He pointed to additional findings
from the school choice studies that could guide policy makers:
Not exact matches
This damning statistic
from last week's New
School study on school choice exposes the absurdity of new Chancellor Richard Carranza's vow that «all students will be supported» as he aims to desegregate the s
School study on
school choice exposes the absurdity of new Chancellor Richard Carranza's vow that «all students will be supported» as he aims to desegregate the s
school choice exposes the absurdity of new Chancellor Richard Carranza's vow that «all students will be supported» as he aims to desegregate the system.
According to a
study from the London Business
School, political differences dictate American beverage
choice: Conservatives prefer domestic pours such as Busch to imports like Guinness.
More than 30 percent of Americans live with at least one cat, and they re probably getting the same stress relief and happy - hormone release
from their pet of
choice that dog - owners get; there are simply fewer
studies to prove it, says judge Alan Beck, ScD, director of the Center for Human - Animal Bond at the Purdue University
School of Veterinary Medicine.
These
studies show, consistently, that parental
schools of
choice not controlled by public
school districts 1) are usually prohibited by law
from screening out students based on admission exams, 2) use ability tracking less frequently than traditional public
schools even when, legally, they can, and 3) may use ability tracking, but when they do, it is less likely to have a negative effect on the achievement of low - track students.
Two conclusions
from recent PISA
studies are that increased national performance is associated with greater equity in the distribution of educational resources and that equity can be undermined when
school choice segregates students into
schools based on socioeconomic background.
In this
study we investigate whether district officials in a position to influence policy and practice have begun to respond to competitive pressure
from school choice in new ways.
Among male high
school students at high risk of criminal activity, winning admission to a first -
choice school reduced felony arrests
from 77 to 43 per 100 students over the
study period (2002 - 2009).
Previous gold standard
studies had almost unanimously found modest positive effects
from school choice, which raises the obvious question: what makes the Louisiana Scholarship Program (LSP) so different?
The book emerged
from the authors»
study of
choice programs in the
schools of San Antonio, but it became an attempt at a sweeping synthesis of scholarly work on education policy, drawing on literature in philosophy, economics, political science, education, and law.
We can learn a great deal about
school choice, entrepreneurship, social capital, and community
from studying these organizations in greater depth.
The most commonly cited
school choice review, by economists Cecilia Rouse and Lisa Barrow, declares that it will focus on the evidence
from existing experimental
studies but then leaves out four such
studies (three of which reported positive
choice effects) and includes one
study that was non-experimental (and found no significant effect of
choice).
About 67 percent of students
from both groups attend their first -
choice school, according to the
study, which was conducted by the Cohen Center for Modern Jewish
Studies at Brandeis University in Waltham, Mass..
Greg Forster's Win - Win report
from 2013 is a welcome exception and gets the award for the
school choice review closest to covering all of the
studies that fit his inclusion criteria — 93.3 %.
The results reported here are consistent with four similar
studies - the 1973 High
School Seniors Cohort Study, the National Educational Longitudinal Study, the Latino National Political Survey, and data collected from participants in school - choice programs in Washington, D.C., and Dayton,
School Seniors Cohort
Study, the National Educational Longitudinal
Study, the Latino National Political Survey, and data collected
from participants in
school - choice programs in Washington, D.C., and Dayton,
school -
choice programs in Washington, D.C., and Dayton, Ohio.
The Commission, chaired by Dr. Paul Hill of the University of Washington, carefully reviewed the research on the impact of
school choice on student achievement and included in its report the following statement: «The most rigorous
school choice evaluations that used random assignment... found that academic gains
from vouchers were largely limited to the African - American students in their
studies.»
Chingos wrote about these
studies in «What Have We Learned From Three Studies of Private School Choice?
studies in «What Have We Learned
From Three
Studies of Private School Choice?
Studies of Private
School Choice?»
After
studying six years of data
from Milwaukee, Warren concludes, in a new
study reported here, «Students in the Milwaukee
choice program are more likely to graduate
from high
school than» students in the Milwaukee Public
Schools (MPS).
The evidence
from a
study of New York's magnet
schools for secondary students «seems to indicate that it is possible to construct a public high -
school choice system that eliminates some of the worst excesses of an unfettered
choice plan,» the
study says.
Given a half - century of failure
from school reform, great priority should be given to the further
study of the effects of
school choice in empowering parents over educators and
school boards and its effects on advancing student achievement and parent satisfaction.
But there is risk of overstating results
from any single
study, especially on issues as controversial and polarizing as private
school choice.
Like Chloe, many students have no
choice but to work long hours to pay for
school, which prevents them
from fully engaging in their
studies and probably contributes to the high dropout rate among low - income students.
Smarick's
study, «The Chartered Course,» explores how private
schools and advocates of educational
choice can learn
from the charter sector.
Seven of the eight previous
studies using similar definitions of segregation found that, on average, students move
from more segregated to less segregated
schools as a result of
school choice.
Rounding out the mix of resources are a diagram explaining the five steps in the
school - climate improvement process, descriptions of 15 available workshops,
school case
studies and a few
choice video clips
from experts.
In Mike's fourth post criticizing our
study he chastises us for generalizing the results
from evaluations of entire
school choice programs to regulator behavior regarding individual
schools.
In our
study we draw upon the findings
from 24 evaluations of various types of
school choice programs to show that the achievement effects
from those programs are only weakly and inconsistently predictive of their subsequent attainment effects.
Researchers
from the Urban Institute have released a
study looking at how long it takes students to travel
from home to
school in five different cities where families have a significant amount of educational
choice.
Last week, Mike Petrilli, President of the Thomas B. Fordham Institute, published a series of blog posts at the Education Gadfly and Education Next critiquing an AEI
study by Dr. Collin Hitt, Dr. Michael McShane, and myself discussing the surprising disconnect between the achievement and attainment effects
from school choice programs in the US.
This longitudinal ethnographic
study follows the college
choice experiences of two - high performing English learners (ELs)
from junior year to high
school graduation.
That is true, and while we have numerous
studies establishing positive competitive effects on district
schools from choice programs, few states have
choice programs going at a scale to place a large amount of pressure on district enrolments.
Small high
schools send larger shares of students to college, new
study says ChalkbeatNY: The multi-year
study examines a subset of 123 «small
schools of
choice» that opened between 2002 and 2008 with private funding
from the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation and support
from former Mayor Michael Bloomberg's administration.
Paul Hill and Tom Loveless, both senior scholars at the Brookings Institution, recently acquired a million - dollar grant
from the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation to assemble a panel of experts on
school choice, with the goal of writing the definitive statement on what we know and what requires additional
study.
The introduction of randomized field trials to education research is as much a boon to knowledge as the results
from any single
study on
school choice.
Though the only data on large - scale voucher programs she finds convincing come
from her own
study of the New Zealand public -
choice program and Martin Carnoy's work in Chile, Ladd confidently asserts that vouchers will not help those public
schools that are having the hardest time of it.
Results
from other
studies on private
school choice, however, do not indicate a relationship.
Good Morning A new
study from Patrick J. Wolf at the University of Arkansas found that students in the Milwaukee Parental
Choice Program were likely to commit crimes than comparable students who attended Milwaukee public
schools.
It does so despite the preponderance of evidence that, as the authors of one educational
study from 2002 wrote, «
school choice, on average, does not produce the equity and social justice that proponents spin.»
Today, researchers
from the
School Choice Demonstration Project at the University of Arkansas and the Education Research Alliance for New Orleans at Tulane University will release findings
from their
study of the third year of results
from the Louisiana Scholarship Program at the Urban Institute in Washington.
Two recent
studies of LSP indicate initial negative student achievement results that do not align with the greater body of research showing positive or neutral outcomes
from school choice programs in other cities and states.
Using these measures, a near - consensus of the «gold standard»
studies — those that employ random assignment to determine the causal impact of a policy — have found that students in a
school choice program benefit academically
from the new setting.
His current projects include
studying high
school interventions to improve college enrollment and degree completion, how lessons
from behavioral economics can be applied to persistence and success in Massive Open Online Courses (MOOCs), whether financial incentives can alter students»
choice of major, and how students use Advanced Placement credits in college.
This report is based on a «meta - analysis» — a
study that examines all of the existing research and examines the overall findings — of the research literature on private
school choice programs, including vouchers and tax credit scholarships,
from around the world.
To read more analysis
from this synthesis of 100 empirical
school choice studies, visit edchoice.org/Win-Win.
The national report compiles results
from rigorous empirical
studies that examine the academic outcomes of
school choice students, the academic effect of competition on public
schools, the fiscal impact of
school choice on taxpayers and government, racial segregation in
schools and the effect of
school choice on civic values and practices.
Throughout their time in
school, students will have the opportunity to make different
choices on a range of issues -
from decisions and
choices about their own actions and behaviours, to the clubs that they join and (as they move through the Learning Trust) the subjects that they
study.
In fact, the evidence
from the 7 rigorous
studies on
school choice programs with long - term outcomes suggests that portfolio management and other heavy regulations are neither necessary nor desirable for producing long - term gains for students.
Yesterday, the
School Choice Demonstration Project at the University of Arkansas and the Education Research Alliance for New Orleans at Tulane University released findings
from their
study of the third year of results
from the Louisiana Scholarship Program.
School choice has grown by leaps and bounds over the past two decades, with literally millions of students benefiting from the choice movement, precisely because most studies have shown that school choice programs help improve educational outcomes — for students who receive private school scholarships, those who attend public charter schools, and those who remain in traditional public sc
School choice has grown by leaps and bounds over the past two decades, with literally millions of students benefiting
from the
choice movement, precisely because most
studies have shown that
school choice programs help improve educational outcomes — for students who receive private school scholarships, those who attend public charter schools, and those who remain in traditional public sc
school choice programs help improve educational outcomes — for students who receive private
school scholarships, those who attend public charter schools, and those who remain in traditional public sc
school scholarships, those who attend public charter
schools, and those who remain in traditional public
schools.
The
studies show that as public
schools in the country are growing more segregated,
school choice is moving students
from more segregated to more integrated classrooms.