For years, battles
for school board control in high charter growth cities have revolved around unilateral opposition to charters or benign collaboration.
Not exact matches
Federal regulations serve as the baseline
for school nutrition programs thus allowing state governments and local
school boards an element of local
control.
Senate Republicans plan to cover a range of issues with mayoral
control, includnig student performance, graduation rates, and «the effectiveness of having a single person accountable
for the public
school system as compared to the previous community
board system.»
Senate Republicans plan to cover a range of issues with mayoral
control, including student performance, graduation rates, and «the effectiveness of having a single person accountable
for the public
school system as compared to the previous community
board system.»
A former
board member of the Rockefeller Institute of Government, Faso also served for three years as a member of the Control Board that worked to fix the financial and managerial issues of the City of Buffalo and its school sy
board member of the Rockefeller Institute of Government, Faso also served
for three years as a member of the
Control Board that worked to fix the financial and managerial issues of the City of Buffalo and its school sy
Board that worked to fix the financial and managerial issues of the City of Buffalo and its
school system.
Under her plan
for mayoral
control over Syracuse
schools, Lavine said she would pick
school board members with the advice and consent of the Syracuse Common Council.
They are joined by nonprofit leaders who have scrutinized DOE practices
for years, including under Mayor Michael Bloomberg, who first won mayoral
control of city
schools in 2002, ending the old
Board of Education system.
But most humiliating, he was granted mayoral
control of the city's
school system
for a mere year — meaning he's going to have to beg Albany yet again to let him stay in charge of city
schools, even though no rational person really believes New York City would be better off with the old
Board of Education.
Mayoral
control would eliminate
board members» need to run on party lines, better holding the mayor accountable
for the state of city
schools, Lavine said.
Mayor de Blasio, who has been pushing
for an extension of the mayoral
control law, expects similar battles from both sides if the community
school boards are reconstituted.
Cuomo made the announcement on the mayoral
control extension as part of a broader agreement on a range of issues, including an extension of state
control of the New York Racing Association, testing
for lead in
school drinking water and new flexibility
for charter
schools to allow them to switch to the
Board of Trustees of State University of New York
for oversight.
But that's exactly what is happening in this year's
School Board races, with different factions warring
for control.
The district has been fighting
for some time over funding, with the Orthodox Jewish -
controlled school board diverting funds to Yeshivas — religious private
schools that educate a minority of students — and away from the public
schools attended by a majority of students, many of whom are black and Latino.
With
control of the Buffalo
School Board at stake — or perhaps no five - member majority emerging — candidates already are scrambling for support in the May 3 election in which the six district seats on the nine - member board will be up for g
Board at stake — or perhaps no five - member majority emerging — candidates already are scrambling
for support in the May 3 election in which the six district seats on the nine - member
board will be up for g
board will be up
for grabs.
And there was the discordant thud last Wednesday night, when Assembly Speaker Carl Heastie, a Democrat, and Senate Majority Leader John Flanagan, a Republican, declared they were sending their members home without doing one of the few things that actually came with a deadline: extending mayoral
control for New York City's
schools, a system that both houses and parties view as a vast improvement over the old system of
board control.
It's true there is broad agreement that mayoral
control is a better governance system
for the city's 1,800
schools than the previous system of local
school board control.
On Wednesday the
Board of Education was reconstituted (with seven members, one appointed by each borough president and two by Bloomberg himself) and met
for a nine - minute session, wherein they voted to retain Joel Klein as
schools chancellor, and to disband themselves
for good if and when the State Senate (ever) passes mayoral
control for real.
For the JSCB's second phase, which will involve roughly $ 300 million in
school renovations, state legislators changed the mandated composition of the
board to give Miner and Contreras
control over its composition.
Cuomo's Five - Year Financial Plan keeps revenue sharing with local governments flat at a time when scores of local governments and
school districts are headed
for insolvency and a takeover by state
Control Boards.
Mayor de Blasio is on
board with the Assembly's plan to extend his
control of city
schools for three years, though he was jockeying
for seven years.
The
school boards group point out that its members» personnel costs are rising so rapidly - partly
for reasons out of their
control - that a tax cap would leave them collectively $ 3 billion short over the next four years.
Another candidate aligned with the Buffalo
School Board majority was knocked off the ballot Monday in the latest twist in a fierce contest
for control of the
board.The continued challenges to petitions of would - be candidates underscore the dramatic politics that make this an unusually tense election, drawing interest from political, labor and business factions not typical...
Another candidate aligned with the Buffalo
School Board majority was knocked off the ballot Monday in the latest twist in a fierce contest for control of the b
Board majority was knocked off the ballot Monday in the latest twist in a fierce contest
for control of the
boardboard.
The governor was quick not to answer a question last week about whether he'd like to change the way the state
Board of Regents is appointed, fueling speculation he'll use today's speech to call
for greater gubernatorial
control of
schools.
Spano, a Democrat who campaigned
for mayoral
control last year and even convinced the Senate majority conference to include the change in its state budget proposal, said the issue isn't as urgent
for him now because the city recently merged some of its administrative offices with the
school board.
Should the governor, Assembly and State Senate fail to reach a consensus by the month's end,
control of the city education system would revert to the old community
school boards — widely criticized
for their uneven, inefficient and decentralized structure.
The Hasidic -
controlled school board says the budget
for the public
schools is approaching destitution levels and they are therefore cutting out programs offered to the public
schools except perhaps
for your Common Core.
We supported the introduction of mayoral
control in 2002 because no one took responsibility
for our
schools under the old system of locally elected
school boards.
Mayor Michael R. White, along with an appointed nine - member
school board and a superintendent of his choosing, will take over the Cleveland
schools, returning the district to local
control for the first time in nearly 25 years.
Anyone thinking about centralized
control — federal or state — should volunteer
for a local
school board.
But, the jury concluded, the ulti0 mate responsibility
for the district's need to seek bankruptcy protection earlier this spring belonged to a
school board that failed to
control the district...
A columnist
for the Sacramento Bee goes further, charging that such «a fuzzy, nonspecific «accountability» system completely undermines the ability of parents, especially in poor communities, to demand improvement in underperforming
schools, including the creation of charter
schools to seize
control from
school boards, superintendents and their union allies.»
Chicagoans watched closely last week
for clues about the future of the city's
schools, as Mayor Richard M. Daley prepared to assume unprecedented
control over a big - city district through the appointment of a corporate - style
board.
«It's why I opposed
school boards and why I fought
for mayoral
control.»
The movement also includes proposals to give teachers more
control over the profession through independent, state - level standard - setting
boards and to give the National Council
for the Accreditation of Teacher Education, the body that accredits education
schools, more
control over the number and origin of undergraduate degrees granted in education each year.
As a result, the legal significance of the local
control idea, much like the legal status of
school boards themselves, is likely to be contested
for some time to come.
The Dade County, Fla.,
school board has reaffirmed its support
for a 10 - year - old policy that bars administrators from exercising editorial
control over student publications.
The elected Orleans Parish
School Board (OPSB) retained authority over the system's 16 still - viable
schools, an administrative domain that shrank further as several of the best
schools fled central
control for the greater autonomy that comes with charter status.
The poster boy
for PM, New Orleans, with its exceptional hurricane origin and large charter sector to advocate on its behalf, reverted to
control by the previously reviled and inept locally elected
school board in about a decade.
Education Next's Mike Petrilli talks with Gene about his experience as a
school board member — and now,
school board president — and whether he sees a future
for this last bastion of local
control.
Just as the charter
school plan continued the pre-Katrina trend of decreasing
board control of New Orleans public
schools, the post-hurricane changes accelerated the trend of increasing state involvement and paved the way
for many more charter
schools.
According to Reiss, he did not push harder
for local
control because once he took office he learned how much power the teachers unions held over many local
school boards.
According to the court, the initiative authorizing charters suffered from two constitutional problems: 1) charter
schools are not «common»
schools, because they are not
controlled by
school boards, and 2) charters would divert money reserved
for common
schools.
See, e.g., Coleman, The Struggle
for Control of Education, in Education and Social Policy: Local Control of Education 64, 77 - 79 (C. Bowers, I. Housego & D. Dyke eds.1970); J. Conant, The Child, The Parent, and The State 27 (1959)(«Unless a local community, through its school board, has some control over the purse, there can be little real feeling in the community that the schools are in fact, local schools...»); Howe, Anatomy of a Revolution, in Saturday Review 84, 88 (Nov. 20, 1971)(«It is an axiom of American politics that control and power follow money...»); R. Hutchinson, State - Administered Locally Shared Taxes 21 (1931)-LRB-» [S] tate administration of taxation is the first step toward state control of the functions supported by these taxes...&r
Control of Education, in Education and Social Policy: Local
Control of Education 64, 77 - 79 (C. Bowers, I. Housego & D. Dyke eds.1970); J. Conant, The Child, The Parent, and The State 27 (1959)(«Unless a local community, through its school board, has some control over the purse, there can be little real feeling in the community that the schools are in fact, local schools...»); Howe, Anatomy of a Revolution, in Saturday Review 84, 88 (Nov. 20, 1971)(«It is an axiom of American politics that control and power follow money...»); R. Hutchinson, State - Administered Locally Shared Taxes 21 (1931)-LRB-» [S] tate administration of taxation is the first step toward state control of the functions supported by these taxes...&r
Control of Education 64, 77 - 79 (C. Bowers, I. Housego & D. Dyke eds.1970); J. Conant, The Child, The Parent, and The State 27 (1959)(«Unless a local community, through its
school board, has some
control over the purse, there can be little real feeling in the community that the schools are in fact, local schools...»); Howe, Anatomy of a Revolution, in Saturday Review 84, 88 (Nov. 20, 1971)(«It is an axiom of American politics that control and power follow money...»); R. Hutchinson, State - Administered Locally Shared Taxes 21 (1931)-LRB-» [S] tate administration of taxation is the first step toward state control of the functions supported by these taxes...&r
control over the purse, there can be little real feeling in the community that the
schools are in fact, local
schools...»); Howe, Anatomy of a Revolution, in Saturday Review 84, 88 (Nov. 20, 1971)(«It is an axiom of American politics that
control and power follow money...»); R. Hutchinson, State - Administered Locally Shared Taxes 21 (1931)-LRB-» [S] tate administration of taxation is the first step toward state control of the functions supported by these taxes...&r
control and power follow money...»); R. Hutchinson, State - Administered Locally Shared Taxes 21 (1931)-LRB-» [S] tate administration of taxation is the first step toward state
control of the functions supported by these taxes...&r
control of the functions supported by these taxes...»).
Relying on the 1909 ruling created a fundamental problem
for the court: the state constitution nowhere requires «complete
control» of common
schools by local
school boards.
For instance, it seems increasingly clear that our revered system of «local
control» by elected municipal
school boards can not cope with today's realities of metropolitanization, mobility, and interest - group politics.
A decision by the New Jersey
board of education to take
control of the Newark
schools was delayed last week as the state's largest district asked the state supreme court
for a stay.
Last year, heeding calls
for «local
control» of education decisions and less invasive interventions in underperforming
schools, Congress passed the Every Student Succeeds Act, granting states and local
school boards, rather than the federal government, broad latitude in determining how to rate the performance of
schools and how to intervene when performance lags.
(Our own Checker Finn has not been a fan of
school boards for some time and as recently as 2010 wrote, in National Affairs, that «it seems increasingly clear that our revered system of «local
control» by elected municipal
school boards can not cope with today's realities of metropolitanization, mobility, and interest - group politics.»)
In education, it could be read as an argument
for «local
control» — but with the important caveat that parents, teachers, and principals, not elected
school boards, are closest to the action that matters.