NHC uses the GFDL
hurricane model as one of its main sources of forecast guidance.
A while ago Eli pointed to a 2005 article by Thomas Knutson and Robert Tulyea on
hurricane modeling as an example of fine climate snark
Not exact matches
While many people will point to
Hurricane Katrina and the 2005 damage done in New Orleans and along the Gulf Coast
as a
model for what we may expect from Harvey, the 2016 floods in Baton Rouge may be more realistic.
When Mother Nature wields her fury through natural disasters such
as tornadoes,
hurricanes and earthquakes, weather forecasters and emergency personnel alert local communities based on input they've received from event
modeling and simulations.
Despite being specialized for epidemics, Marathe says, the tool's underlying geographic
models and synthetic populations are general, and they can be applied to other kinds of disasters, such
as chemical spills,
hurricanes, and cascading failures in power networks.
Satellite imagery is used for all sorts of climate study, from identifying conditions that allow infectious diseases like West Nile virus and cholera to emerge, to creating
models for predicting
hurricanes, to distinguishing natural resources such
as wind, water and sunlight.
Unlike existing
models, FV3 can also re-create vertical air currents that move between boxes, such
as the updrafts that are a key element of
hurricanes as well
as tornadoes and thunderstorms.
• EXTREME WEATHER New radar and satellite technologies will allow forecasters to build better computer
models for extreme weather events, such
as tornadoes and
hurricanes.
Now, in a new $ 62 million, 5 - year program, the network of doomsday machines is expanding to simulate
hurricanes and tornadoes and is joining forces with computer
modeling to study how things too big for a physical test — such
as nuclear reactors or even an entire city — will weather what Mother Nature throws at them.
Using weather and sea data from the time of the sinking, along with a new theoretical
model, a Georgia Institute of Technology researcher has calculated that there was
as much
as a one - in - 130 chance — over a period of time and area — that a rogue wave 46 feet high (14 meters) could have occurred during the
hurricane.
For every
hurricane in the North Atlantic Basin between 1997 and 2013, they pulled information such
as mean sea - level pressure and temperature
as well
as vertical temperature and humidity profiles, and entered it into a thermodynamic
hurricane model that treats each storm
as a gigantic heat engine.
What he found was that not only were the simulations much closer to actual observations, but the high - resolution
models were far better at reproducing intense storms, such
as hurricanes and cyclones.
«It is difficult to use climate
models to study
hurricane activity, and so studies such
as ours, which produced a record of storms under different climate conditions, are important for our understanding of future storm activity,» Denniston said.
There is hope that attribution of
hurricanes and other dynamic weather events will improve
as scientists tinker on climate
models, said Adam Sobel, a climate scientist at Columbia University.
Seeing himself
as a strict empiricist whose
hurricane predictions are based on decades of «crunching huge piles of data,» Gray is convinced that the atmosphere is too complicated to be captured in computer simulations, at one point fulminating that «any experienced meteorologist that believes in a climate
model of any type should have their head examined.»
The other
model about
hurricanes, recently published in Icarus, predicts that the warming of the northern hemisphere could also bring
hurricanes, also known
as tropical cyclones.
To get a sense for how this probability, or risk of such a storm, will change in the future, he performed the same analysis, this time embedding the
hurricane model within six global climate
models, and running each
model from the years 2081 to 2100, under a future scenario in which the world's climate changes
as a result of unmitigated growth of greenhouse gas emissions.
She notes that a reliable proxy record for
hurricanes would be very useful
as a way of evaluating
models of storm activity.
But there, challenges also arise,
as models that simulate changing climate at a global scale do so at relatively coarse resolution, of around hundreds of kilometers, while
hurricanes require resolutions of a few kilometers.
So far, these early results showed that physical conditions where the air and the ocean interact must be a vital part of any successful
hurricane forecasting
model and would help explain, and predict, how a storm might intensify
as it moves through across the water based on the physical stress at the ocean's surface.
Modeling Animation: Storm - tide flooding of the Battery in New York City through several tidal cycles during
Hurricane Sandy
as modeled by Professor Harry Wang and colleagues at VIMS.
«Our job is to collect
as many observations
as we can to send to the National
Hurricane Center in Miami, and to NOAA's numerical
models center in Washington.»
Climate
models suggest that
hurricane intensity should increase
as the world warms, and that the most intense storms will become a bigger proportion of the total.
Also, unlike the bulk of climate
models to date, the increase in odds of extreme storms found in the study stems both from a shift toward more intense
hurricanes as well
as an overall increase in
hurricane frequency.
As we've reported previously, the JL
model will be lighter and more fuel - efficient, embracing aluminium to reduce weight and the
Hurricane 2.0 - litre turbocharged petrol four - cylinder at entry level.
(
As mentioned in the paper, when downscaling the GFDL CM2.1
model, rather than the ensemble mean, the number of
hurricanes stays roughly unchanged by the end of the 21st century, and we see a substantial increase in the strongest
model storms, those that exceed the surface pressure criterion for category 3.
The evolution of the
hurricanes is altered in some way by conditions other than SST (such
as humidity) in the various
models because the resulting intensity of the
hurricanes seems to be shifted somewhat surprisingly by a constant amount across all SSTs according to Figure 11.
Chan and Liu (2004) argue that current
models are not yet sufficiently good for addressing the question regarding global warming and typhoons (A typhoon is technically the same
as a
hurricane, the difference being that they form over the western Pacific or the Indean Ocean).
If you look just at SST changes, the maximum wind speed can be estimated by
modeling the
hurricane as a Carnot cycle heat engine.
All in all the science of
hurricanes does appear to be much more fun and interesting than the average climate change issue,
as there is a debate, a «fight» between different hypothesis, predictions compared to near - future observations, and all that does not always get pre-eminence in the exchanges about
models.
(
As an aside, we wonder how Gray, who is largely known for prediction of
hurricane behavior based on (statistical)
modeling, felt about this?).
2)
As with some previous potent winter storms and hurricanes (including Sandy), there's been a consistent focus on the computer model of the European Center for Medium - Range Weather Forecasts (ECMWF, for short) as the best at getting details like snowfall amounts righ
As with some previous potent winter storms and
hurricanes (including Sandy), there's been a consistent focus on the computer
model of the European Center for Medium - Range Weather Forecasts (ECMWF, for short)
as the best at getting details like snowfall amounts righ
as the best at getting details like snowfall amounts right.
Using a recently developed
hurricane synthesizer driven by large - scale meteorological variables derived from global climate
models, 1000 artificial 100 - yr time series of Atlantic
hurricanes that make landfall along the U.S. Gulf and East Coasts are generated for four climate
models and for current climate conditions
as well
as for the warmer climate of 100 yr hence under the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) emissions scenario A1b.
Here is why I think it matters: 1) Actively subverting FOIA intent 2) Admitting a) Hockey stick flawed & Steve is right, b) hide decline was dishonest, c) climate
models are pretty bad, and d) cherry picking results like Japan
hurricanes to emphasize a pre-ordained message 3) Trying to manipulate (and probably succeeding) who gets to be IPCC author 4) Trying to manage the message (PR concern) 5) Viewing science results
as helping or hurting «the cause» — Mann especially All the above subverts the official messages of «overwhelming consencus» and «science is settled», world's best scientists just doing their science, and that it would be «absurd» to see a conspiracy.
What he found was that not only were the simulations much closer to actual observations, but the high - resolution
models were far better at reproducing intense storms, such
as hurricanes and cyclones.
As the United States cleans up after one major hurricane and braces for another, optimists note that all this destruction could yield one positive result: As we experience bigger and more powerful storms — just as the models predicted — perhaps we'll finally come to grips with climate chang
As the United States cleans up after one major
hurricane and braces for another, optimists note that all this destruction could yield one positive result:
As we experience bigger and more powerful storms — just as the models predicted — perhaps we'll finally come to grips with climate chang
As we experience bigger and more powerful storms — just
as the models predicted — perhaps we'll finally come to grips with climate chang
as the
models predicted — perhaps we'll finally come to grips with climate change.
That means the «findings probably haven't faced
as rigorous a review
as they might have,» Ars Technica reported, but it does show Emanuel is confident in his
hurricane modeling, which has already been peer - reviewed.
'' «Global Green's «Solar for Sandy» initiative will serve
as a catalytic
model for the resilient, and green rebuilding of low - lying, coastal neighborhoods devastated by
Hurricane Sandy,»» stated Petersen.
For problems with coherent features, such
as hurricanes, thunderstorms, firelines, squall lines, and rain fronts, there is a need to adjust the numerical
model state by deforming the state in space (its grid)
as well
as by correcting the state amplitudes additively.
Basic physics predicts that
as we continue to increase greenhouse gasses,
hurricanes will get stronger (Emanuel, 1987) and climate
models confirm this (Knutson and Tuleya, 2004).
Most IPCC climate
models project an increase in the strength of tropical storms and
hurricanes as the oceans warm.
Scaling the results from both theory
as well
as climate
model projections suggest, then, that roughly 3 % of
hurricane rainfall today can be reasonably attributed to manmade global warming.
As a caution, one of the four
models examined (a respected
model) predicts fewer strong
hurricanes in a warmer world instead.
The research version of this computer
model, known by the acronym HWRF (pronounced «H WARF»), picks up on storm features that other
models typically miss altogether, such
as the evolution of the rain bands that pinwheel around a tropical storm or
hurricane.
It remains to be seen how much of an improvement the new HWRF
model will bring to this year's
hurricane forecasts, but the bar has been set so low that any progress would be heralded
as a breakthrough.
For example,
as part of HFIP, a group of researchers set up shop in Boulder, Colo., far from tropical weather systems, where they took advantage of high speed computer resources to duplicate a computer
model that the
Hurricane Center relies on to make its forecasts.
Until recently, insurers were convinced that their calculations for predicting
hurricane damage - known
as «catastrophe
models» - were accurate.
If you believe that government should intervene in markets to incentivize rapid reduction of greenhouse gas emissions, you can justify your preference with data, theories, and
models that predict increases in extreme weather events such
as hurricanes, droughts, and floods.
Data from an ocean glider equipped with a host of scientific instrumentation and deployed ahead of the storm allowed researchers not only to see how sediment was being redistributed by the
hurricane as the storm unfolded but also to compare their real - life observations with forecasts from mathematical
models.
However, a confident assessment of human influence on
hurricanes will require further studies using
models and observations, with emphasis on distinguishing natural from human - induced changes in
hurricane activity through their influence on factors such
as historical sea surface temperatures, wind shear, and atmospheric vertical stability.