Hopefully it will provide a window into whether or not voucher students are experiencing better learning
gains than public school students.
Not exact matches
A separate study of the ECLS - K data, also by Peterson and Llaudet, similarly showed that private
school students gained significantly more in reading achievement
than demographically similar
public school students in
schools with similar
student populations.
Another literature review, conducted by economists Jeffrey Grogger and Derek Neal, found few clear - cut
gains for white
students, while «urban minorities in Catholic
schools fare much better
than similar
students in
public schools.»
(A few years later, using survey data from the second round of «High
School and Beyond,» the team showed that
students in private
schools had greater learning
gains between their sophomore and senior years
than did
students in
public schools.
In their report, Miron and Applegate conclude that Edison
Schools do improve from year to year on norm - referenced tests, which measure gains in students knowledge over time, but on criterion - referenced tests, which measure whether or not students meet state standards, Edison students fared no better than students from surrounding public s
Schools do improve from year to year on norm - referenced tests, which measure
gains in
students knowledge over time, but on criterion - referenced tests, which measure whether or not
students meet state standards, Edison
students fared no better
than students from surrounding
public schoolsschools.
And, finally, do
students who attend traditional
public schools subject to competition from charter
schools make larger achievement
gains than they would have in the absence of charter
schools?
We address three main questions: Do
students attending charter
schools in these grades make larger or smaller
gains in achievement
than they would have made in traditional
public schools?
Students in these grades make considerably smaller achievement
gains in charter
schools than they would have in traditional
public schools, and the negative effects are not limited to
schools in their first year of operation.
Second,
students who choose to remain in charter
schools do not continue to make smaller
gains than students in traditional
public schools after their initial year in a charter
school.
This pattern provides strong evidence that the smaller
gains made by these charter
school students are indeed due to the quality of the
schools they attend rather
than to any unobserved differences between charter
school students and
students in traditional
public schools.
Based on the findings presented here, the typical
student in Michigan charter
schools gains more learning in a year
than his [traditional
public school (TPS)-RSB- counterparts, amounting to about two months of additional
gains in reading and math.
Known as the CREDO study, it evaluated
student progress on math tests in half the nation's five thousand charter
schools and concluded that 17 percent were superior to a matched traditional
public school; 37 percent were worse
than the
public school; and the remaining 46 percent had academic
gains no different from that of a similar
public school.
The Boston study of just over 2,000
students in the
public school district's universal program for 4 - to -5-year-olds found greater
gains in vocabulary and math for participating
students compared with nonparticipants, after one year,
than seen in any other study of other large - scale pre-K programs around the US.
Teske and Schneider note that the existing empirical work on
school vouchers is quite positive on a variety of issues: academic considerations appear paramount when parents choose
schools; voucher recipients are more satisfied with their
schools than their peers within
public schools; and vouchers lead to «clear performance
gains for some groups of
students using the vouchers, particularly blacks, compared with the control group.»
Studies conducted by Mathematica Policy Research show that KIPP
schools achieve significantly greater
gains in
student achievement
than do traditional
public schools teaching similar
students.
He notes that, although few studies have examined the impact of choice on
public school students, most every finding to date suggests that vouchers, rather
than adversely affecting
students who are «left behind» in
public schools, actually lead to
gains for
public and private
school students.
Recently released results from the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) show that Arizona's
public charter
school students have posted greater scale score
gains than any individual state, from 2009 to 2017.
Unfortunately, though, the main premise of the equity argument has not been fulfilled — inner - city poor
students attending private
schools with vouchers in general show no greater
gains in academic achievement
than comparable
students in
public schools.
Compared to Chicago
Public Schools» district - wide 1 - point improvement in the same period, these two schools improved by 8 and 10 points, respectively, on the student - teacher trust measure of the 5Essentials Survey — a school climate survey based on more than 20 years of research that found schools strong on three or more of the 5Essential components were ten times more likely to improve student learning
Schools» district - wide 1 - point improvement in the same period, these two
schools improved by 8 and 10 points, respectively, on the student - teacher trust measure of the 5Essentials Survey — a school climate survey based on more than 20 years of research that found schools strong on three or more of the 5Essential components were ten times more likely to improve student learning
schools improved by 8 and 10 points, respectively, on the
student - teacher trust measure of the 5Essentials Survey — a
school climate survey based on more
than 20 years of research that found
schools strong on three or more of the 5Essential components were ten times more likely to improve student learning
schools strong on three or more of the 5Essential components were ten times more likely to improve
student learning
gains.
Maryland's
public school students made greater
gains on a national standardized test
than their peers in nearly every other state, although the achievement gap between white and minority
students persists.
Both educators and the
public are beginning to better understand that success for our
students, beyond high
school and through college and careers, means that teaching and learning must focus on more
than just core academic content — and that
students do not
gain social and emotional competencies at the expense of rigorous academics.
With small classes, individualized learning programs, strong teaching, and support from the local community, King / Chavez has more
than tripled the
student achievement
gains made in the broader
public school system.
the typical
student in a New York City
public charter
school gains more learning in a year
than his or her peer in a district
public school, amounting to about one more month of learning in reading and five more months of learning in math.
The results for the typical
student in a Harlem
public charter
school — approximately 25 percent of the city's charter
students — were even more pronounced in math, on average
gaining seven more months
than his or her peer in a district
public school, but less
than a full additional month in reading.
DeVos supporters point to a 2013 Stanford study that found that Michigan charter -
school students are learning at a faster rate in reading and math
than their
public -
school peers — seeing an additional two months of
gains in each subject.
Analyzing more
than a decade's worth of data from Chicago
Public Schools, they found that schools where adults demonstrate a shared sense of responsibility for student learning are four times more likely to make substantial gains in reading than schools without strong professiona
Schools, they found that
schools where adults demonstrate a shared sense of responsibility for student learning are four times more likely to make substantial gains in reading than schools without strong professiona
schools where adults demonstrate a shared sense of responsibility for
student learning are four times more likely to make substantial
gains in reading
than schools without strong professiona
schools without strong professional ties.
In addition,
students at new charter
schools have lower reading and math
gains than at
public schools.
Three years after closures, the
public -
school students had
gained, on average, what equates to 49 extra days of learning in reading —
gaining more
than a year of achievement growth, as measured by state reading exams.
A independent national study released this year by the Center for Research on Education Outcomes shows charter
school students have greater learning
gains in reading
than their peers in traditional
public schools.
CREDO found that, on average,
students in New Jersey charter
schools are making greater
gains in both reading and math
than their counterparts in traditional
public schools.
Groundbreaking research was released on November 1, 2017 that showed Chicago
Public School students make faster academic gains than students in 96 % of school districts in Am
School students make faster academic
gains than students in 96 % of
school districts in Am
school districts in America.
Late last year, Stanford released research which showed that elementary Chicago
Public School students were achieving faster learning gains than almost any other large public school district in the co
Public School students were achieving faster learning gains than almost any other large public school district in the co
School students were achieving faster learning
gains than almost any other large
public school district in the co
public school district in the co
school district in the country.
A 2011 report (PDF) by Stanford's Center for Research on Education Outcomes (CREDO), using a different methodology, indicated
students in Pennsylvania's online charter
schools «have significantly smaller
gains in reading and math
than those of their traditional
public school peers.»
Earlier this month, state Superintendent of Education John White trumpeted the fact that Louisiana
public high
school students showed greater
gains this year in earning college credit
than those in any other state except Massachusetts.
However, the study concludes that «elementary and middle -
school charter
students exhibited higher learning
gains than equivalent
students in the traditional
public school system» and «
students in poverty and English - language learners experience larger learning
gains in charter
schools.»
These ideas — choice, charter
schools, vouchers — have all
gained a foothold to one degree or another in struggling urban districts across the country, including in DeVos» own home turf of Detroit, where more
than half of
public school students now attend charter
schools.
The charter
students in Detroit
gain over three months per year more
than their counterparts at traditional
public schools.»
Two reports have been published to date, which both demonstrate significant learning
gains for Bridge PSL
public school students; notably that they are learning two times quicker
than their peers in non-PSL
public schools.
Comparisons were made based on subject, grade level and subgroup and showed in 82 of 96 comparisons, the percentage of charter
school students making learning
gains was higher
than the percentage of traditional
public school students making learning
gains.
Overall,
students in charter
schools have had bigger
gains in both reading and math
than similar
students enrolled in the DC
Public School system, especially when it comes to middle school
School system, especially when it comes to middle
schoolschool math.
Sometimes
students in regular, old inner city
public schools made more impressive
gains than students in publicly funded but privately owned and managed charter
schools, and sometimes
students in charter
schools did better.
As Commissioner of Education, Dianna Wentzell commented, «In some cases,
students in choice programs made greater academic
gains than their peers not enrolled in these programs (
students in traditional
public schools), thereby closing the achievement gap, while in other cases they did not.»
Students in public schools faced with increased private school competition showed greater gains in test scores than students in other public schools with the introduction of the
Students in
public schools faced with increased private
school competition showed greater
gains in test scores
than students in other public schools with the introduction of the
students in other
public schools with the introduction of the program.
Students in the District's traditional
public schools scored higher
than ever on the city's math and reading tests this year, also posting the largest single - year
gain since 2008, according to test results released Tuesday.
Some charter
schools show impressive academic
gains for their
students, but others perform the same as or in some cases worse
than regular
public schools.
It found that
students who used vouchers did not see academic
gains in their new
schools and that they performed worse, on average,
than their matched peers in the
public schools that they left.
Competitive effects studies may have high external validity, but they have lower internal validity
than RCTs, meaning we don't have as much confidence as we would with RCTs that there is a causal relationship between
school choice programs and test score
gains by
students who remain in
public schools.