That system involves several metrics,
from classroom observations of a teacher's work to student surveys about their instruction to student scores on Texas» annual achievement exams.
Not exact matches
Using pre - and post-course surveys, open - ended questions, self - reports
of section leader teaching practices, and
classroom observations, the researchers compared student examination scores and end -
of - course evaluations
from 150 Masters - level candidates in the «Principles
of Epidemiology» introductory course.
After extensive research on teacher evaluation procedures, the Measures
of Effective Teaching Project mentions three different measures to provide teachers with feedback for growth: (1)
classroom observations by peer - colleagues using validated scales such as the Framework for Teaching or the
Classroom Assessment Scoring System, further described in Gathering Feedback for Teaching (PDF) and Learning About Teaching (PDF), (2) student evaluations using the Tripod survey developed by Ron Ferguson
from Harvard, which measures students» perceptions
of teachers» ability to care, control, clarify, challenge, captivate, confer, and consolidate, and (3) growth in student learning based on standardized test scores over multiple years.
Under IMPACT, all teachers receive a single score ranging
from 100 to 400 points at the end
of each school year based on
classroom observations, measures
of student learning, and commitment to the school community.
Key Elements
of Observing Practice (DVD) contains a series
of short videos that invite you into
classrooms and meeting rooms at the Richard J. Murphy School in Boston, a school that uses data wisely, and comes with a Facilitator's Guide for designing your own process for learning
from classroom observation.
A few weeks ago, I met with a group
of educators to discuss their
observations from a series
of learning walks in
classrooms.
The idea is to see if combining information
from the tests, survey, and
classroom observations could produce more stable measures
of teacher contributions to learning than is possible by just using the state test.
Students really enjoy the visualisers, and we did extensive research into how to maximise their
classroom effect, including both the
observations of teachers, and ideas
from our student digital leaders, deciding where the technology would be best placed.
MET argues for a more balanced set
of weights among value added,
classroom observations, and feedback
from student surveys on other grounds.
We demonstrated that a regression - based statistical correction for the proportion
of the students in each teacher's class that are English - language learners, have education disabilities, are
from low - income families, and so forth, wrings most
of the bias out
of classroom observations.
The authors point out that the Cincinnati system
of evaluation is different
from the standard practice in place in most American school districts, where perfunctory evaluations assign the vast majority
of teachers «satisfactory» ratings, leading many to «characterize
classroom observation as a hopelessly flawed approach to assessing teacher effectiveness.»
The bias in
classroom observation systems that derives
from some teachers being assigned much more able students than other teachers is very important to the overall performance
of the teacher evaluation system.
(To generate the weights, we regressed a teacher's average student - achievement gain in one class against the three different measures
from another class, resulting in weights
of.758,.200, and.042 on value - added, student survey, and
classroom observation, respectively).
In a significant pedagogical shift
from the norm
of timed set recordings or set
classroom observation, leading to «performances»
from the teacher and the students (the Hawthorne effect), an always - on camera recording 360 - degree video enable live and retrospective viewing.
The artefacts
of the review (e.g. comments
from any
classroom observations and peer feedback) are confidential to the reviewer / reviewee (s); and,
After decades
of relying on often - perfunctory
classroom observations to assess teacher performance, districts
from Washington, D.C., to Los Angeles now evaluate many
of their teachers based in part on VA measures and, in some cases, use these measures as a basis for differences in compensation.
Misunderstanding the Gates Foundation's Measures
of Effective Teaching Project Education Next, January 10, 2013 «MET argues for a more balanced set
of weights among value added,
classroom observations, and feedback
from student surveys on other grounds.
This way, staff are confidently identifying and meeting the needs
of all learners, and evidence
of this can be seen
from observations of classroom practice, progress and attainment data, the scrutiny
of work produced, discussion with teachers, the views
of parents / carers as well as the views
of the pupil, too.
What's more, significantly improved predictive power
from a mixture
of classroom observations with test score gains could have made the case for why we need both.
(2) A program must use information
from paragraph (b)(1)
of this section with informal teacher
observations and additional information
from family and staff, as relevant, to determine a child's strengths and needs, adjust strategies to better support individualized learning and improve
classroom practices in center - based and family child care settings and improve home visit strategies in home based models.
A performance review
of career teachers needs to be conducted once every three years and include
classroom observation of the teacher, a review
of the teacher's progress on the Iowa teaching standards and additional standards and criteria, a review
of the implementation
of teacher's individual professional development plan, and supporting documentation
from other evaluators, teachers, parents, and students.
All three studies achieved very high response rates on all data collections, whether teacher surveys,
classroom observations, collection
of teachers» scores on college entrance exams or precertification exams, student achievement tests, collection
of student data
from district administrative records, principal surveys, or interviews with program officials.
Or, put another way, if teachers were generating high test score gains
from their students by creating a climate
of abject fear in their
classrooms, their
observation scores should be low and that information is useful.
Cambridge, MA (October 5, 2015)-- On October 5, researchers at the Center for Education Policy Research at Harvard University will release findings
from the Best Foot Forward project, an initiative testing whether video technology can help address the challenges faced by teachers and school leaders in implementing
classroom observations that are part
of teacher evaluation systems.
«It is clear
from these findings and the MET project's earlier study
of classroom observation instruments that
classroom observations are not discerning large absolute differences in practice,» the authors wrote.
In line with the MET report, I think some kind
of triangulation
of qualitative and quantitative data that utilizes student feedback (with teacher reflection), teacher and / or Professional Learning Community evidence
of student learning and growth (with teacher reflection), and supervisor feedback
from classroom observations (with teacher reflection) would help to provide a balanced and multi-dimensional approach for more intentionally and comprehensively understanding teaching and learning.
He received his doctorate
from St. John's University where he conducted a study on the effectiveness
of classroom observation practices for the purpose
of instructional improvement.
She cites no data other than her own impressions
from classroom observations and the assertions
of advocates
of reform - oriented instruction.
For the project as a whole, we collected two rounds
of survey data
from principals and teachers and three rounds
of site - visit data
from schools and districts, including
classroom observations and interviews with teachers and building and district administrators.
Mrs. Purser was chosen after a rigorous process, consisting
of three rounds
of application evaluations
from internal and external stakeholders, a
classroom observation, and a final in - person interview.
But in RTTC, I get to invite teachers to be part
of the learning and growth process by using qualitative and quantitative data
from classroom observations to get the teacher to reflect on the implementation
of their deliverables and how they impact student engagement and
classroom culture.
Context
of use Students used RCE as one source
from a host
of possible sources they were encouraged to draw upon in the course, including (but not limited to)
classroom observations, readings, personal experiences, past careers, and video.
Optimism, test scores on the rise at English High School November 30, 2015 In a fourth - floor
classroom, students diligently scrawled notes across lined pages one recent morning as social studies teacher Frank Swoboda explained the role
of politics in economic development, peppering his lesson with
observations from students... read more.
Angela Lee, director
of Krescent City Kids Learning Academy, said the overall feedback she got
from the first year
of observations of her toddler and pre-K
classrooms was somewhat helpful, but a chance to review the observer's notes would be even more so.
The following data were collected at each school: structured interviews
of approximately an hour for each building principal and five to seven early reading program staff; school and
classroom observations of approximately 12 hours per school; field notes
from observations and informal conversations with school staff; and selected artifacts
from the early reading programs.
If I were running a school I'd probably want to evaluate teachers using a mixture
of student test score gains,
classroom observations, and feedback
from parents, students, and other staff.
Designed to highlight local proof points, EduTours couple a presentation
of research on the designated topic with a school visit that includes conversation with school leadership,
classroom observations, and insights
from experts in the field.
The certification process comprises two days
of intensive communication with school stakeholders,
classroom observations to see students in action, and an exit presentation
of the findings
from the review team.
Apply what you learned by reviewing evidence
from observations of classroom teachers and being a part
of a complete formal
observation process
of a specialist.
Under the new system, principals are required to spend
from 60 to 90 minutes in a teacher's
classroom annually, depending on a teacher's experience — meaning for veteran teachers, principals must conduct four 15 - minute
observations over the course
of the school year.
Ann Schulte, associate professor at California State University, Chico, says that preparation programs should be focused on working with and assessing teacher candidates in the field, so they receive frequent
observations and feedback during their student teaching experiences
from someone with extensive knowledge
of their abilities and
classrooms.
The state also simplified the rubric for
classroom observations, reducing the number
of points principals track in
observations and cutting one rating level for teachers, creating four options
from «ineffective,» to «highly effective.»
Using examples
from classroom teachers with whom she has worked, Collay describes four dimensions
of powerful
classroom - based leadership: (1) teaching well by drawing on professional knowledge to respond to the complex relationship challenges that affect learning; (2) finding creative ways to collaborate with both colleagues and parents; (3) conducting
classroom - based inquiry, both through informal
observation and through formal, structured research; and (4) using partnerships with outside organizations to support student learning.
In the example handout, I draw
from a specific
classroom activity observed, other more general
observations of the
classroom, things the teacher has told me, and things I know about the daily routine in the
classroom.
And considering the low - quality
of subjective
classroom observations that are the norm for traditional teacher evaluation systems, the state laws and collective bargaining agreements governing teacher performance management discourage school leaders
from providing more - ample feedback, and that the use
of objective student test score growth data is just coming into play, few teachers have gotten the kind
of feedback needed to build such expertise in the first place.
Since the written test described
classroom situations that were different
from those shown in the interactive video activities, the
classroom observation test was considered to measure transfer
of learning.
One
of the key areas
of congruence throughout the state data
from Florida, Tennessee, and Georgia is the generally high scores given to teachers during
classroom observations, a finding that comes right as new research is revealing clues about the properties
of such
observations and how they are shaped by the norms within schools.
In addition, researchers found (although we have known this prior) that «
classroom observations have the potential
of providing formative feedback to teachers that [theoretically] helps them improve their practice [more than VAMs]... [because] feedback
from [VAMs]... is often too delayed and vague to produce improvement in teaching.»
AdvancED's senior researcher Dr. Matt Dawson shares the results
of the
classroom observation tool used in over 26,000
classrooms to assess effective learning environments in his article, Analyzing Results
from AdvancED's
Classroom Observation Tool.
Different
from the conventional approach
of teacher
observation, I quantify teacher behaviors through their language and interaction with students
from word - to - word transcriptions
of classroom videos.