As we learned during our series on abuse in the church, cases of
fabricated allegations of child abuse are quite rare, so when this many consistent counts are leveled against an organization, we should be wary of jumping to the defense of the accused and treating the alleged victims as liars.
Not exact matches
[37] A key feature
of the Director's conduct in this case is that she and many
of her agents approached the case in front
of them with a closed mind, having concluded at a very early stage, before the
children were interviewed, that there was no merit to the sexual
abuse allegations and that J.P. had
fabricated them and had coached her
children to make their disclosures.
Moreover, women's anger specifically is very faux pas and «unmotherly», so when they make
allegations of child abuse, it is stereotyped to be passive aggressive and
fabricated.
[F] athers most frequently make intentionally false reports [while] mothers and
children [are the] least likely to
fabricate reports
of abuse or neglect... [D] eliberate fabrication
of abuse by custodial parents is relatively low, alleviating the concerns that there is a widespread problem
of custodial parents trying to manipulate the legal system or seek vengeance against their former partners... diverting attention from the more prevalent problems
of unsubstantiated
allegations made in good faith and unresolved investigations where suspicions
of abuse or neglect remain but can not be confirmed.
Gardner, R. A. (1989) «Differentiating Between Bona Fide and
Fabricated Allegations of Sexual
Abuse of Children.»
Of the intentionally false allegations of maltreatment... custodial parents (usually mothers) and children [are] least likely to fabricate reports of abuse or neglect.&raqu
Of the intentionally false
allegations of maltreatment... custodial parents (usually mothers) and children [are] least likely to fabricate reports of abuse or neglect.&raqu
of maltreatment... custodial parents (usually mothers) and
children [are] least likely to
fabricate reports
of abuse or neglect.&raqu
of abuse or neglect.»
The PAS criteria used by Gardner, as noted above, are essentially borrowed from and built upon his earlier (and now widely discredited) test for determining whether
children were
fabricating allegations of sexual
abuse, the «Sexual Abuse Legitimacy Scale» (SAL Scale)
abuse, the «Sexual
Abuse Legitimacy Scale» (SAL Scale)
Abuse Legitimacy Scale» (SAL Scale)(Id.)
Differentiating between bona fide and
fabricated allegations of sexual
abuse of children.