Eric, It's not that the ratio of good to bad in indie books is the same as the ratio of good to bad
in trad books, it's just that the good indie books rise to the top.
In the trad book world, hardcover books are given freely to reviewers, but in Amazon's world, where a free video game or computer may be given to a reviewer rather than a mere book, it can seem like a bribe.
Not exact matches
We are
in a flood of authors and
books, and it doesn't matter if you are a
Trad - Author or Indie Author we all float the same and we're on our own.
Anne, there is no question that my humour column blog (www.melodiecampbell.com — forgive the mention) was instrumental
in getting me that first publishing contract at Orca
Books, a large Canadian
trad publisher.
The worst thing on the planet for me would be where
trad publishers start paying 50 % or more to their authors, and lose their battle with Amazon, only to see their
books priced
in the weeds.
We asked her a bunch of questions about what she found
in regard to author income,
books on sale, and whether indie or
trad publishing is more likely to get a person to a living wage (which she defined as the U.S. average of $ 32,000 a year).
I tend to keep with the above list, especially for science fiction and fantasy, because that is how print
books in those genres (from
trad publishers) open their
books.
You are right
in that there are a lot of bad indie
books out there, but I also think there are a lot of bad
trad books out there... some of which are indie publishers that got picked up by
trad publishers because readers loved the
books.
Kozlowski is the only person I know oblivious enough to include a graph of daily ebooks showing indie
books making up nearly 50 % of the US ebook market, and then
in the very next paragraph babble about them only being a «drop
in the bucket» relative to the
trad - published side.
I'm hoping to get the best of both worlds, so to speak - get some of my
books out there for «immediate consumption» (so to speak), and establish credibility
in the writing community through
trad.
Books 2 and 3
in that «City of God» series are selling well and earning much better than they did
in their first editions as
trad - pubbed novels.
That's why
trad publishers still have a lot to offer, especially
in the marketing area... they get your
books out to the right newspapers, they get your
book up for literary prizes... indeed, any newbie signing a contract tese days should take a very close look at the type of marketing the
trad publisher is committed to undertake...
This is how I sold my first several
books and how many of my
trad - pubbed friends broke
in to publishing and I have long believed it's the best way to make contacts.
I've been fielding emails for years from readers asking why that
book was priced so high when the rest of the
books in the series (this is the series that started out
in trad pub and that is now self pub) ranged from free to about $ 4.99.
But none
in the traditional publishing arena, because, however lousy one reader or another may think a
trad - pubbed
book, at the very least SOMEBODY liked it besides the author.
She only has one indie
book out, while all the rest are
trad... and when she didn't get a
book out for two years (three since the last one
in that series), she still had fairly good sales, as many of her fans were happy to read anything she'd put out.
A publisher friend of mine assures me that
trad publishers still get greater visibility for their
books in ebook stores (unless it hits the Amazon top 100) and you only have to look at what pops up when you go anywhere and you can see the truth
in that.
Another reason your
trad pubbed
books may sell well
in print versions is because there are lots and lots of readers
in that market — by the accounts I have read 60 - 70 % of total — and many of them prefer print, or to find reads
in physical locations.
I have people writing to me on Facebook and
in email and talking to me
in person about how much they love my
books, and here I am envying the awards and the accolades, certain that a
trad pub deal was the only way I could get them.
However, we know they're elitists from things they've said
in the past about self - published
books being of lesser quality compared to
trad pub
books (how ironic that now
trad pub authors are complaining more about their
books having so many typos and problems when printed).
But one reason I won't be publishing a lot more middle grade is because I also like to sell
books... and it's just very hard to do that
in indie MG (or
trad - pub MG, to be honest — the market is simply smaller).
Second, what I was saying that if Good Writer writes Good
Book and sends it to either market —
trad or self pub —
in a proper, professional manner, they seem to have roughly equal success rates.
When a
trad - pub
book weighs
in at $ 9.99 and you can buy somewhere between two to four times as much reading material from Indie authors, the choice seems obvious.
Literary fiction never did well
in indie publishing because it depends on reviews from the big, well known journals like the New Yorker, the NYT
book review, the TLS, the Guardian, the NY Review of
Books, etc, and they only review
trad pub.
Or perhaps someone whose
books have been
trad - pubbed
in some countries but not
in others.
I'm an indy - author since trying the
trad - publishing route
in 2005 - 06 with my first two
books (historical novels, which several agents looked at, and said regretfully that they were very good... but just not marketable.)
I'm trading the indie ebook market (which I think the
book has peaked
in) for the
trad pub ebook market
Sometime
in the late 1990s, when I began ghostwriting, and writing business
books for
trad publishers, I launched my first blog.
Because I view all of that as found money, and because it highlights that even if you're not madly pursuing a
trad deal, good agents still have a valuable role they can play
in the mix, even with indie published
books.
I think when the first AE report came out, July 2014, showing the sales shares of indie vs
trad pub genre
books, was the moment I realized that the Tra Pubs were
in deep, deep, pre-processed grass and oats.
Yes, your initial
trad - pub
books will probably bring
in less money than your later self - pubbed
books, but that's not necessarily a bad trade - off.
As for spelling mistakes with indies, yeh, some but no more than I've found
in the
trad published
books.
One advantage NY
Trads have appears to be
in the editing process (and of course print distribution), however with POD services the print distribution for a
book can be as broad as ebook distribution.
Many go indie
in the hopes that their
book will be discovered by traditional publishers, only to find that after doing all the work it makes no sense to go
trad.
Yes, there is a great deal of dreck
in self - published
books, but have you taken a really good look at
trad pubbed
books lately?
Then
in November of 2012, Hugh Howey negotiated a deal whereby he kept the digital rights, and
in February of last year Colleen Hoover negotiated a deal to sell just the print rights to one
book, without signing one of the indentured servitude contracts the
trads are so fond of.
Your article could have helped people avoid the bad indie
books, yet you decided instead to write an article perpetuating the myth that all indie
books are vanity tripe and inferior
in quality to
trad pubbed
books, which is patently untrue.
It dramatically helps
trad authors to buy their
books in the first week, and I want my favorite authors to keep publishing.
Since we're making outlandish, provocative (and unsubstantiated) claims, I'll concur with the response that
trad published authors are lazy because they don't want to put
in the time and effort to produce or market their
books.
But you may be an indie - only reviewer, so you wouldn't be interested
in a
trad - pub
book in any case.
Joe's initiative is great, but if we could inform our readers that the money they spend on taxes going to libraries is practically only devoted to
trad pub
books and ebooks, and that this doesn't reflect EXACTLY, for instance the indie market share of the first retailer
in the world, maybe things would advance a little bit
in the right direction.
It would also be great if Author Earnings could study this, and compare the money made by a
trad pub author
in libraries vs an indie author's, and also the raw numbers of
books trad published
in libraries vs indie published.
The impression I get is that plenty of good
books have alway stalled
in the
trad - pub slush piles and querying processes, too.
So not only were my self - published
books not included
in my bio, the original
trad - published
book in the series (from Midnight Ink) wasn't, either.
I think that writers who are interested
in being a hybrid for * non * financial reasons (validation, because Mom dreamed of seeing our
book on a shelf at B&N), will obviously find plenty of good reasons to choose
trad publishing.
I review all of my
trad pub royalty statements when they come
in, but I'm not sure what I should be looking for beyond checking that the various royalty rates are as they should be and running the math (cost of
book x royalty rate x no.
Not long ago I was talking to a traditionally published author who saw what I was doing — stories, novellas, novelettes, non-fiction, backlist (all
in addition to my
trad books)
Amazon introduced Kindle Unlimited, which enables customers to pay $ 10 a month and borrow as many
books as they like — with the caveat that only some titles are
in the program, which pays $ 1.33 for a borrow instead of the royalty an author would normally see (except for Amazon imprints and
trad pubs, which see their full royalty on a borrow); a windfall for those writing 10K short stories or serials, but not so great for those with novels, hence limited participation.
Add
in the price factor (Print On Demand
books tend to be more expensive than
trad - pub print runs), and it's tough to get those paper
books into kids hands.
In the case of Vanquish Writer's Block (and my other self - pub books), I knew that in many cases they were too short for a trad house to pick up AND I knew I could get them out to my readers faster and more effectivel
In the case of Vanquish Writer's Block (and my other self - pub
books), I knew that
in many cases they were too short for a trad house to pick up AND I knew I could get them out to my readers faster and more effectivel
in many cases they were too short for a
trad house to pick up AND I knew I could get them out to my readers faster and more effectively.