After a real estate profession overturned
a finding of professional misconduct on appeal to the court, the professional sued the regulatory body for malicious prosecution.
The Law Society of Upper Canada's tribunal has refused to license as a paralegal a former justice of the peace, who was removed from the bench following
a finding of professional misconduct.
Sandeman v Council of the Law Society of Scotland 2011 S.C. 596: opposition to appeal against
finding of professional misconduct.
Campbell Riddell Breeze Paterson v. Council of the Law Society [2007] CSIH 1 Inner House; Solicitors» Disciplinary Proceedings; Appeal against
finding of professional misconduct from the Scottish Solicitors» Discipline Tribunal.
It is not necessary for conduct to be «dishonourable, disgraceful, blatant or cavalier» (paragraph 32) in order to make
a finding of professional misconduct or unprofessional conduct.
The bulk of the Panel's decision focused not on
the finding of professional misconduct, but rather on the issue of whether the 4 month suspension proposed by the Law Society and Ms. Robidoux was the appropriate sanction.
There is good reason to limit Tribunal panels to consider only
findings of professional misconduct by prior panels.
There was a time when our regulatory process was so lawyer - centric that even prosecutions and
findings of professional misconduct were not transparent.
HAMALENGWA —
Findings of Professional Misconduct — While representing a difficult client who was charged with first degree murder, the Lawyer was eligible to bill the Ministry of the Attorney General for fees and disbursements pursuant to a Fisher order — The Lawyer's accounting, billing and docketing systems were deplorable and bore no relationship to his billings to the Ministry — The Lawyer engaged in professional misconduct by billing the Ministry for attendances at court when he had not attended or attended for less time than he claimed; overbilling for legal research; billing for services that were not properly billable as legal services; overbilling for student assistance disbursements he had not incurred; overbilling for fees and disbursements that were not fair and reasonable; and submitting a document to the Ministry purporting to be an invoice from a student working under his direction when the invoice was not prepared by the student and the services were not rendered as described in the document.
[10] The court, confirmed, however, that the committee having concerns did not amount to
findings of professional misconduct, or findings of fact or credibility.
The necessity of such immunity (as well as the limits of such immunity where a plaintiff alleges bad faith conduct) is illustrated in the Ontario case of Deep v. College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario, 2010 ONSC 5248 (September 23, 2010), where the College revoked the claimant's certificate of registration based on
findings of professional misconduct and incompetence.
(A successful appeal by Marc Beaumont for a Barrister against 5
findings of professional misconduct; signing a statement of truth and serving a pleading are not «the conduct of litigation;» meaning of, «discreditable to a Barrister;» trial panel gave no oral or written reasons for decision, nor did it allow any closing speech by the defence; gross breaches of natural justice; Chair of trial panel only honorary QC; not authorised to sit)
Ng Ariss Fong has established precedent - setting cases concerning the necessity of mental culpability for
findings of professional misconduct in BC, the right of professionals to maintain anonymity during appeal processes, errors in reasoning by tribunals, and public interest factors bearing on name publication decisions.
That was one of the issues in a Law Society Tribunal case in which the panel made
findings of professional misconduct against a Whitby, Ont., lawyer who acted for a client in her matrimonial dispute.
Not exact matches
Condon's own investigation said the
findings of misconduct against Fisher were based on faulty evidence and «inaccurate conclusions» that «did not meet
professional standards.»
The paper inflamed public fears about vaccines, but it was retracted in 2010 after the UK General Medical Council (GMC) concluded that Wakefield had a charge
of serious
professional misconduct to answer, in part because it
found that his team did not have proper ethical approval for tests performed on the children.
The CTC, mandated under state law to serve as the arbiter
of professional integrity and quality for California's teachers, was the subject
of a critical audit released in early 2011 that
found a backlog
of thousands
of unprocessed teacher
misconduct complaints that state officials said may have exposed some students to unsafe classroom conditions.
The Disciplinary Board
found she violated Rules
of Professional Conduct regarding impartiality, decorum
of the tribunal, and
misconduct.
A majority
of the Committee
found insufficient evidence for
professional misconduct.
But in Hughes v. Board
of Professional Responsibility (PDF), the Tennessee Supreme Court
found that his prior
misconduct, combined with his felony convictions, demonstrated «a pattern
of behavior over a period
of years that conflicts with the standards
of the bar, the sanctity
of our judicial system and the public trust.
According to Ryan's lawyer, the crucial piece
of evidence this time around was a psychiatric assessment which
found that Ryan's prior «
misconduct» was out
of character with how he conducted both his personal and
professional life.
Moore - Bick LJ, giving the leading judgment identified the primary issue as being «whether a person who suffers damage as a result
of findings of personal or
professional misconduct leading to dismissal and loss
of professional status that were made against him in disciplinary proceedings conducted in breach
of contract, but which would not otherwise have been made, can recover damages at large».
«(i) that in matters
of personal conduct he would be subject to the hospital's general procedures and that in matters
of professional conduct he would be subject to a procedure agreed by the Local Negotiating Committee in respect
of medical practitioners; (ii) that he was accused by the Trust
of personal and
professional misconduct; (iii) that because
of the nature
of the allegations made against him he was contractually entitled to a formal disciplinary hearing by a panel which included a clinician
of the same discipline as himself and a legally qualified chairman, before which he would have the benefit
of legal representation, if he so wished; (iv) that the disciplinary hearing which resulted in the
findings of misconduct was not conducted in accordance with the terms
of his contract
of employment because the panel did not include a clinician
of the same discipline as himself, nor a legally qualified chairman and because his request to be allowed legal representation was refused; (iv) that following the panel's
findings he was dismissed for personal and
professional misconduct; (v) that if the proceedings had been carried out in accordance with his contract
of employment the panel would not have
found that he was guilty
of personal and
professional misconduct and he would not have been dismissed; (vii) that because he was dismissed on the grounds
of personal and
professional misconduct (including dishonesty) he has been unable to
find comparable alternative employment» [at para 10]:
A subsequent three - member LSBC hearing panel
found Johnson's use
of the expletive constituted
professional misconduct in the sense that it was a marked departure
of what the law society expects from its members.
After investigation, the Trust
found Wasteney guilty
of serious
misconduct, namely the blurring
of professional boundaries and the subjection
of a junior colleague to improper pressure and unwanted conduct.
But if the individual clicks through to the result they will
find this lawyer has never been accused
of professional misconduct.
But if you need to be convinced, consider that failing to notify your liability insurer
of a potential claim could have consequences beyond potential coverage issues under the policy, including the possibility that you could be
found guilty
of professional misconduct.
The Court upheld a decision
of The Law Society
of Manitoba's Discipline Panel
finding a lawyer guilty
of professional misconduct for, inter alia, failing to give notice to the Director
of Insurance
of the Law Society as soon as practicable after becoming aware
of any acts or omissions that might give rise to a claim.
But in October 2013, a law society hearing panel said it had no evidence to
find the pair guilty
of professional misconduct.
Joseph Farkas was
found guilty
of professional misconduct last year after a disciplinary tribunal
found he had failed to supervise his non-lawyer staff when dealing with his clients» claims.
If
found guilty
of professional misconduct, Groia could face sanctions ranging from a reprimand to losing his licence to practise law.
While he
found it would be almost impossible to create an exact formula for determining when a lawyer has committed
professional misconduct in the courtroom and agreed that it should be up to the Law Society to determine when
misconduct took place, he did offer a set
of basic principles that could be applied when trying to make a determination
of in - court
misconduct.
Its position was that he had already been
found guilty
of professional misconduct by the higher courts that heard the OSC appeal and that all the law society had to do was «rubber stamp his conviction and sentence him,» Groia says in his factum.
Still, Doré himself was
found by a disciplinary council
of his province's Bar Association to have engaged in
professional misconduct, based on the letter to the judge which was deemed «rude and insulting».
As illustrated in the Farbeh case, conclusions
of professional misconduct must be supported by
findings in reasons that support such conclusions: Farbeh v. College
of Pharmacists
of British Columbia, 2011 BCSC 1676.
Accountancy
professionals may also
find themselves the subject
of regulatory and disciplinary proceedings if an allegation
of misconduct is made against them in criminal or civil proceedings.
Nevertheless, the judge
found the appeal panel's test for measuring potential
professional misconduct — that counsel must not impugn their opponents unless they make their allegations in good faith and on a reasonable basis — «fails to go far enough to protect the importance
of zealous advocacy.»
The Law Society
found that all
of these actions constituted
professional misconduct.
Writing for a three - judge panel, Justice Ian Nordheimer
found «the decision
of the Appeal Panel that the appellant had engaged in
professional misconduct is a reasonable one.»
Admission or proof
of the alleged
professional misconduct (or incompetence) is not the same as a plea or
finding of guilt in a criminal matter.
... We have not
found any instances
of professional misconduct for this lawyer.»
Peirovy was
found guilty by the panel last July
of «acts
of professional misconduct in that he engaged in the sexual abuse»
of four patients.
Similarly, a complainant may seek to use, in court, any disciplinary
findings that certain acts
of negligence amount to
professional misconduct (although this possibility has existed since before this HPRB decision).
The Discipline Committee Panel
found Dr. Leering guilty
of professional misconduct for sexual abuse and revoked his certificate
of registration.
Mallon v General Medical Council 2007 SC 426: opposition to appeal by General Practitioner following
finding of serious
professional misconduct — first Scottish GMC appeal.
a) A lawyer will not accept a nomination, for appointment to «Her Majesty's Counsel» (Q.C.), having been
found guilty
of professional conduct («unfit») and / or while under investigation («disqualified») for allegations
of professional misconduct.
The Law Society; in their custodial duties as regulators (advisory committee to AG on Q.C. appointments), must submit the names
of lawyers nominated and / or appointed, to the Attorney General, who have been
found guilty
of professional misconduct and / or who are currently under investigation for allegations
of professional misconduct.
«Professor Meadow did not simply quote statistics from a government publication; rather, whether by negligence or ignorance, he misquoted; the
finding of serious
professional misconduct was not rejected by the High Court; rather the court felt the sanction
of being struck off was too severe.
53.1 In an appropriate case, a panel may make an order requiring a member who the panel
finds has committed an act
of professional misconduct or
finds to be incompetent to pay all or part
of the following costs and expenses:
71.1 Section 71 also applies to an order made by a panel
of the Discipline Committee because
of a
finding that a member has committed sexual abuse
of the kind described in paragraph 3
of subsection 51 (5) or an act
of professional misconduct described in subsection 51 (5.2).