Sentences with phrase «journal editors decide»

Not exact matches

In peer - reviewed journals, reviewers usually decide what gets published — but editors may decide whether to even send a paper out for review.

As an editor at the journal Physical Review Letters, my job is to consult experts in the field and ultimately decide which manuscripts to publish.

Next month, journal editors will decide whether to retract the paper.

There are two common reasons for editorial rejection: Editors have decided the work does not fit the journal's purview, or the experimental approach was judged inappropriate or unconvincing.

And when it came time to apply for a job she decided to pursue a career as a journal editor.

As for peer review, it means only that reasonably qualified scientists examined the manuscript and recommended changes to improve the paper, or recommended that the paper be rejected; the journal editor has to make a determination about the merits of the paper based largely, but not entirely on the reviewers» comments (the editor has some discretion in deciding to accept or reject — his / her reputation as an editor, and the reputation of the journal, depend on sound editorial judgments).

Unless we decide to submit the piece to a regular journal, with all the complications of delay, possibly quixotic editors and reviewers that is the best we can do, and I think it would be fine to call it a peer review,» Happer wrote in an email to undercover reporters.

After all the shenanigans at GRL with the replacement of the editor and the resubmission of letters, the journal decided once again to reject Wahl and Amman's attempt to rebut McIntyre's work.

After seeing the critique, Climate Research editor - in - chief Hans von Storch decided he had to make changes in the journal's editorial process.

«After reviewing our last week of comments, we have decided to become more assertive with our comment moderating,» ABA Journal Assistant Managing Editor Molly McDonough wrote in a post to the magazine's Web site Monday.