If 20 % of players buy gold, if most players are too low - level to encounter gold farmers, and if gold farming may stabilize some game economies, is it really the case that
gold farmers do more harm than good?
Gold farmers don't destroy the game?
My goal is not to justify what
gold farmers do, but rather to complicate the typical story we tell about gold farming.
Understanding why
gold farmers do what they do changes how they interact with them.
Not exact matches
Azeroth's economy is based on (virtual)
gold, and although it doesn't cost (real) money — notorious Chinese
gold farmers notwithstanding — it
does take time.
They didn't come from privilege or prep school; the nine young men in the University of Washington scull who won
gold in the 1936 Olympics, infuriating the Führer while the home crowd cheered, were the sons of
farmers, loggers and longshoremen.
EA wants to show to the world that is
doing something with
gold farmers but in my opinion they will lose.
Some
gold farmers actually don't mind their jobs because they hang around playing games for extensive periods of time.
I hate to stereotype all
gold farmers as Chinese, but the ones I've run into really
did seem like they weren't at all competent with the English language (though to be fair, that describes a fairly large chunk of the population, especially on the PvP servers).
As we've seen, most of the profit from
gold farming
does not go to the actual
gold farmers.
Over the past 6 months, several reports of who these
gold farmers are and what they
do has emerged and the overall picture is quite consistent.
I don't mind much of the presence of
gold farmers on my server, but there is a limit to the sympathy I give them.
I wrote a (hopefully) interesting post on how the subscription model affects MMO gameplay (it doesn't just predict hunting
gold -
farmers, it even predicts new MMOs will become increasingly LESS fun)
THAT»S why I hate the so - called «Chinese
Gold Farmers» (and no, I don't assume they're all chinese, but I
DO find them ALL to be leaches
DO find them ALL to be leaches.)
I don't really want to debate your underlying assumptions, such as whether or not
gold farmers cause inflation, whether or not 20 % of players buying
gold is an unrealistically high estimate, etc..
I think people intentionally fail to get the point that it doesn't matter WHAT country
gold farmers come from but that the MARKET is white and middle class.
If
gold farmers really are
doing more good than harm, how can their actions be unethical?
The fact that racists are using the
gold farming phenomenon as an opportunity to hurl racial epithets
does not affect the
gold farmers» moral culpability one way or the other.
What people mostly don't like is that
farmers create imbalance between «regular» players and
gold buyers.
Now comes my interest in all of this... The stereotypical Jewish businessman who is greedy and unwilling to share, as horrible a stereo type that it is, has survived for well over 500 years... How long will the Chinese
gold farmer label survive if nothing is
done to remove the connotations and worse, as MMORPGS are played by more people and terms from these games become more accepted by the wider community, how long till the first little white boy goes to school and offers to pay his Asian friend to
do his homework... or maybe it is already happening?
As I mentioned to Thezdin, apart from this rule itself,
do we really know whether
gold farmers are
doing more harm than good?
I'm not rich, in fact the average
gold farmer (Chinese or otherwise) makes a better living then I
do, so tell me again why they should be allowed again?
Race has a lot to
do with
gold farming because many players use racial cues to «identify»
gold farmers who they then label as hostile.
Why
do I dislike
gold farmers you may ask?
While there may be 24/7
gold farmers out there, that doesn't mean all of it comes from them.
That's why I don't think the metaphor is particularly apt, and why I think it
does tend to suggest the somewhat Marxist point of view that
gold farmers are not morally culpable for their actions because they are oppressed.
I don't think that is what was being said, once again someone has stated that they are effected as a player, not as a
gold farmer from an Eastern European country as opposed to an asian country, they are simply stating that their gaming enjoyment is ruined by the existence of
farmers.
Regardless, There are a few points which remain, WoW is a game whilst it has an economy and whilst it is possible to exploit that, it doesn t make it right regardless of who
does it or for what reason, so whilst I am disgusted by the appellation Chinese
gold farmer, I refuse to allow my distaste for the racism prevent me from hating the people
doing it!
In homemade World of Warcraft video clips that circulate on YouTube or GameTrailers, with titles like «Chinese
Gold Farmers Must Die» and «Chinese Farmer Extermination,» players document their farmer - killing expeditions through that same Timbermaw - ridden patch of WoW in which Min does his farming — a place so popular with farmers that Western players sometimes call it Chin
Farmers Must Die» and «Chinese
Farmer Extermination,» players document their
farmer - killing expeditions through that same Timbermaw - ridden patch of WoW in which Min
does his farming — a place so popular with
farmers that Western players sometimes call it Chin
farmers that Western players sometimes call it China Town.
Did the
gold farmers destroy the economy?
Not all
farmers are bad - players have to farm as part of the game Persistent
farmers are bad - the type that
do nothing but farm (since we know their
gold / items are used for sale, not personal use) Not all
farmers are rude The majority of
farmers seem to be Chinese (see above as to why) Chinese - speaking players are only encountered when they are farming Chinese
farmers are rude, train mobs, try to control an area, and are disruptive to players attempting to play in the same area Chinese
farmers monopolize an area, causing other players distress Non-Chinese
farmers typically
do not exhibit the rudeness and other negative attitudes / behaviors