Moberg et al also fail to show
the hockey stick by terminating the study prior to the modern uptick derived from the incorporation of the instrumental temperature record.
The latest attempt to resurrect
the hockey stick by Tingley and Huybers was quickly dismissed as more of the same using some statistical manipulation.
«The revealing of the 20th Century warming hoax follows the earlier debunking of
the Hockey Stick by Steve McIntyre and Ross McKitrick.
Although they reference the MBH study, they do not directly criticize it or mention
the hockey stick by name.
At least you appear to be one of the rare AGW» ers admitting the importance of solar forcing and who at the same time implicitly refutes Mann's
hockey stick by acknowledging the proxies that established the existence of the Little Ice Age, and for that matter, the Medieval Warm Period.
It all started with one person posting a picture of his porch light on and
his hockey stick by the door.
Not exact matches
In the middle space, where the small firms can hit a
hockey stick and grow, I'm quite excited
by this creation of the business growth fund, which is actually a private - sector initiative, but with certain rules that make it easier to happen.
And rarely, if ever, should the goal be the fast kind of «
hockey stick» growth that is associated with the tiny slice of startups who receive the majority of coverage
by tech - focused digital media covering startups: the extraordinarily rare company that obtains backing from a venture fund.
As observed
by hockey player, Sean Collins, although there is a plethora of factories dedicated to making
hockey sticks in China, there are few resellers, and his China - based team relies on China - made equipment imported from abroad.
(Can't use he double
hockey sticks without being censored
by a prudish American).
«We're not looking to create any sort of
hockey stick growth profile, but are going to keep up that growth pattern
by moving into the best, coolest, fun markets in America,» League says.
The
Hockey Stick and the Climate Wars: Dispatches from the Front Lines,
by Michael Mann.
The climate change «
hockey stick» is a graph first published in 1998
by Michael Mann et al. that attempted to reconstruct the mean surface temperature on the planet during the period A. D. 900 to the present, using multiple proxies, such as tree rings, to measure temperatures before formal instrumentation was in use.
One would have hoped it would have an outcome similar to the hurricane story, but the
hockey stick thing was exacerbated
by Michael Mann's behavior, trying to keep the data and all the information away from McIntyre, McKitrick, and other people who are skeptical of what they were doing.
The
hockey stick - shape temperature plot that shows modern climate considerably warmer than past climate has been verified
by many scientists using different methodologies (PCA, CPS, EIV, isotopic analysis, & direct T measurements).
It's fallen
by two - thirds to 2000 now: a real «
hockey stick» curve, and an instance of the UN's growing reliance on computer guesswork rather than facts»
The http://www.realclimate.org website, run
by two of the «
hockey -
stick» graph's authors, said the same in a blog entitled «Cuckoo science».»
However, we are still up against the second part of the «
Hockey Stick» the alleged surface temperature record, as promulgated
by Jones, Hansen and Karl., which continues to claim that the current temperature is «unprecedented»
Mr. Cuccinelli is well known for his harassment of Michael Mann, a climate scientist vilified
by industry apologists for creating the «
Hockey Stick» graph illustrating the increase of average global temperature measurements over the last millennium.
It replaced the graph with the now infamously debunked «
hockey stick graph»... and claimed the 1990's were
by far the warmest period -LSB-...]
If you look at the proxy portion of the new Moberg graphic, you see nothing that would be problematic for opponents of the
hockey stick: it shows a striking Medieval Warm Period (MWP), a cold Little Ice Age and 20th century warming not quite reaching MWP levels
by 1979, when the proxy portion of the study ends.
This was illustrated quite nicely
by the «Mann
hockey stick».
Enhanced Gameplay - An updated arsenal of highlight reel - worthy superstar moves, blocked shots,
stick - handling moves, hit -
by - puck collisions, and a greatly - enhanced skating engine make up for an exciting and all - new
hockey experience complete with more than 1,400 new gameplay animations.
You'll use both the Wii Remote and Nunchuk for
hockey, steering your player with the analog
stick and shooting the puck
by shaking the Wii Remote.
These dangers stem largely from the fact that each player plays the game with a
hockey stick, a piece of equipment that is capable of causing serious injury, but... minkey is part of the curriculum in many primary schools and this is testimony to its acceptance
by the community as being beneficial for young children.»
One
hockey stick on the porch was impactful but a wave of support was created
by «community» when many others did the same.
Rounding out the profile view are fender bulges front and rear, a
hockey stick style element punctuated
by a stroked version of Infiniti's signature fender vent, and a lower chrome sill piece that's part of a motorized step - up feature.
Similar brightwork elements frame the round wheel opening in a soft - topped parallelogram that appears created
by the
hockey -
stick sill trim piece.
Designed
by Larry Shinoda, their most distinguishing visual characteristic, the
hockey stick side striping, was introduced on the 1970 model.
They all sort of looked alike, too — the boys all wearing their maroon home
hockey jerseys and their hats backward, bright thatches of hair
stuck through the loops at their foreheads like the start of a fire; the girls carbon copies of Courtney,
by studious design.
It's like teaching your child to play
hockey by buying him a cool
stick rather than showing him how to pass, shoot and backcheck.
Second, present the graph with a log scale so the
hockey -
stick effect is hidden and the portfolios» growth rates are represented
by the lines» slopes.
And then in early 16», this chart reflected the massive credit injection
by the PBoC (China's central bank)
by hockey sticking upwards, which subsequently marked the nadir of the commodity / EM bear market.
There is an intro tutorial with a nice presentation
by Hockey Canada that features tutorials for the new additions to the deking system and the ability to actually control your
stick on defense.
Yet the basic conclusions of the «
hockey stick» remain, and indeed have been strengthened
by subsequent work.
I can't believe that we are still discussing the pathetic attempts
by those that are either irretrievably ignorant still trying to debunk the
hockey stick.
You can then respond
by saying but if Dr. Judith Curry is correct about the fact that there were, or even are, flaws still in the «
Hockey Stick» (as I (and others) have pointed out over, and over, and over, all models have flaws, in fact all models are wrong to some degree) then you and she are still barking up the wrong tree.
I think part of the problem with the
hockey stick is that it has been used so heavily
by the IPCC and others that it has become rather totemic for both sides of this debate.
Wegman is very unpopular with the warmists because his 2006 NRC report was very critical of the statistics used
by mann et al. in the creation of the
hockey stick.
Isotopious (# 50) argues that the
hockey stick (a thousand years of stable temperatures followed
by a rapid rise) does not constitute evidence of climate change, that it is in fact «absolutely nothing out of the ordinary».
Just to point out, every utterance of «
hockey stick» results in multitudes of counter posts
by the «auditors.»
Scientists respond to intimidation from Rep. Joe Barton (R - TX) RealClimate has the complete scoop on how scientists have responded to efforts to intimidate scientists
by Rep. Joe Barton (R - TX) over a particular detail (the now famous
hockey stick) in the climate science.
Because this is what's really important, the results stand regardless, and subsequent work
by Mann and many others have led to an entire team's worth of
hockey sticks.
I note without comment that The
Hockey Stick Illusion is published
by Stacey International Publishers.
The chief focus is the original
hockey stick, a reconstruction of past temperature for the northern hemisphere covering the last 600 years
by Mike Mann, Ray Bradley, and Malcolm Hughes (1998, Nature, 392, 779, doi: 10.1038 / 33859, available here), hereafter called «MBH98» (the reconstruction was later extended back to a thousand years
by Mann et al, 1999, or «MBH99»).
The CETR also shows a stronger
hockey -
stick shape than the central England series used
by MBH98, in part because it includes earlier data (from the late 17th century) than the Bradley and Jones dataset.
In reply, MM complained that the MBH98 PC1 (the
hockey -
stick shaped one) wasn't PC1 in the completely standard analysis, that normalization wasn't required for the analysis, and that «Preisendorfer's rule N» (the selection rule used
by MBH98) wasn't the «industry standard» MBH claimed it to be.
Salzer did show that there may have been a problem with the standardization used
by Graybill on the stripbark samples, but the newly developed chronologies still show a
hockey stick.
And as for the AIT, the
hockey stick only got a brief mention, and that was
by mistake (he used the wrong panel from a Lonnie Thompson paper).
If you don't know much about climate science, or about the details of the controversy over the «
hockey stick,» then A. W. Montford's book The Hockey Stick Illusion: Climategate and the Corruption of Science might persuade you that not only the hockey stick, but all of modern climate science, is a fraud perpetrated by a massive conspiracy of climate scientists and politicians, in order to guarantee an unending supply of research funding and political
hockey stick,» then A. W. Montford's book The Hockey Stick Illusion: Climategate and the Corruption of Science might persuade you that not only the hockey stick, but all of modern climate science, is a fraud perpetrated by a massive conspiracy of climate scientists and politicians, in order to guarantee an unending supply of research funding and political p
stick,» then A. W. Montford's book The
Hockey Stick Illusion: Climategate and the Corruption of Science might persuade you that not only the hockey stick, but all of modern climate science, is a fraud perpetrated by a massive conspiracy of climate scientists and politicians, in order to guarantee an unending supply of research funding and political
Hockey Stick Illusion: Climategate and the Corruption of Science might persuade you that not only the hockey stick, but all of modern climate science, is a fraud perpetrated by a massive conspiracy of climate scientists and politicians, in order to guarantee an unending supply of research funding and political p
Stick Illusion: Climategate and the Corruption of Science might persuade you that not only the
hockey stick, but all of modern climate science, is a fraud perpetrated by a massive conspiracy of climate scientists and politicians, in order to guarantee an unending supply of research funding and political
hockey stick, but all of modern climate science, is a fraud perpetrated by a massive conspiracy of climate scientists and politicians, in order to guarantee an unending supply of research funding and political p
stick, but all of modern climate science, is a fraud perpetrated
by a massive conspiracy of climate scientists and politicians, in order to guarantee an unending supply of research funding and political power.