There is no doubt that the CO2 is from fossil sources, as
isotope ratios show that the carbon has been less exposed to galactic cosmic rays (GCRs).
«We found that lithium
isotope ratios show a... peak around this time, and we can model that as being due to a decrease in silicate weathering during this cooling time period,» Pogge von Strandmann said.
Their carbon -
isotope ratio shows that all of a sudden there was a lot more light carbon - 12 — the kind that living organisms favor, the kind in seafloor hydrates — in the water around the forams.
3b) Analysis of carbon -
isotope ratios shows that the additional carbon in the atmosphere is fossil carbon.
Not exact matches
More recently, researchers have
shown that the
ratio of
isotopes in feathers can provide a rough guide to where a bird has been feeding, because the feather
ratios mirror those of food sources.
Knowing that strontium derived from land
shows a slightly higher
ratio of strontium 87 than strontium derived from hydrothermal circulation, the scientists compared
isotopes in each type of barite.
Analysis of
isotope ratios in hair samples
showed how much of the bears» diets came from human food.
«We therefore had to use a different method, so we measured the composition of carbon
isotopes — the
ratio of protein and mineral content — in the fossilized sloth bones,» explains Bocherens, and he continues, «Our measurements
show that Megatherium lived on an exclusively vegetarian diet.»
Ancient sediments that once resided on a lake bed and the ocean floor
show sulfur
isotope ratios unlike those found in other samples from the same time, calling into question accepted ideas about when the Earth's atmosphere began to contain oxygen, according to researchers from the U.S., Canada and Japan.
u «The moon rocks, however,
showed [oxygen
isotope]
ratios markedly similar to those of rocks from Earth.
Investigation of ash sediments from recent Mt. Pinatubo eruptions and other major volcanic events
show a signature of mass independent
isotope ratios of sulfur, while sediment from minor eruption does not.
Surprisingly, both samples» sulfur
isotope ratios fall in the mass - dependent fractionation range and do not
show the signal of an oxygenless atmosphere.
Initial SAM results
show an increase of 5 percent in heavier
isotopes of carbon in the atmospheric carbon dioxide compared to estimates of the isotopic
ratios present when Mars formed.
Minerals and
isotopes in these zircons
show that water and granite were also present.38 The extremely low
ratio of 13C to 12C suggests that all these carbon
isotopes were not originally present.
The thread here http://www.realclimate.org/index.php?p=87 that makes that claim does not
show that quantitatively (e.g. does not take into account natural variations in carbon
isotope ratios).
Here's a link
showing one way carbon
isotope ratios can vary naturally.
Isotope ratios of carbon are one very strong line of evidence to
show that the increase in CO2 comes from the burning of fossil fuels.
Tests
showed the
ratio of the nitrogen - 15
isotope to the more common nitrogen - 14
isotope had changed from pre-industrial times to the present.
Laboratory PhD Matteus Lindgren is
showing some hardware of the MAT 253
Isotope Ratio Mass Spectrometer to Assoc. prof, Giuliana Panieri, laboratory manager Trine Dahl and Director of CAGE Jürgen Mienert.
This analytical document
shows that stable
isotope ratios can be used to monitor changes in the character of precipitation in response to periodic variability or changes in climate.
Thus even if more C4 plants are grown, that changes the amounts of 12CO2 which is absorbed vs. 13CO2, but as long as the O2 levels
show that the biosphere is a net sink for CO2 (whatever the type), more 12CO2 leaves the atmosphere than 13CO2, compared to the atmospheric
isotope ratio.
Plotting the
isotope ratio's will
show the temperature history, but not calibrated to temperature.
Also, the carbon
isotope ratios are supposed to
show that the increase is anthropogenic (from using burning «old carbon», less C14 or deduced by C13 / C12
ratios, etc..)
Mona Loa dCO2 / dT (Fraction of emission «
showing up» in atmosphere) Also: Spencer Part2: More CO2 Peculiarities — The C13 / C12
Isotope Ratio
There are a multitude number of pieces of evidence for this, stemming from mass balance arguments, changes in
isotopes, O2 / N2
ratios, observed changes in carbon in other sources (acting as a sink), paleo - sensitivity studies
showing that CO2 is a relatively slow and weak feedback (~ 10 ppm / C), etc..
Paleo temperatures from oxygen
isotope ratios from the greenland ice cores
show that a temperature increase of 0.7 °C will not bring the current temperature up to the level of the Medieval Warm Period let alone the Roman optimum and the MInoan Warm period which were both warmer than the medieval warm period.
Carbon and oxygen
isotope ratios both shift at the same boundary; the former
shows disruption of the carbon cycle, while the latter
shows an abrupt warming of about 6 degrees.
13 - C / 12 - C
isotope mass balance calculations
show that IPCC's atmospheric residence time of 50 - 200 years make the atmosphere too light (50 % of its current CO2 mass) to fit its measured 13 - C / 12 - C
isotope ratio.