assessment
of two outcomes (parenting and child problem behavior), availability
of four data points, minimal attrition across waves, and LGM analyses that specified and tested a theoretically based potential mediator
of program effects.
Compared with prior research, our
study significantly expands inquiry in this area by broadening the range
of social participation indicators examined, increasing the
external validity of findings, focusing on the under -
studied developmental stage
of adolescence, and taking an ecological approach that included many potential correlates
of social participation.
In summary, compared with prior research, our
study significantly expands inquiry in this area by broadening the range
of social participation indicators examined, by increasing the
external validity of findings, by focusing on the under -
studied developmental stage
of adolescence, and by taking an ecological approach that included many potential correlates
of social participation.
«As with all
studies that focus on usefully unusual settings, there is a question
of generalizability and
external validity.