Why is public tax money allowed to
go to private school vouchers, when private schools do not have to test and, therefore, are not held «accountable»?
Not exact matches
Opposition
to expanding
school choice through a universal
voucher initiative that «gives all students an opportunity
to go to private schools with government funding» is higher in this year's survey than a year ago.
Lots of ed reformers, especially those on the political left, still oppose publicly funded
voucher programs that would enable disadvantaged kids
to go to private schools.
Lawmakers considering portability or other federal
voucher programs must understand that the concept of federal dollars
going into a «backpack of cash» that follows eligible students
to the
schools of their choice, whether public or
private, is only part of the story.
Even
voucher advocates would agree that, because
private school choice is costly under the current system, parents who
go private are likely
to be more socially advantaged than parents who remain in the public
schools.
But Wisconsin state senator Russ Decker, a leading opponent of
vouchers, has argued that the program gives money
to children who would attend
private schools anyway and declared, «You've got a lot of additional money
going into the choice program that we could better use funding public education statewide.»
We've
gone from two, century - old
voucher programs in Maine and Vermont
to having
private school choice in more than half of the states.
In the absence of
vouchers, only parents with enough money are able
to seek out good
schools by
going private; but under a
voucher system, they argue, with the cost of
private education much reduced (or zero), many more parents would be able
to — and would want
to.
Most people are familiar with
voucher programs, where state dollars
go to pay for tuition at
private schools.
The poor, so this logic
goes, need government assistance if they are
to get a good education, which helps explain why, in the United States, many
school choice enthusiasts believe that the only way the poor can get the education they deserve is through
vouchers or charter
schools, proxies for those better
private or independent
schools, paid for with public funds.
As of 2005, more than one - third of the city's parents chose either
to enroll their child in a charter
school, use a
voucher to go to a
private school, or seek out a place in a suburban public
school.
The other half was asked a question that might be termed «
voucher - unfriendly» in that it emphasizes students
going to private school at public expense.
Critics on the right lamented that the Bush administration and its allies within the parochial
school establishment failed
to go even further and make
private school vouchers a bigger part of the new regime.
We found that that college enrollments for low - income, African American students who used a
voucher to go to private elementary
school increased by24 percent.
We wanted
to see whether students performed better on standard tests if they won the
voucher opportunity and
went to private school.
On Top of the News
Private School Vouchers to Go to about 300 D.C. Students Washington Post August 5, 2012 Behind the Headline How Vouchers Came to D.C. Education Next Fall 2004 Nearly three hundred new students have been awarded vouchers in D.C. as part of a controversial federally - funded
Vouchers to Go to about 300 D.C. Students Washington Post August 5, 2012 Behind the Headline How
Vouchers Came to D.C. Education Next Fall 2004 Nearly three hundred new students have been awarded vouchers in D.C. as part of a controversial federally - funded
Vouchers Came
to D.C. Education Next Fall 2004 Nearly three hundred new students have been awarded
vouchers in D.C. as part of a controversial federally - funded
vouchers in D.C. as part of a controversial federally - funded program.
A recent Friedman Foundation report, for example, bemoaned testing requirements that «may force all participating
schools to move in the direction of a single, monopolistic curriculum and pedagogy...» And analysts at the Cato Institute
went so far as
to send letters
to Indiana
private schools urging them not
to participate in the state's new
voucher program, which it called a «strategic defeat» for
school reform, in part because of its testing and transparency requirements.
The bill, called the Opportunity Scholarship Act, is essentially a
voucher program that would give as many as 20,000 poor students who
go to failing
schools about $ 6,000
to $ 9,000 each
to attend a
private or parochial
school.
An education
voucher is essentially a scholarship that
goes directly
to the
private school by way of parental decisions.
«The end result is the same — federal tax dollars
going to private schools,» said Sasha Pudelski, assistant director for policy and advocacy at AASA, The
School Superintendents Association, who called the program «a backdoor
voucher.»
«My general view,» says the Post's Mathews, «is that the
voucher path is a dead end because we are never
going to have nearly enough spaces in
private schools for the kids who need it.
The only way
to neutralize these concerns is
to randomly offer students a chance
to go to private school and see what happens — a condition that the
voucher programs of the 1990s have satisfied.
The Allentown Morning Call wrote Sunday that «Corbett said he wants
vouchers «aimed at failing
schools,» where parents, if they choose, «should be able
to go the public
school next door... or that
private school... and take that money and get that opportunity.»
DeVos told Collins she would explore the possibility of turning IDEA funds — which currently
go to states and
school districts — into
vouchers that could follow students
to private schools.
«The question is, will you enforce the law with regard
to students with disabilities» who get a
voucher to go to a
private school, which then refuses
to provide them with services they deserve?
In addition, $ 250 million would
go to create
vouchers for
private schools, and $ 167 million for charter
schools.
«
To be voucher - eligible, our children would have to actually go back to public school, get reenrolled there, be there for year, then we'd have to take them back out at the end and then send them back to our private school,» says Abbot
To be
voucher - eligible, our children would have
to actually go back to public school, get reenrolled there, be there for year, then we'd have to take them back out at the end and then send them back to our private school,» says Abbot
to actually
go back
to public school, get reenrolled there, be there for year, then we'd have to take them back out at the end and then send them back to our private school,» says Abbot
to public
school, get reenrolled there, be there for year, then we'd have
to take them back out at the end and then send them back to our private school,» says Abbot
to take them back out at the end and then send them back
to our private school,» says Abbot
to our
private school,» says Abbott.
«This national research is worth paying attention
to, and cautions other states not
to go down the same road as Wisconsin in terms of unaccountable
private school vouchers,» said WEAC President Ron Martin.
Speaking on background, a staffer for Rep. Sondy Pope, who has been outspoken in her criticism of underwriting
private school tuition with
vouchers, said «our caucus as a whole is looking»
to do something even more stringent than in Racine, but was less than optimistic about Republicans
going along.
The
voucher program works like this: Taxpayer subsidies
go to lower - and middle - income parents who choose
to send their children
to private and religious
schools.
The bigger problem, though, is that most of the new
vouchers are
going to students who were already attending
private schools.
* Two grants totaling $ 50,000
went to Parents for Educational Freedom in North Carolina, a group pushing for more public charters
schools as well as
private school vouchers.
For his part, Pocan pointed out that the last expansion of the choice program resulted in three - fourths of the public money
going to parents whose kids were already enrolled in the
private schools they were getting
vouchers for, and two - thirds
went to families making over $ 100,000 a year.
When companies choose the tax credit, these dollars bypass the state and
go directly
to vouchers — making it harder for opponents
to argue that «public» money is
going to private schools.
«If we're
going to give kids a
voucher to an unregulated
private school, then how do we know they're getting a good education?»
So does this mean you're
going to call for the implementation of Common Core as a requirement for
private schools accepting taxpayer money in the forms of
vouchers or scholarship tax credits?
Now, the nation's oldest
voucher program lets nearly 28,000 students attend
private, mostly religious
voucher schools, while another 76,000 children attend district
schools and 7,000
go to public charter
schools.
62 — percent of
vouchers provided in 2013 - 2014 under proposal by House Speaker Paul Stam that would
go to students currently enrolled in
private or religious
schools (Ibid)
Pointing out that «states with constitutional provisions similar
to ours have uniformly rejected the notion that
schools are not aided by tuition payments,» the court in this case rejected the argument that the
voucher payments merely represent indirect aid
to private schools because they
go to students and their parents, who then make the payment
to the
schools.
Under current law,
school districts can continue
to receive funding for students they no longer educate if they choose
to go to a
private school with a
voucher, meaning that a student leaving actually increases the district's per - student revenue in the short term.
Borsuk says some studies, sponsored by pro-
voucher groups but conducted by reputable scholars, indicate that a student
going to a
private high
school on a
voucher is more likely
to graduate than a student
going to MPS, more likely
to go to and do well in college - not by a huge amounts but fairly modest gains,» he says.
Ultimately, kids who are getting
vouchers and
going to private schools are doing the same at kids in MPS.
Much of that money would
go toward the
private sector, and DeVos has also been challenged repeatedly for supporting
vouchers that allow parents
to use government dollars
to pay for
private, for - profit and religious
schools, a cornerstone of Trump's stated plan.
Democrats largely support Evers, and see him as one of the only obstacles left
to keep public dollars from
going to private voucher schools.
«It seems, again, irrational
to me
to say, public
schools, you're
going to have
to make do but let's expand the
voucher program over here where history has shown us that 70
to 80 percent of those kids are already in
private schools,» Evers said.
And in order
to get THAT, the public has
to agree
to tax credits that send $ 50 million in tax dollars
to private and religious foundations and another $ 70 million that will
go in $ 500 increments
to private and parochial
schools as «credits» that act as
vouchers.
Last year, the taxpayers of Indiana paid out $ 146.1 million
to voucher schools, with most of it
going to families who would have sent their children
to private school anyway.
Colorado and Missouri are among 39 states that have strict prohibitions on public funds»
going to religious
schools, known as Blaine Amendments, which
voucher advocates consider the last line of defense for opponents of
private school choice.
Scott wants
to expand a
voucher program that allows low - income and disabled students
to use public money
to go to private schools to ALL students.
Money for
school vouchers was originally scheduled for disbursement
to private schools on September 15, but that date was moved up
to allow funds
to go out the door prior
to today's hearing.