The early identification of risk
for grade retention among African American children at risk for school difficulty
A lot of people don't realize there are tremendous economic costs, because of suspensions increase your dropout risk or risk
for grade retention.
Low - income students are at increased risk
for grade retention and suspension, which dampens their chances of high school graduation, college attendance, and future success.
In particular, I examine 1) whether a child was below grade for age while still of school age (a proxy
for grade retention); 2) three indicators of adult educational attainment (high school dropout, high school degree only, and some college); 3) adult wage and salary earnings and indicators of employment and receipt of public assistance income; and 4) an indicator for residence in institutionalized group quarters, a widely used proxy for incarceration.
Not exact matches
Providing your child with opportunities
for success can prevent the stigma of
grade retention from affecting your child.
For the first time, researchers in the College of Education and Human Development at Texas A&M University have provided the strongest evidence to date that
grade retention in the elementary
grades hurts students» chances of graduating high school.
Participating children had higher rates of high - school completion, lower rates of
grade retention and special education placement, and a lower rate of juvenile arrests.32 Another example showing more intensive programming has larger impacts is the Healthy Steps evaluation showing significantly better child language outcomes when the program was initiated prenatally through 24 months.33 These studies suggest that a more intensive intervention involving the child directly may be required
for larger effects to be seen.
North Carolina's investment in early child care and education programs resulted in higher test scores, less
grade retention and fewer special education placements through fifth
grade, research from the Duke Center
for Child and Family Policy finds.
Preliminary data show that 4 percent to 5 percent of the 500,000 students tested failed the examination, which is used to screen pupils
for summer remedial programs and possible
grade retention.
Classroom behavior,
grades, and attendance were all given a more prominent role in the
retention decision, and an appeals process was, in theory at least, implemented
for parents who wanted to dispute a
retention decision — in part the result of an agreement with the U.S. Office
for Civil Rights that was brought on by the 1999 PURE lawsuit.
At the same time that thousands of school districts nationwide are beginning to implement the Common Core State Standards in English / language arts, many also face new state reading policies
for the early
grades that call
for the identification of struggling readers, require interventions to help them, and, in some instances, mandate the
retention of 3rd graders who lack adequate reading skills.
Second, if states wanted to try to make vesting more of a
retention incentive, they could offer teachers a «
graded» vesting system, where workers are eligible
for a growing share of their employer's retirement contributions over time.
I find evidence that state funding of universal kindergarten lowered high - school dropout and institutionalization rates among whites, but not among African Americans, and detect no impact of state funding
for children of either race on
grade retention, public assistance receipt, employment or earnings.
The high performers aren't twiddling their thumbs and the low performers aren't headed
for remediation or
grade retention because their time to master the material is up.
Because the state has not yet identified students
for retention, the test scores of students the first time they are in the 3rd
grade are not affected by any change in the student cohort resulting from the
retention policy.
Our fundamental findings from an analysis of the 3rd - and 4th -
grade data
for these two years indicate that the performance of students identified
for retention, regardless of whether they were retained or exempted and promoted, exceeded the performance of low - performing students from the previous year who were not subject to the
retention policy; and students who were actually retained made the larger relative gains.
The best way to answer the question is to look at changes in student test - score performance among those in 3rd
grade for the first time, as their test scores are unaffected by the
retention policy.
If the gains observed
for 4th graders were a function of differences in the type of students entering that
grade due to the
retention policy, then the performance of those entering 3rd
grade should look essentially the same after 2002 as it did before the
retention policy was put into place.
The motivation
for Mexican education reform is driven by high
grade retention, high dropout rates, and low test scores — even when compared with children from other Latin American countries.
Defined as perseverance and passion
for long - term goals, grit accounted
for an average of 4 percent of the variance in success outcomes, including educational attainment among two samples of adults;
grade point average among Ivy League undergraduates;
retention among two classes at the United States Military Academy, West Point; and ranking in the Scripps National Spelling Bee.
According to surveys conducted by the Attleboro Public Schools,
retention rates — holding students back — in
grades 2 - 8 decreased by more than 43 percent, special education referrals dropped by more than 55 percent, and discipline and suspensions — especially in the middle schools — declined significantly, while attendance rates improved
for both students and teachers.
Proponents of test - based promotion argue that the threat of
retention provides a powerful incentive
for educators to help students become strong readers by 3rd
grade, and that students who fall short could stand to benefit from an additional year of schooling.
The study also showed no discernible impact
for either group on many of the long - term outcomes desired by policymakers, including minimizing
grade retention and dependence on public assistance and positively impacting later employment and earnings.
One of the reasons
for lower
retention rates was improved 3rd -
grade performance on the state's examination.
The impact of
grade retention is comparable, too, though that intervention is pertinent only
for low - achieving students.
The Commission will examine factors in raising student achievement from prekindergarten through high school including: state accountability and curriculum requirements; model programs to improve student achievement beginning in early learning programs and continuing throughout high school; strategies
for every student to achieve at
grade level such as intervention and support systems; and policies to improve student attendance and
retention.
The authors demonstrate that the effects of high - stakes testing pro- grams on outcomes, such as
retention and graduation, are different from the results of using
grades alone, and that some groups of students who are already faring poorly, such as African Americans and Latinos / Latinas, will do even worse if high - stakes testing programs are used as criteria
for promotion and graduation.
Its purpose was to promote the usage of students» test scores to
grade and pay teachers annual bonuses (i.e., «supplements») as per their performance, and «provide a procedure
for observing and evaluating teachers» to help make other «significant differentiation [s] in pay,
retention, promotion, dismissals, and other staffing decisions, including transfers, placements, and preferences in the event of reductions in force, [as] primarily [based] on evaluation results.»
As amended, the law required, among various other provisions,
retention in
grade 3 with intensive interventions
for students who did not exhibit the requisite level of reading proficiency.
For example, in K.P. v. District of Columbia (2013), a federal district court rejected the parents» claim that the child's
retention in
grade based on truancy and academic failure proved that her IEP was not appropriate.
Similarly, while providing
for individualized determinations, the IDEA does not contain any absolute bar to retaining students with IEPs from
grade retention.
Before parents and teachers could react, unproven concepts such as a high stakes tests mandatory
grade retention,
for profit charter schools, vouchers, A-F school / district
grades and tying teacher evaluations to test scores were signed into law at a rapid pace.
In comparing the results of the Program
for International Student Assessment in 65 countries, OECD researchers found that differences among countries
grade -
retention trends could explain up to 15 percent of the variance among average scores on the 2009 PISA.
Chronic absenteeism in kindergarten, and even pre-K, can predict lower test scores, repeated patterns of poor attendance and
retention in later
grades, especially if the absences persist
for more than a year.
Clearly states have an interest in ensuring that any investments they make enable strong outcomes that produce the desired benefits of stronger learning and school success, along with savings from reduced needs
for special education,
grade retention, remediation, or dropping out.
Low expectations, disproportionate
grade -
retention rates, and low graduation rates
for ethnic minority or EL students
In -
grade retention has been linked to increased rates of disciplinary actions and limited access to rigorous educational programs
for students of color (Jimerson, et al., 2005).
Mississippi's governor, Phil Bryant,
for example, championed a third
grade literacy
retention law in 2013.
It is time
for 21st century educators, researchers and policymakers to abandon the argument regarding
grade retention versus social promotion.
According to the Education Commission of the States, 16 states plus Washington, D.C. have laws that require
retention for students not reading at a certain level by the end of third
grade.
The factors identified in the GAO report — that low - income students and high - mobility students are high - risk, that low achievement and
grade retention are precursors to leaving school — provide a guide
for what we need to do to improve high school completion rates.
Once students reach fourth
grade, it becomes virtually impossible
for retention to be a positive thing.
Chronic absenteeism in kindergarten, and even pre-K, can predict lower test scores, repeated patterns of poor attendance and
retention in later
grades, especially if the problem persists
for more than a year.
If you are not accountable
for whether they graduate or not, whether there is high
grade retention, or high rates of suspension or expulsion, then you pave the way
for a totally inefficient system even with good intentions of trying to raise test scores.
The study included a caveat: «Given the expense of
grade retention and the emotional toil
retention exacts on students, a finding of «no significant difference»
for retention on achievement calls into question the educational benefits of
grade retention policies.»
And in one of my favorite examples, an EdSector study of Florida high schools showed that state «report card»
grades of «A» and «D» failed to predict which high school did the best job of preparing graduates
for college: the «D» rated school was producing students with higher college
grades and
retention.
Studies of students who attend high - quality programs
for a significant period of time show improvements in academic performance and social competence, including better
grades, improved homework completion, higher scores on achievement tests, lower levels of
grade retention, improved behavior in school, increased competence and sense of self as a learner, better work habits, fewer absences from school, better emotional adjustment and relationships with parents, and a greater sense of belonging in the community.
As exposure to lead increases, so does student absenteeism,
retention in
grade and the need
for special education services.
The program's economic benefits in 2007 dollars exceeded costs, including increased earnings and tax revenues, averted costs related to crime and savings
for child welfare, special education and
grade retention.
The program had an estimated return on investment of $ 10
for every $ 1 spent due to savings from increased earnings, lower crime rates, reduced need
for child - abuse and neglect services, and K - 12 savings from reduced special education and
grade retention.