We use
isotope data from Zachos et al. [4], which are improved over data used in our earlier study [5], and we improve our prescription for separating the effects of deep ocean temperature and ice volume in the oxygen isotope record as well as our prescription for relating deep ocean temperature to surface air temperature.
A new database brings together water
isotope data from many sources, providing an integrated resource for studying changes in Earth's hydroclimate over the past 2,000 years.
Thus recent events described in AGW denier's blogs are following the same pattern of strange events in the past, including the effort to hide xenon
isotope data from the 1995 Galileo probe of Jupiter:
>... there are still ways of discovering the temperatures of past centuries,... tree rings... Core samples from drilling in ice fields... historical reconstruction... coral growth,
isotope data from sea floor sediment, and insects, all of which point to a very warm climate in medieval times.
Here we present coupled high - resolution carbon - and sulfur -
isotope data from four European OAE 2 sections spanning the Cenomanian — Turonian boundary that show roughly parallel positive excursions.
The researchers used the measured temperatures from these two sites and
the isotope data from the ice core from the overlapping time period (a method called «scaling») to quantitatively reconstruct earlier temperature variations.
Strontium
isotope data from the Danube Gorges in the north - central Balkan show Europe's first farmers were immigrants.
This interpretation was based on water
isotope data from central Greenland ice cores.
If Trenberth, Abraham and Gleick wanted to protect the integrity of climate science, they would ask why NASA hid
isotopes data from the 1995 Galileo probe of Jupiter (finally released at press conference in 1998 [1]-RRB- that confirmed 1975 - 1983 findings [2 - 5]:
Not exact matches
In order to determine its origin, Italian scientists took a tiny sample
from the blade and compared the proportion of lead
isotope — a kind of «finger print» of the ore deposits which remains unchanged in any objects subsequently made
from the ore — with the corresponding
data from numerous mineral deposits in Europe and the entire Mediterranean region.
J. You / Science;
Data: «Climatic signals in multiple highly resolved stable
isotope records
from Greenland,» Vinther et al, 3 November 2009; «Norse Greenland settlement,» Dugmore et al., 2007; «Human diet and subsistence patterns in Norse Greenland AD c. 980 — AD c. 1450,» Arneborg et al. 2012
It is measurable in terms of oxygen and carbon
isotope ratios and was compared to «environmental archive»
data from other parts of the earth.
Data from the GPS units helped confirm that the conclusions they drew
from feather
isotopes were accurate.
Not Ernö Rubik's latest toy, but the
data from a four - year experiment to measure the half - life of the rare radioactive
isotope silicon - 32.
The paleoclimate
data, which included mainly changes in the oxygen
isotopes of the calcium carbonate deposits, were then compared to similar records
from other caves, ice cores, and sediment records as well as model predictions for water availability in the Middle East and west central Asia today and into the future.
Analysis of the stable
isotope control
data was funded in part by a grant
from the Fishmongers» Company, one of London's medieval Livery Companies, which retains responsibility for quality control at London's Billingsgate fish market.
As for the geochemical
data, it is based on Mg / Ca in foraminifera, alkenone unsaturation in sediments and some sparse
data from other techniques such as Ca
isotopes, clumped
isotopes and TEX86.
The scientists behind the research,
from Europe and North America, didn't get their
data from a magical ancient pH - sensing prototype, but by analyzing
isotopes from algae that grew amongst sampled coral.
It basically says that ringwidth is a function of: age trend + climate signal + endogenous (local) disturbances + exogenous (standwide) disturbances + unexplained variation Basically, this concept also underlies all other dendro proxies, be it maximum latewood density or stable
isotope ratios, even though there are variations, e. g. age trend in density
data is treated differently
from ring width
data).
The isotopic
data evaluated above is derived
from the fractionation of the naturally occuring stable
isotopes of Carbon, 12 and 13.
The CO2 level comes
from half a dozen different ice core analyses, while the temperature
data come
from marine sediments, pollen analyses,
isotopes, corals etc..
The evidence that the current rises of both CO2 and CH4 are anthropogenic are overwhelming (
from isotope data, O2
data, ocean
data, emission inventories etc.).
Sunspot observations (going back to the 17th century), as well as
data from isotopes generated by cosmic radiation, provide evidence for longer - term changes in solar activity.
Carbon
isotope data (obtainable in biological materials such as tree rings that can extend back long before the atomic bomb explosion in 1945) demonstrates that atmospheric CO2 has exhibited a reduction in the C14 / C12 ratio commensurate with a rise in total CO2 concentration to an extent indicating that the additional carbon coming
from any postulated unidentified source (e.g., outside of deforestation) must have been lacking in C14.
Individual model parameterizations were constrained by paleontological
data, and the overall modeled relationship between global temperature and sea level matched well against records
from four previous warm periods: preindustrial, the last interglacial, marine
isotope stage 11, and the mid-Pliocene.
Like the
data used right through 0.02 to 66 My, the Freidrich et al collection comprises stable oxygen
isotope ratios
from the shells of tiny bottom - dwelling, deep - water marine organisms (benthic foraminifera).
«The solar and volcanic forcings we use are derived
from reconstructions based on proxy
data and are therefore also subject to considerable uncertainties, although recent explosive volcanic eruptions are likely to have cooled climate, and independent records of solar activity levels inferred
from the cosmogenic
isotope 10Be (43) and geomagnetic records (44) provide support to reconstructions (22, 45) that show generally increasing solar activity during the 20th century (12).»
We studied a high - resolution multiproxy
data set, including magnetic susceptibility (MS), CaCO3 content, and stable
isotopes (δ18O and δ13C),
from the stratigraphic interval covering the uppermost Maastrichtian and the lower Danian, represented by the pelagic limestones of the Scaglia Rossa Formation continuously exposed in the classic sections of the Bottaccione Gorge and the Contessa Highway near Gubbio, Italy.
This is not
isotope data, as one usually sees
from ice cores.
Early TRL projects focused on establishing long tree - ring records
from temperature - sensitive boreal forest locations in North American for studies of global change, using dendrochronologically dated wood, to investigate the value of stable
isotope ratios in cellulose as paleo - thermometers and developing the necessary computer software for processing the
data.
Isotopes of carbon and oxygen were sampled on an annual time scale while all environmental
data was finer - grained, ranging
from half - hourly to monthly.
My analysis of the
isotope data indicates that about one third of the CO2 accumulation is
from organic sources and two - thirds
from inorganic.
This is a similar value to the ~ 5 years found
from 13C / 12C carbon
isotope mass balance calculations of measured atmospheric CO2 13C / 12C carbon
isotope data by Segalstad (1992); the ~ 5 years obtained
from CO2 solubility
data by Murray (1992); and the ~ 5 years derived
from CO2 chemical kinetic
data by Stumm & Morgan (1970).
An examination of the
data from: i) measurements of the fractionation of CO2 by way of Carbon - 12 and Carbon - 13
isotopes; ii) the seasonal variations of the concentration of CO2 in the Northern Hemisphere; and iii) the time delay between Northern and Southern Hemisphere variations in CO2, raises questions about the conventional explanation of the source of increased atmospheric CO2.
The modulation potential used in the calculations is based on the composite of
data determined
from the cosmogenic
isotope records of 10Be and a neutron monitor.
While there is obviously ongoing «skeptic» interest in a Holocene perspective, such commentary (e.g. recent WUWT posts) is far too often limited to a Northern Hemisphere (Greenland) perspective and, in particular, to the problematic Cuffey - Clow temperature reconstruction
from GISP2 (which ends in 1855, though GISP2
isotope data is available to 1987).
I have repeatedly pointed out (in several places including WUWT) that (1) ice core
data are useful because they indicate CO2 concentration and
isotope - derived temperature
data from the same trapped gas bubbles but (2) ice core
data are NOT a direct indication of anything because (2a) different ice cores provide different indications and (2b) other proxies (e.g. stomata
data) provide different indications to those of the ice cores and to each other.
Although a previous estimate based on this approach yielded a MAT of approximately — 5 °C, additional information
from oxygen
isotopes in mosses at the site allowed us to calculate isotopic enrichment in the cellulose of fossil trees, thereby reducing assumptions and increasing the precision of our MAT estimates (see the
Data Repository).
Schmidt, G.A., 1999: Forward modeling of carbonate proxy
data from planktonic foraminifera using oxygen
isotope tracers in a global ocean model.
Isotope Data Suggests Fossil Fuels Not to Blame for Increase Methane bubbles up
from swamps and rivers, belches
from volcanoes, rises
from wildfires, and seeps
from the guts of cows and termites (where is it made by microbes).
The three evidences of the United Nations Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), that the apparent contemporary atmospheric CO2 increase is anthropogenic, is discussed and rejected: CO2 measurements
from ice cores; CO2 measurements in air; and carbon
isotope data in conjunction with carbon cycle modelling.
The researchers were able to discern agricultural methane
from other sources of methane by looking at the gas» isotopic signatures — or the ratio of various carbon
isotopes — using
data from atmospheric monitoring stations around the world.
The scientists initially determined the rate of the LIS collapse using «radiocarbon dates of organic matter and marine shells, cosmogenic dates
from the surface of boulders, and the composition of
isotopes in marine sediment cores», but then the scientists also used a state - of - the art climate model to see if its results would bear out the paleoclimate
data.
Hegerl et al. (2006) used a mixture of 14 regional series, of which only 3 were not made up
from tree ring
data (a Greenland ice O
isotope record and two composite series,
from China and Europe, including a mixture of instrumental, documentary and other
data).
Their research, published in Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B, examined a wide range of published
data arising
from satellite imagery, charcoal records in sediments and
isotope - ratio records in ice cores, to build up a picture of wildfire in the recent and more distant past.
The main panel 1
data is
from stable oxygen
isotope measurements
from the shells of macroscopic marine organisms («fossil shells»), collected by Veizer et al (1999), as re-interpreted by Royer et al (2004).