They correctly point out that's not true: while there are two levels
of foreign withholding tax with this structure, investors don't pay twice as much.
Should we determine opportunities are available to return these earnings, we may be required to record tax expenses related to
foreign withholding taxes in the second half of fiscal 2018.
It's also more tax - efficient since it holds developed markets stocks directly rather than via an underlying ETF, which results in
lower foreign withholding taxes.
One thing to keep in mind is that RWO's financial statements will only include
foreign withholding taxes levied from countries other than the US (since the ETF is US - domiciled).
For investors who use XAW, the drag caused
by foreign withholding taxes is somewhat smaller, because not all of its stocks are held via U.S. - listed ETFs.
Foreign withholding taxes also occur with mutual funds and ETFs listed on Canadian or U.S. exchanges, which is why this topic was featured in the ETF stream of a BMO Global Asset Management conference on ETFs and mutual funds that I participated in last week in Chicago.
Based on the calculations we made in our recentwhite paper, I'd
estimate foreign withholding taxes would add approximately 0.45 % to the cost of the fund if it's held in a registered account.
While foreign withholding taxes will continue to apply to dividends paid on certain international equity securities included in the XEF Index, it is expected that the change in investment strategy implementation will reduce the overall amount of withholding taxes borne directly or indirectly by XEF.»
In other words, whether Julie avoids
foreign withholding taxes altogether (as she's doing in her RRSP) or paying them upfront but later having them refunded (as in her non-registered account), the overall impact is the same.
You should also understand that when Canadian ETF providers report performance, they do so after
subtracting foreign withholding taxes: in other words, they do not presume these taxes will be subsequently recovered.
Foreign securities inside the TFSA will be subject to
foreign withholding tax based on the terms of the tax treaty Canada has with the other country.
By holding the US - listed ETFs directly, an additional cost savings of 0.52 % per year can be expected (this estimate includes the lower expense ratios of the US - listed ETFs, as well as the
lower foreign withholding taxes levied — however, it does not include the costs of currency conversion, which can be substantial if not carefully implemented).
If you mean that the 15 %
foreign withholding taxes levied by the US on dividends paid from IEMG to XEC are generally recoverable in a taxable account, then that would be accurate — but you would still pay full tax on the dividends received (so you don't avoid taxes on dividends).
In our newly revised white paper, Justin Bender and I explain the hidden cost of
foreign withholding taxes on U.S. and international equity ETFs.
After taking into account the additional tax drag
from foreign withholding taxes, the estimated cost of VXC increases to 0.66 % (from 0.27 %), while the estimated cost of XAW increases to 0.56 % (from 0.23 %).
Here are my posts for the past two weeks:
Foreign Withholding Taxes on New Vanguard ETFs Measuring Returns in Different Currencies.
Lesser - known tax issues include: high coupon bonds in taxable accounts, tax harvesting to minimize taxable gains, and
foreign withholding tax.
I've looked into British companies like UL and BT since there is
no foreign withholding tax for US investors, but it's their irregular payments and currency fluctuations that annoys the heck out of me.