Sentences with phrase «fatally flawed papers»
Benestad still cites what he knows to be a fatally flawed paper.
http://www.climate-resistance.org/ Not exact matches
To ensure that the papers were both fatally flawed and credible submissions, two independent groups of molecular biologists at Harvard University volunteered to be virtual peer reviewers.
How can I be feel that the Common Core State Standards for Mathematics (CCSSM) are a step forward and yet criticize the Smarter Balanced tests as harshly as I have done in the paper «The Smarter Balanced Common Core Tests for Mathematics Are Fatally Flawed and Should Not Be Used»?
We'd only remind them, and the journal, that a publication is a publication, whether it's online or in print, so if this paper turns out to be fatally flawed, it would need to be retracted and not simply disappear.
«Both [Fall et al. 2011 and Menne et al. 2010](and cited by Muller et al) do an analysis over a thirty year time period while the Muller et al paper uses data for comparison from 1950 — 2010... I see this as a basic failure in understanding the limitations of the siting survey we conducted on the USHCN, rendering the Muller et al paper conclusions highly uncertain, if not erroneous... I consider the paper fatally flawed as it now stands, and thus I recommend it be removed from publication consideration by JGR until such time that it can be reworked... it appears they have circumvented the scientific process in favor of PR.»
I don't see why everybody is arguing over human issues (which have a way of never getting resolved) when statistically Briffa's paper is fatally flawed.
The Gergis team in Australia has been awarded what is said to be a top prize in Australian science (the «Eureka Prize») for the work that includes that fatally flawed, withdrawn, and never — seen - again paper that had been shredded by Jean S and Steve Mc, et al., at Climate Audit.
Most papers on sunspots are fatally flawed.