The trial
judges in both cases referred extensively to my case of Cobb v. Martin Estate, 2017 ONCA 717 — a case that I will never forget.
Not exact matches
(Recall that the AG's office actually doesn't have subpoena power
in corruption
cases until the governor specifically
refers a
case to his office, which is why Andrew Cuomo couldn't compel testimony
in the Troopergate
case, but former Chief
Judge Judith Kaye — working as Cuomo's request on the ethics charges lodged against Gov. David Paterson — can do so).
What they're accusing him of is
referring business that is going to come before him, almost like a
judge who would pick the lawyers who are going to be
in the
case.
CASE -
referred experts are not expected to serve pro bono; each expert's fee is determined between the expert and the
judge, although AAAS will assist
in the process.
In this case, the judge is not applying UK law but referring to the 1992 EU package travel directive which makes European tour operators liable for the safety of their guests anywhere in the worl
In this
case, the
judge is not applying UK law but
referring to the 1992 EU package travel directive which makes European tour operators liable for the safety of their guests anywhere
in the worl
in the world.
None of them were fatal
in that a
judge or opposing counsel could certainly have figured out what
case the cite
referred to, but that isn't really the point.
Nevertheless, the
judges who decided the TBG Limited -
case refer extensively to the judgment
in the Prunus -
case.
In its 20 year history the CCRC has only
referred two
cases back to the appeal
judges on a second referral.
As
in the Kuznetsov
case, the decision
in the Arcadis
case provides a helpful summary of the applicable principles determining whether or not there is a binding contract between parties, with the
judge referring to the elegant summary of Lord Clarke
in RTS Limited v Molkerei Alois Müller GmbH [2010] 1 WLR 753:
In the
case, the
judge referred to Miss Woodward as an «extraordinarily able lady» while her defence counsel described her as «bright».
At page 78 he
refers to the Law Society submission and states «The report does not however give,
in our view, adequate attention to the way
in which the market is manipulated by BTE insurers so that clients are not free to choose the solicitor of their own choice... The Association of District
Judges has made known to the Law Society, during 2008, its concerns that this system frequently operates as a denial of justice to claimants who lose, undersettle or not pursue
cases as a result of the nature of representation provided.».
Certainly, had the
judge in Re W (a Child)[2016] EWCA Civ 1051 (
referred to
in Pt 1) looked at the
case in terms of W's Charter rights — which
in 2016 she should have done — it is difficult to see how the decision not to join the child
in her return order proceedings could have been made.
That is, if the
case before them is the first
in their jurisdiction,
judges will
refer to other common law countries for guidance.
Where the reference is not clear or incomplete, much time has to be devoted to understanding the
case and
in particular, and this is more important, understanding the problem of EU law the
referring judge has encountered.
A stay is not inevitable especially if neither side has expressed an interest
in mediation but a district
judge has
referred the
case to the mediator.
The
referring judge considers that this
case is not isolated but merely illustrates the general situation
in Italy.
The
Judge cited
cases such as Re G - Tech Construction Ltd [2007] BPIR 1275 which allowed for such a possibility, but emphasised that the judgment
in G - Tech was an incomplete draft which had not been approved by the author before he died, and
in any event did not
refer to previous authorities which supported the general proposition that retrospective orders should only be made if the underlying legislation contained «very strong and explicit words» permitting them.
Cases of Gregoire & Kumar (ONCA, 2008)
referred to below
in H.L., [2009] O.J. No. 3572 (SCJ, Hill J): Analysis 25 On the appeal, without the benefit of the June 20 and June 27, 2008 transcripts, the court raised with the parties the propriety of the pre-trial justice presiding as the sentencing trial
judge.
When ordered by the presiding
judge, or when automatically
referred to mediation
in accordance with this Administrative Order, parties must participate
in mediation of family
cases.
The trial
judge assessed the evidence
in this
case and
referred to a 1980 Ontario
case that set out indicators of co-habitation, such as:
The
case was
referred to the ECJ by a Danish
judge in a dispute between Post Danmark and Konkurrencerådet, the Danish competition authority.
Or, one will see
cases in which the
judge refers to a long list of
cases — some appellate, some co-ordinate, all of which deal with the point
in issue — and concludes with the line that since neither counsel cited the binding authorities, let alone any, nobody gets costs.
Some of the
judges from the conference
referred to above supposedly «pleaded with the law professors to write about actual
cases and doctrines,
in quick, plain and accessible articles».
In this
case, however, I am satisfied that the trial
judge's failure to
refer to the impact of the breaches on the appellant's Charter - protected rights does demonstrate a failure to consider that impact.
Judge Baylson had 31 Malibu Media
cases referred to him, making it far more reasonable to join five of the defendants who had already filed motions
in their
cases.
A plan to require trial
judges in civil
cases refer a motion to disqualify to another
judge for determination has been heavily amended.
The CJEU held
in the
case of Coty Germany GmbH v First Note Perfumes NV (C - 360 / 12), which His Honour
Judge Hacon
referred to
in his judgment, that the «linking factor relates to active conduct on the part of the person causing that infringement».
Many of the actions of the
referring judge will become an issue in the case, calling into question the objectives and motives of Judge
judge will become an issue
in the
case, calling into question the objectives and motives of
Judge Judge Snow.
In order to support his position, the
Judge referred to the recent Otis
Case (which has also been discussed on this blog).
In one
case, opposing counsel
referred to a retired
judge who was appearing as counsel as «His Honour».
(2) Court personnel
referred to
in subsection (1) who are assigned to and present
in a courtroom shall act at the direction of the presiding
judge, justice of the peace, master or
case management master while the court is
in session.
(3) If an allegation of misconduct against a provincial
judge is made to any other
judge or to the Attorney General, the other
judge, or the Attorney General, as the
case may be, shall provide the person making the allegation with information about the Judicial Council's role
in the justice system and about how a complaint may be made, and shall
refer the person to the Judicial Council.
In Tuesday's opinion, written by appellate Judge Janice Rogers Brown on behalf of the three - judge panel, she referred to the constant back - and - forth as «Sisyphean labor,» stating that the case must be brought to a close in «the interest of procedural fairness and judicial finality.&raqu
In Tuesday's opinion, written by appellate
Judge Janice Rogers Brown on behalf of the three - judge panel, she referred to the constant back - and - forth as «Sisyphean labor,» stating that the case must be brought to a close in «the interest of procedural fairness and judicial finality.&r
Judge Janice Rogers Brown on behalf of the three -
judge panel, she referred to the constant back - and - forth as «Sisyphean labor,» stating that the case must be brought to a close in «the interest of procedural fairness and judicial finality.&r
judge panel, she
referred to the constant back - and - forth as «Sisyphean labor,» stating that the
case must be brought to a close
in «the interest of procedural fairness and judicial finality.&raqu
in «the interest of procedural fairness and judicial finality.»
As the
case started
in Scotland, the
judges refer to skilled witnesses but that's the Scottish for expert witnesses.
The
judge in the Hahn
case referred to the decision of Collyer v. Boon, 2008 BCSC 1745, wherein Madam Justice L. Russell, at para. 105, stated the following:
11 Accordingly, notwithstanding the principle (which I do not doubt) that questions of apportionment are generally questions of fact with which we should interfere only
in exceptional
cases, I would conclude that the issues I have
referred to are ones of law and that the learned trial
judge erred
in law
in placing too high a standard on the plaintiff and
in failing to consider the assumptions she was entitled to make.
The Legal 500 have
referred to Russell as being an approachable, clear and practical advocate who has an excellent manner with clients, who is good
in front of
judges and who leaves no stone unturned when dealing with
cases.
However, the
Judge held that the Policy (which stipulates that complaints of serious criminal conduct should normally be
referred to the police
in the first instance and that the University's Policy may not be applicable
in such
cases) was on its face unarguably lawful.
In a recent case in this Court, Fuller v. Harper, 2010 BCCA 421 (CanLII), the Court, after referring to the comments of Mr. Justice Rothstein in Pecore, noted that the effect of any presumption of resulting trust only will be requisite after all the evidence and the surrounding circumstances in which the transfer was made has been weighed and considered by the trial judg
In a recent
case in this Court, Fuller v. Harper, 2010 BCCA 421 (CanLII), the Court, after referring to the comments of Mr. Justice Rothstein in Pecore, noted that the effect of any presumption of resulting trust only will be requisite after all the evidence and the surrounding circumstances in which the transfer was made has been weighed and considered by the trial judg
in this Court, Fuller v. Harper, 2010 BCCA 421 (CanLII), the Court, after
referring to the comments of Mr. Justice Rothstein
in Pecore, noted that the effect of any presumption of resulting trust only will be requisite after all the evidence and the surrounding circumstances in which the transfer was made has been weighed and considered by the trial judg
in Pecore, noted that the effect of any presumption of resulting trust only will be requisite after all the evidence and the surrounding circumstances
in which the transfer was made has been weighed and considered by the trial judg
in which the transfer was made has been weighed and considered by the trial
judge.
Some
judges have found that by
referring, for example boundary disputes to mediation, they relieve themselves of having to hear the most tiresome and futile
cases in their lists.
17 By letter of 20 June 2016, the Court Registry acknowledged receipt of the request that the present
case be
referred to the Grand Chamber and informed the parties of its referral, pursuant to Article 28 (5) of the Rules of Procedure, to an extended Chamber sitting with five
Judges,
in this instance the Seventh Chamber (Extended Composition).
Finally, the trial
judge in the Camden City
case dealt with the separate issues posed by a parent's access to her own child's records, «access logs» for those records, and other documents possessed by the school district that
refer to her child.
«
In relation to the considerations that serve to distinguish a policy decision from the operational decision, I continue to think that the four considerations referred to by Madam Justice McLachlin, as the trial judge in Just, are helpful and are unaffected by the decision of the Supreme Court of Canada in that cas
In relation to the considerations that serve to distinguish a policy decision from the operational decision, I continue to think that the four considerations
referred to by Madam Justice McLachlin, as the trial
judge in Just, are helpful and are unaffected by the decision of the Supreme Court of Canada in that cas
in Just, are helpful and are unaffected by the decision of the Supreme Court of Canada
in that cas
in that
case.
The Court of Appeal quotes a prior B.C.
case in which a B.C.S.C.
judge refers to a particular luxury car as «the stuff of a young man's fantasy, and an older man's crisis» (See para. 26)-- a potentially (inadvertently?)
Specifically, the
judge,
in that
case, permitted the use of predictive coding for that review, a general term that at that time
referred to programs that used algorithms to determine whether documents are relevant to a
case.
The guidance meat of the judgment is at the end where the
judge refers in emphatic terms to the clear need for parties to plead their
case on particular issues, to «nail their colours to the mast».
Venables is one of a growing number of
cases in which
judges routinely
refer to international instruments.
When talking about wasting
judges» time, we're not
referring to a pet peeve shared by many
judges we've spoken to relating to the fact that parties wait until the last minute to settle
cases, making it impossible to schedule
in a new
case for the assigned
judge and courtroom.
In this decision, the Court of Appeal arrived at a result which is contrary to the result in its 2011 decision in L - 3 Communication Spar Aerospace Limited v. CAE Inc (which decision was not referred to in the Federation v. Markel decision, although one of the judges sat on both cases
In this decision, the Court of Appeal arrived at a result which is contrary to the result
in its 2011 decision in L - 3 Communication Spar Aerospace Limited v. CAE Inc (which decision was not referred to in the Federation v. Markel decision, although one of the judges sat on both cases
in its 2011 decision
in L - 3 Communication Spar Aerospace Limited v. CAE Inc (which decision was not referred to in the Federation v. Markel decision, although one of the judges sat on both cases
in L - 3 Communication Spar Aerospace Limited v. CAE Inc (which decision was not
referred to
in the Federation v. Markel decision, although one of the judges sat on both cases
in the Federation v. Markel decision, although one of the
judges sat on both
cases).
* For the purpose of this program, delinquent citations
refer to capias pro fine
cases, or
cases in which a
Judge has found the individual guilty, has issued a fine and the defendant has failed to pay the fine.