Some of these changes are significant
for decadal variability of surface temperature.
In a recent paper, Sanchez - Franks and Zhang show that the underlying physical driver
for the decadal variability in the Gulf Stream path and the regional biogeochemical cycling is linked to the low - frequency variability of the large - scale ocean circulation in the Atlantic, also known as Atlantic meridional overturning circulation (AMOC).
They write in their abstract: «The Pacific decadal oscillation (PDO), defined as the leading empirical orthogonal function of North Pacific sea surface temperature anomalies, is a widely used index
for decadal variability.
Not exact matches
A study led by scientists at the GEOMAR Helmholtz Centre
for Ocean Research Kiel shows that the ocean currents influence the heat exchange between ocean and atmosphere and thus can explain climate
variability on
decadal time scales.
Rainfall during the Indian monsoon season, which runs from June to September and accounts
for about 70 % of annual rainfall, exhibits
decadal variability.
Nate, a member of the FI Board of Directors, is the leader
for the Landscape Ecology Team at NOAA's Southwest Fisheries Science Center, and has expertise about
decadal - scale climate
variability and ecosystem regime shifts.
We quantify the interannual - to -
decadal variability of the heat content (mean temperature) of the world ocean from the surface through 3000 - meter depth
for the period 1948 to 1998.
Despite large year - to - year
variability of temperature,
decadal averages reveal isotherms (lines of a given average temperature) moving poleward at a typical rate of the order of 100 km / decade in the past three decades [101], although the range shifts
for specific species follow more complex patterns [102].
He took two indices of interannual
variability: the Southern Oscillation (SOI) index, which is a proxy
for El Nino, and the Pacific
Decadal Oscillation Index (PDOI).
Periods that are of possibly the most interest
for testing sensitivities associated with uncertainties in future projections are the mid-Holocene (
for tropical rainfall, sea ice), the 8.2 kyr event (
for the ocean thermohaline circulation), the last two millennia (
for decadal / multi-
decadal variability), the last interglacial (
for ice sheets / sea level) etc..
Mike's work, like that of previous award winners, is diverse, and includes pioneering and highly cited work in time series analysis (an elegant use of Thomson's multitaper spectral analysis approach to detect spatiotemporal oscillations in the climate record and methods
for smoothing temporal data),
decadal climate
variability (the term «Atlantic Multidecadal Oscillation» or «AMO» was coined by Mike in an interview with Science's Richard Kerr about a paper he had published with Tom Delworth of GFDL showing evidence in both climate model simulations and observational data
for a 50 - 70 year oscillation in the climate system; significantly Mike also published work with Kerry Emanuel in 2006 showing that the AMO concept has been overstated as regards its role in 20th century tropical Atlantic SST changes, a finding recently reaffirmed by a study published in Nature), in showing how changes in radiative forcing from volcanoes can affect ENSO, in examining the role of solar variations in explaining the pattern of the Medieval Climate Anomaly and Little Ice Age, the relationship between the climate changes of past centuries and phenomena such as Atlantic tropical cyclones and global sea level, and even a bit of work in atmospheric chemistry (an analysis of beryllium - 7 measurements).
Our best armory
for the arguments you fear quite rightly is to build up our understanding of
decadal variability and the extent to which it can cloud the long term trend.
There is
decadal and multi-
decadal variability in each of these reconstructions, but such
variability arises from and is accounted
for in different ways (refer to Calafat et al., 2014
for a related discussion).
The model used in Hansen et al (2005)
for instance, does not have a good representation of ENSO
variability — conceivably leading to this underestimate of
decadal variability, but other models do a better job and it would be good to see what their
variability looked like in this metric.
«The forecast
for global mean temperature which we published highlights the ability of natural
variability to cause climate fluctuations on
decadal scale, even on a global scale.
In some models, the
decadal variability for monsoons such as the South Asian monsoon also outweighs the magnitude of the future trends, and in others it does not (the review above is one example showing this).
These factors driving the present changes of the NHSM system are instrumental
for understanding and predicting future
decadal changes and determining the proportions of climate change that are attributable to anthropogenic effects and long - term internal
variability in the complex climate system.
``... My comments quoted above refer very specifically to the potential
for global models to give more precise probability distributions of outcomes at the regional and
decadal scales which are dominated by intrinsic interannual and interdecadal
variability.»
Indeed regionally, interannual and
decadal variability is still dominant in the climate record and will be
for a long time.
and J. Willebrand, J. (1996) «
Decadal Variability», Springer, NATO ASI series, volume 44; chapter: «Spectral Methods: What they Can and Can not Do
for Climate Times Series» by M. Ghil and P. Yiou
The paper... offers a useful framework
for which
decadal variations in the global (or northern hemisphere) may be explained via large scale modes of oceanic
variability.
However, my comments quoted above refer very specifically to the potential
for global models to give more precise probability distributions of outcomes at the regional and
decadal scales which are dominated by intrinsic interannual and interdecadal
variability.
(and over the next century,
decadal variability will give us wetter and drier periods imposed on, and maybe interacting with, a greenhouse signal) We don't know
for sure, and so we must try and assess the risks with the info we have at hand.
This criterion may not be satisfied if observations are available only over a short time period (as is the case
for the vertical structure of clouds), or if the predictor is defined through low - frequency
variability (trends,
decadal variability), or if there is a lack of consistency among available datasets (as in the case
for global - mean precipitation and surface fluxes).
The study by Macias & Johnson (2008) provides not only evidence
for the link between
decadal - scale changes in the teleconnection patterns (e.g. the Pacific Decadal Oscillation (PDO) index) and the increased fire frequency in the late twentieth century but also an explanation of why the pattern of fire variability and fire - climate relationships changes at different time scales from centennial / decadal to interannu
decadal - scale changes in the teleconnection patterns (e.g. the Pacific
Decadal Oscillation (PDO) index) and the increased fire frequency in the late twentieth century but also an explanation of why the pattern of fire variability and fire - climate relationships changes at different time scales from centennial / decadal to interannu
Decadal Oscillation (PDO) index) and the increased fire frequency in the late twentieth century but also an explanation of why the pattern of fire
variability and fire - climate relationships changes at different time scales from centennial /
decadal to interannu
decadal to interannual.....
The other forecasts, such as
for hurricanes, rainfall, and snow cover, are not significantly different than under natural
variability, and will advance more slowly than the
decadal oscillations.
(A) coordinate programs at the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration to ensure the timely production and distribution of data and information on global, national, regional, and local climate
variability and change over all time scales relevant
for planning and response, including intraseasonal, interannual,
decadal, and multidecadal time periods;
Roger could reply again by stating that models that don't show skill in projecting changing statistics can not be used
for this reasoning by simulation, but I remain to disgree with him: the skill of climate models to project changing climate statistics at
decadal time scales can formally not be established due to large role of natural
variability, but is also not always required
for generating useful information that enters the imagination process.
Noteworthy in the reconstructions are the post-1976 warm / wet period, unprecedented in the 1,425 - year record both in amplitude and duration, anomalous and prolonged late 20th century warmth, that while never exceeded, was nearly equaled in magnitude
for brief intervals in the past, and substantial
decadal - scale
variability within the Medieval Warm Period and Little Ice Age intervals.
Building on previous efforts, this three - day workshop will use the outcomes to guide synthesis efforts, coordinate on - going research to fill out key gaps, and provide specific recommendations
for accelerating scientific progress — with the aim to improve our understanding and predictability of 1) high - to mid-latitude climate
variability on subseasonal - to - seasonal and on interannual - to -
decadal timescales and 2) climate extremes.
Whether the faster rate
for 1993 to 2003 [3.1 mm / year] reflects
decadal variability or an increase in the longer - term trend is unclear.
Obviously you are not aware that the
decadal variability of ENSO is not in synch with the PDO: The graph is from this post: http://bobtisdale.wordpress.com/2011/06/30/yet-even-more-discussions-about-the-pacific-
decadal-oscillation-pdo/ The reasons
for the differences are of course due to the influence of sea level pressure on the PDO.
Good to see FOMBS so warmly embracing vigorous
decadal to cenntennial
variability and what that might imply
for the Arctic, the US, Alaska and parts of Europe.
Yes we really like observations in Earth sciences FOMBS — happy to see you are on board with vigourous
decadal variability for which a great deal of science exists.
To describe and understand the physical processes responsible
for climate
variability and predictability on seasonal, interannual,
decadal, and centennial time - scales, through the collection and analysis of observations and the development and application of models of the coupled climate system, in cooperation with other relevant climate - research and observing programmes.
«The authors write that North Pacific
Decadal Variability (NPDV) «is a key component in predictability studies of both regional and global climate change,»... they emphasize that given the links between both the PDO and the NPGO with global climate, the accurate characterization and the degree of predictability of these two modes in coupled climate models is an important «open question in climate dynamics» that needs to be addressed... report that model - derived «temporal and spatial statistics of the North Pacific Ocean modes exhibit significant discrepancies from observations in their twentieth - century climate... conclude that «
for implications on future climate change, the coupled climate models show no consensus on projected future changes in frequency of either the first or second leading pattern of North Pacific SST anomalies,» and they say that «the lack of a consensus in changes in either mode also affects confidence in projected changes in the overlying atmospheric circulation.»»
Understanding the
variability of the Gulf Stream path at
decadal and longer timescales is crucial
for predicting future physical and biogeochemical variations in this region.
Further, AMOC - induced
decadal variability in chlorophyll and nutrient concentrations in the Gulf Stream region might be important
for changes in the localized carbon cycle and fisheries at
decadal timescales.
For example, there is
decadal variability from the solar cycle, many posit large non-anthropogenic
variability due to AMO, etc..
Variations in the Atlantic Multi-
decadal Oscillation (see Section 3.6.6
for a more detailed discussion) could account
for some of the evolution of global and hemispheric mean temperatures during the instrumental period (Schlesinger and Ramankutty, 1994; Andronova and Schlesinger, 2000; Delworth and Mann, 2000); Knight et al. (2005) estimate that variations in the Atlantic Multi-
decadal Oscillation could account
for up to 0.2 °C peak - to - trough
variability in NH mean
decadal temperatures.
Develop a framework
for understanding
decadal variability through metrics that can be used as a strategy to assess and validate
decadal climate predictions simulations.
For example, while El Niño or El Niño - like
decadal variability results in unusually warm annual temperatures, the spatial pattern associated with such a warming is more structured, with cooling in the North Pacific and South Pacific (see, e.g., Zhang et al., 1997).
Exactly, but using good numbers not a «hotchpotch assembly»
for which it is claimed to be global temperature (there is no such thing, there is global energy content, but that is totally different story) So calculate correlation CET - GT from 1880 using 5 year bin averaging http://www.vukcevic.talktalk.net//CETGNH.htm P.S. your statement on natural
variability on
decadal scale is grossly misleading, you got about 130 years of good records so you need to look at multi-
decadal picture.
US CLIVAR
Decadal Predictability Working Group, 2011: Distinguishing the roles of natural and anthropogenically forced decadal climate variability: Implications for prediction
Decadal Predictability Working Group, 2011: Distinguishing the roles of natural and anthropogenically forced
decadal climate variability: Implications for prediction
decadal climate
variability: Implications
for prediction, Bull.
For myself, I've suggested that 2005 - 2025 is likely to be below 0.2; and specifically somewhere from 0.15 to 0.2, but that's a quick guess not a calculation, based on rough consideration of
decadal scale
variability /
Variability of the El Niño / La Niña cycle, described as a Pacific
Decadal Oscillation, largely accounts
for the temporary decrease of warming [18], as we discuss further below in conjunction with global temperature simulations.
Despite large year - to - year
variability of temperature,
decadal averages reveal isotherms (lines of a given average temperature) moving poleward at a typical rate of the order of 100 km / decade in the past three decades [101], although the range shifts
for specific species follow more complex patterns [102].
A 35 - year dust record established from Barbados surface dust and satellite observations from TOMS and the European geostationary meteorological satellite (Meteosat) show the importance of climate control and Sahel drought
for interannual and
decadal dust
variability, with no overall trend yet documented (Chiapello et al., 2005).
«However, if the anthropogenic signal has mulit -
decadal variability (and it does in the GCMs —
for instance in Miller et al (2014), fig 7), then this process will remove that component.»
A natural
variability of no more than + / - 0.1 C is invoked
for this effect, which is not much in the long term expected 2 - 4 C or so, but it can modify shorter term
decadal trends.