More specifically, looking at the data from state school report cards has taught us to question every dramatic claim that Mr. Duncan makes about
individual turnaround schools.
Not exact matches
In the world of
schooling, the majority of highly successful
turnaround cases seem to be those where an
individual educator had not only the right idea about instruction, but also the tenacity to bend or break those rules that would have prevented meaningful changes at the
school level.
Even if most
individual turnaround attempts fail, you can achieve a cumulative success rate of 70 or 80 % by retrying rapidly: bringing a new, more capable leader; closing the
school and starting fresh with a new operator; or closing the
school altogether and dispersing the students to other, better
schools.
In general, most
turnaround efforts have focused on improving
individual schools, with less attention paid to changing the
school - system level conditions that contributed to the chronic underperformance in the first place.
Equally astonishing is their decision to put a non-certified
individual in charge of Connecticut's
school turnaround program.
Individual school turnarounds are hard to do because principals usually don't control budgets (which usually means teachers) or personnel decisions (also teachers)-- those are governed by the central office, by state laws influenced by lobbying by affiliates of the National Education Association and American Federation of Teachers, and collective bargaining agreements that protect veteran teachers regardless of their performance.
It's been three years since Tennessee implemented the Achievement
School District (ASD), a statewide district to
turnaround the state's lowest - performing
schools by pulling
individual schools under state control.
When Louisiana and Tennessee wanted to focus on their lowest - performing
schools, they created statewide
turnaround districts, which pull
individual schools under state control.
After years of working in
schools beset by
turnaround programs that turned a blind eye to our
individual experiences and communities, I now work in a
school with a high capacity for responding to new demands and improving instruction.