Not exact matches
For example, a
holistic rubric might describe an A essay using the following criteria: «The essay has a clear, creative thesis statement and a consistent overall argument.
A
holistic rubric breaks an assignment down into general levels at which a student can perform, assigning an overall grade
for each level.
Students are still given clear explanations
for the grades they earned, but there is much more room to account
for a student taking a project in a direction that a
holistic or analytic
rubric didn't or couldn't account
for.
For example, many writing
rubrics (see example) are
holistic because it is not always easy to disentangle clarity from organization or content from presentation.
But
holistic rubrics can also be employed
for more substantial assignments.
In one, Herman, Gearhart, and Baker (1993) were able to get satisfactory levels of interrater agreement
for portfolios containing only narrative and summary writing, but they discovered that students» scores were substantially different across different contexts (standard writing prompt vs. portfolio work; analytic vs.
holistic rubrics; scoring of individual pieces vs. the total portfolio; narrative vs. summaries).
If point systems,
rubrics, or
holistic assessment methods are used
for other activities, these methods may also be used to evaluate students» extended projects.