Parent activist Megan Wolf, who testified about the bill during the Oct. 3 hearing at the State House, said the filing of the new enrollment policy took many by surprise and occurs while the public remains largely in the dark on details such as how the proposed unified enrollment process would work — including
its impact on school choice, equitable access and the BPS budget.
The outcome of the Florida case will have a resounding
impact on school choice across the nation as the state has served as model for other programs, and continues to be a leader in choice options.
If state policymakers want to dampen the regressive distributional effects of the 529 expansion, or enhance
its impact on school choice, or both, what options do they have?
Digital relevance is
impacting on school choice.
Not exact matches
I think it is important to point out that this isn't just an issue for middle class families who care deeply about their child's diet and are able to provide abundant healthy food
choices but
school menus have great
impact on many, many poor children who, through no fault of their own and often with no agency to change the situation, end up being pawns in the lunch tray wars.
The
choices you make about your own
schooling will have a great
impact on what your daughter sees as her own
choices.
But at least some
schools are finding children will eat healthier meals when offered a
choice and take nutrition to heart if they are taught about the positive
impacts on their bodies.
Indeed, I find little
impact either positive or negative of winning a
school -
choice lottery
on criminal activity for the 80 percent of students outside of this group.
Overall, I find that winning the lottery to attend a first -
choice school has a large
impact on crime for high - risk youth.
The positive
impacts on reading achievement observed for voucher users therefore reflect the incremental effect of adding private
school choice through the OSP to the existing
schooling options for low - income D.C. families.
The value given to art and design in
schools and colleges is
impacting on choice and provision of art and design qualifications offered for both higher and lower ability students
In three new articles published in Education Next, researchers with the Education Research Alliance for New Orleans (ERA - New Orleans) at Tulane University, directed by professor of economics, Douglas Harris, show the
impact of the reforms
on student performance; consider to what degree the city's system of
school choice provides a variety of distinct options for families; and take a careful look at the city's unique centralized enrollment system.
The study examines the
impact of winning a
school choice lottery
on dropout rates and crime for groups of students with different propensities to commit crimes, using an index of crime risk that includes test scores, demographics, behavior, and neighborhood characteristics to identify the highest - risk group.
However, others expressed skepticism about what I shall call the Overregulation Theory, and proposed alternative explanations for the LSP's poor results, while a few more raised concerns about the
impact of a more free - market
school choice system
on equity.
The three studies find neutral to positive
impacts of private
school choice on college enrollment and graduation, but with some variation:
In this episode of the podcast, Paul talks with Marty West about his new working paper
on the
impact of
school choice on non-cognitive skills.
Meanwhile, when it comes to statewide private -
school choice initiatives, the
impacts on student outcomes are mixed and experts disagree
on the best path forward.
Given the
impact of educational attainment
on a variety of economic and social outcomes, a positive result could have significant implications for the value of
school -
choice programs that include charter high
schools.
Peterson also points to research by Harvard University's Martin West and German economist Ludger Woessmann, who examined the
impact of
school choice on the performance of 15 - year - old students in 29 industrialized countries and «discovered that the greater the competition between the public and private sector, the better all students do in math, science and reading.»
The studies were conducted as a partnership with the
School Choice Demonstration Project at the University of Arkansas and look at the
impact of the vouchers
on student achievement and non-cognitive skills,
on racial segregation, and
on students attending nearby public
schools (competitive effects).
The Commission, chaired by Dr. Paul Hill of the University of Washington, carefully reviewed the research
on the
impact of
school choice on student achievement and included in its report the following statement: «The most rigorous
school choice evaluations that used random assignment... found that academic gains from vouchers were largely limited to the African - American students in their studies.»
Following our workshops
schools report the positive
impact on students associated with improved dietary consumption and lifestyle
choices;
A study by Matthew M. Chingos and Paul E. Peterson
on the long - term
impact of
school vouchers on college enrollment and graduation won the 2016 Association for Education Finance and Policy (AEFP) Prize awarded for Best Academic Paper on School Choice and R
school vouchers
on college enrollment and graduation won the 2016 Association for Education Finance and Policy (AEFP) Prize awarded for Best Academic Paper
on School Choice and R
School Choice and Reform.
Multiple evaluations, by organizations ranging from the Manhattan Institute to the Urban League, have found the
choice programs to have had a positive
impact on Florida public
schools.
The market - and
choice - oriented policies, which were imposed
on schools «in need of improvement,» have consumed resources and local administrative time but have small
impacts and are not being seriously evaluated.
Despite the numbers, the
school choice programs are not large enough to have had more than a limited statewide
impact on the millions of students attending Florida's public
schools.
Using the Regulatory
Impact Scale I created, I show (1) the impact of a state's private school regulations before any school choice program existed; (2) the immediate regulatory impact that comes with the creation of initial regulations for a school choice program; (3) the impact of changes and additions to the regulations for a school choice program as policymakers revisit school choice programs after their first year of operation; (4) the total regulatory impact the school choice program has had on participating private schools; and (5) the total regulatory impact of all regulations, both before and during school choice programs, on private sc
Impact Scale I created, I show (1) the
impact of a state's private school regulations before any school choice program existed; (2) the immediate regulatory impact that comes with the creation of initial regulations for a school choice program; (3) the impact of changes and additions to the regulations for a school choice program as policymakers revisit school choice programs after their first year of operation; (4) the total regulatory impact the school choice program has had on participating private schools; and (5) the total regulatory impact of all regulations, both before and during school choice programs, on private sc
impact of a state's private
school regulations before any
school choice program existed; (2) the immediate regulatory
impact that comes with the creation of initial regulations for a school choice program; (3) the impact of changes and additions to the regulations for a school choice program as policymakers revisit school choice programs after their first year of operation; (4) the total regulatory impact the school choice program has had on participating private schools; and (5) the total regulatory impact of all regulations, both before and during school choice programs, on private sc
impact that comes with the creation of initial regulations for a
school choice program; (3) the
impact of changes and additions to the regulations for a school choice program as policymakers revisit school choice programs after their first year of operation; (4) the total regulatory impact the school choice program has had on participating private schools; and (5) the total regulatory impact of all regulations, both before and during school choice programs, on private sc
impact of changes and additions to the regulations for a
school choice program as policymakers revisit
school choice programs after their first year of operation; (4) the total regulatory
impact the school choice program has had on participating private schools; and (5) the total regulatory impact of all regulations, both before and during school choice programs, on private sc
impact the
school choice program has had
on participating private
schools; and (5) the total regulatory
impact of all regulations, both before and during school choice programs, on private sc
impact of all regulations, both before and during
school choice programs,
on private
schools.
RH: Given how polarizing the president is, what
impact has Trump had
on support for private -
school choice?
But the results of this investigation nonetheless advance our understanding of the effects of
school choice policies by providing the first experimentally generated information
on the long - term
impact of a voucher intervention.
Florida's voucher program for students in the lowest - rated public
schools is unconstitutional, the state supreme court ruled last week in a 5 - 2 decision that friends and foes of private
school choice are scrutinizing for its potential
impact on voucher debates nationwide.
Taken as a whole, information about local
school rankings has a less substantial
impact on public thinking about teacher policy than it has
on thinking about
school choice policies.
It is simply incorrect to claim, as the AEI authors did, that «a
school choice program's
impact on test scores is a weak predictor of its
impacts on longer - term outcomes.»
Debates about
school choice policies often focus
on their
impacts on student achievement, typically as measured by standardized tests.
With high
impact, brightly coloured packaging, it appeals to brand - savvy youngsters who will often simply walk out the door and buy something
on the high street if they don't like the
choice in the
school canteen.
So is it true, as Hitt, McShane, and Wolf claim, that «a
school choice program's
impact on test scores is a weak predictor of its
impacts on longer - term outcomes»?
What
impact will privatization and
choice have
on public
schools?
To the extent that better information improves the match between families and
schools or leads to pressure
on schools to increase measured achievement, this effect can augment the
impacts of
school -
choice policies.
As the authors put it, «A
school choice program's
impact on test scores is a weak predictor of its
impacts on longer - term outcomes.»
A new paper argues that a
school choice program's
impact on test scores is a weak predictor of its
impacts on longer - term outcomes.
After running a variety of analyses, Hitt, McShane, and Wolf concluded that «A
school choice program's
impact on test scores is a weak predictor of its
impacts on longer - term outcomes.»
If we focus only
on the true
school choice programs — private
school choice, open enrollment, charter
schools, STEM
schools, and small
schools of
choice — and we look at the direction of the
impacts (positive or negative) regardless of their statistical significance, we find a high degree of alignment between achievement and attainment outcomes.
By taking into account factors such as where a child lives and their attainment at
school, the research provides a unique analysis of how educational
choices made at the age of 16 can have a deep
impact on a child's future career and earnings.
The
impacts of
school choice programs
on test score gains and longer term outcomes are not really as out of sync as they may first appear.
The report reflects the
impact of social media
on children's book
choices, with Zoella's 10 million YouTube subscribers helping Girl Online to become the most popular book in the report from Renaissance Learning, which looks in detail at the reading habits of 725,369 children from 3,306 UK
schools.
All week I've been digging into a recent AEI paper that reviews the research literature
on short - term test - score
impacts and long - term student outcomes for
school choice programs.
If charter
schools were having no
impact on student achievement, if such
schools were merely selecting better students, then it would be an easy
choice to vote against the charter cap increase.
As policymakers consider the design, expansion, or reform of private
school choice programs, they should carefully examine not just a program's likely
impact on short - term metrics such as test scores, but also how it might shape long - term outcomes, including college enrollment and graduation.
They looked at a bunch of
school choices studies and tried to see if a
school's
impact on student test scores was connected to its
impact on student life outcomes.
Their conclusion: «at least for
school choice programs, there is a weak relationship between
impacts on test scores and later - life outcomes.»
Abstract: This article analyzes the
impact of classroom characteristics and opportunity wages
on four possible labor market
choices of teachers in Florida: remaining at their present
school, switching
schools within a
school district, changing
school districts, and leaving teaching.