«I kept thinking of the Goya painting because it seemed detached
from ethical judgment.
Not exact matches
Just as one can usually distinguish, according to their purposes, a good
from a bad saddle or a good
from a bad cavalry officer, so too the
judgment of good and bad in the
ethical sense should be eminently adjudicable if moral behavior is goal - determined.
Part of the problem the way the question is posed is by assuming that we can abstract an
ethical ideal
from one part of scripture and use it to judge the actions of God in another part of scripture, as though scripture were given us so we could form such dehistoricized abstract
ethical judgments!
Yet to begin
ethical reflection at this point invariably seems to result in arbitrarily separating the moral
judgment of an action
from the kind of person who performs it.
It was the
ethical judgments of Charlie's physicians that kept Charlie
from getting treatment when there was a reasonable chance it could benefit him.
Making
judgments and taking actions can be pretty tricky, and no doubt even unpleasant
from that context, but like Shawn noted in his «invasion» analogy, they may be entirely necessary (maybe that's a tool to employ in unpacking
ethical / cultural aspects of Biblical history).
The moral importance of Christianity follows
from its truth claims; otherwise its
ethical judgments have no power.
The possible advent of autonomous drones operated by «
ethical governors», however, would entail such a separation of action
from judgment.
What gives legal or
ethical actions theirsignificance is never merely their accordance with a rule, but the fact they follow
from an agent's conscious
judgment to do so.
It has been many years since New York State had a governor with the vision,
judgment and authority that it needs now to turn Albany's budget
from obesity, to resist powerful interests, to plot a course out of an
ethical netherworld in which state the government has become a national embarrassment.
«Each blog post: (a) identifies cases that address technology mishaps (either through negligence,
ethical lapses in
judgment, too much reliance on outside counsel and vendors, or fraud); (b) exposes the specific conduct that caused a problem; (c) explains how and why the conduct was improper; and (d) offers suggestions on how to learn
from these mistakes and prevent similar ones
from reoccurring.»