It seems like a simple enough thing to do but it really is the defining thing that makes for
good film criticism.
The rest of the video highlights the things
good film criticism should do.
Overall, this is an extremely sharp video, and I couldn't agree with it more, particularly the part where Willems says: «If you like movies, you should read
good film criticism.
In his singular combination of rage and tenderness, it is some of
the best film criticism by a «literary» writer you can find.
A friend and colleague, critic and teacher Nicole Brenez, says that
the best film criticism consists of films critiquing one another.
Not exact matches
Anyone familiar with the more intellectual forms of pop
criticism (whether of music or
film) will recognize it as a parody of the Rolling Stone critic — a parody so
good that, for a moment, one is almost convinced the piece is the real thing:
I am disappointed that my
criticism of the
film was greatly edited down...
well, it was basically edited out completely.
When I think of the
criticism I really love, whether it's of books or
films or pop culture, it's when someone is a really
good observer of things.
Well Russ continued in his exploitive areas becoming a gigantic cult filmmaker, beloved by «geeks» everywhere, and Roger went into the
film criticism arena.
Criticisms like this all point to an underlying question: would it have been
better to just give us The Hobbit, on its own with none of the appendices, and let it be a lesser
film?
When it comes to
film criticism...
well, most people know as much about it as they do about the self - defrost mechanisms in their freezers.
«No End in Sight» — Iraq War
criticism that counted because of its levelheadedness — continues Nick Rogers» daily look back at the 365
best films of 2000 - 2009.
Singular in its distillation of Schrader's decades - spanning preoccupations of
film criticism and filmmaking as
well as his religious background, First Reformed is a rare object unified in subject and style.
This is
film criticism with a soul and a sense of urgency growing out of the conviction that faith and the imagination need one another — the
better to open our eyes to the flickerings of God's grace.»
The
film reviews are concise, thoughtful, and
well - rounded pieces of pop
film criticism — especially those by Todd McCarthy.
Perhaps due to the choices to cover older works, they're more able than ever to produce intelligent, thoughtful, and informative
criticism — while this article maligns their production value as no
better than «the average Youtube video,» editing a video review to provide context via clips of the
film is a step beyond what the vast majority of populist or even academic
film criticism has done in the past, let alone other related
films in the genre and in the director's oeuvre for context.
When Rooney Mara was announced as the chosen lead for this
film, the choice was met with quite a bit of
criticism as
well.
Since the writing is so smart and the performances — Hader and Wilson as
well as Wiig — so likable, it dodges the obvious
criticism that it subscribes to the
film industry standard that a gay character must always be unhappy.
These
criticisms may not be entirely fair, but ignoring them makes the
film feel something like a Hallmark channel movie, meant to make the viewers feel
good, even at the risk of over-sensationalizing a topic.
In the whole history of
film criticism and analysis there almost certainly hasn't been a
film so heavily written about in the vein of how much
better it could have been had the studio left it in its author's hands.
Better are an interview book translated from Spanish, Objects of Desire, and a recently published translation of selected writings by Bunuel in both Spanish and French, An Unspeakable Betrayal, which includes his priceless, poetic early
film criticism.
Hong Chau seemed like a breakout lock after Downsizing premiered in Venice, but subsequent screenings in Telluride and Toronto have badly dented that
film, particularly
criticisms that Chau's character is racially problematic — whether not she gives a
good performance.
I can appreciate the
criticisms leveled here but walking out of the theater after seeing this movie, I felt excited about
films again and wonderfully engrossed by this
well - told story.
I don't see the point in discussing
criticism, which is entirely subjective, and then couching a subjective statement like «Little Fockers isn't a
better film than Killing Them Softly» in an objective manner to support what is essentially a subjective argument masquerading as an objective argument.
Among the certainties in the world of
film criticism — there will be a series of pieces bemoaning critics» inability to stop a terrible summer
film from becoming a blockbuster; Armond White will often stake out a position in opposition to many of his fellow critics; movies about middle - aged men having their mid-life crises sorted out by women
well out of their league will always receive mostly kind notices; etc. — there's one that stands above all others.
But enough Intellectual
Film Criticism 101, is the
film any
good?
But when
films that the critics don't think are
best are declared
best by the public and the Oscar brand you invite
criticism for a group that supposedly rewards highest achievements in cinema, not just movies the public bought tickets for.
There's a compliment embedded in the
criticism that Anderson has gotten so
good over the course of just four
films, he's become a cliché.
With all these feuds now is as
good a time as any to address one of the stranger aspects of
film criticism in the post-modern era: the obsessive pursuit of critical consensus.
The extent to which a parent is able to fulfill this obligation is the extent to which The Pagemaster is worthwhile; using this
film as an eighty - minute babysitter - cum - opiate negates any possible positive effect conferred by the picture — raising the question, clearly, of how
best to approach
criticism of the piece.
Yes,
film criticism is subjective, and in the interest of
good journalism, I must report that many critics I respect are entertained by this movie, and I even believe that Perry will have a successful directing career.
Daily newspaper
film criticism at the national level is
better and deeper than it was in Corliss» golden age.
The episode also features a clip of Dario's deep discussion about
film criticism and contemporary
film culture with friend of the podcast Simran Hans, which can be found in full over on our Patreon site for subscribers, as
well as Neil's chat with
film critic and podcaster Leslie Byron Pitt about representation in filmmaking and
film criticism alongside as Basic Instinct and erotic thrillers as Leslie is one quarter of the excellent Fatal Attractions podcast.
It received
criticism from the likes of Jane Fonda and John Wayne — who in his last public appearance had to present it with it's
Best Picture award even though he wasn't fond of the
film.
About Prieur I can say a little more, because I own a rather
good 1980 collection of his
film criticism, Nuits blanches («White Nights»), that includes an essay on «Artaud and the Cinema»; the book's jacket informs me that Prieur was born in Paris in 1951, writes on
film and literature, and is — or was — the
film critic for La nouvelle revue francaise.
One may as
well ask what is the function of
film criticism: to guide the prospective viewer into places they might not go on their own, or to confirm for them what they already believe?
Sure,
good criticism (whether positive or negative) should encourage you to see a
film in new ways you may not have recognized before.
This observation isn't meant as a
criticism specific to this
film — Get On Up provides
good performances and its manipulation of time works
well to contrast the various stages of Brown's life in a unique and engaging way.
I've always preferred a generic approach to
film criticism; I ask myself how
good a movie is of its type.
This gay male gaze did not sit
well with many straight Bat - fans, and while Batman & Robin isn't
good, I realized in reading up on the
film for this podcast that a lot of the
criticism against it smacks of homophobia — in general and directed specifically at out director Joel Schumacher.
It might feel personal, but at times it feels as if cinema isn't worth it, that it doesn't matter how much time I spend developing projects, reading
criticism, writing it, making some experiments shooting, seeing
films... I won't ever be «
good» at it.
Opinion is not
criticism — and I'm not egotistical enough to believe that my favorite
films are also the
best films I've seen.
The group can genuinely be said to represent the
best of contemporary American
film criticism.
Gilderoy also suffers substantially, having to endure Francesco's condescension and
criticism as
well as Santini's passive - aggressiveness and defensiveness about the artistic merit of the
film, which Santini refuses to acknowledge as a horror.
Since more links are only considered a
good thing around here, here's Matt Singer's latest Criticwire Survey, asking participants for the
best piece of
film criticism of 2012.
As the act of transposing images, sounds, feelings into words, sentences, ideas,
film criticism is, I would venture, the
best school of writing there is — not just critical writing, but writing tout court.
The over-the-top nature of the «Fast and Furious» franchise has always been its greatest asset and its biggest
criticism, and there's no
better example of that than in some of the gleefully entertaining «Oh my god, I can't believe that just happened» insanity that takes place in the
film.
In a recent article on Tarkovsky, Julian Graffy notes that the Russian journal Kinovedcheskie zapiski (Notes in Cinema Analysis) asked 27 critics from around the world to list the twentieth century's 12
best films «from the point of view of history» and «from the point of view of
film criticism».
The one crucial
criticism I have of the
film is that, at
well over two hours, it's far too long.
And if the existence of an art form can be determined by the art
criticism to which it gives rise, then the
best gauge of the cinema's health, today, is the quality of
film writing.