Imax's summary
judgment motion based on a limitation defence was denied yesterday, giving the class action bar cause for celebration in light of other recent decisions that seem to go against plaintiffs in similar circumstances where lengthy proceedings have delayed matters.
Judge Land also denied Tyson's summary
judgment motion based on the Portal - to - Portal Act because «there is a genuine issue of material fact as to whether the donning, doffing, and sanitizing activities are «integral and indispensable» to Plaintiffs» principal work activities.»
Although courts do not publish the number of summary judgment motions filed each year, we can estimate how frequently lawyers file summary
judgment motions based on published studies.
Not exact matches
Sienkowski's
motion to vacate the
judgment and for a new trial
based on this information was denied, leading to an appeal to the Court of Appeals of Indiana.
The mother filed a
motion for summary
judgment seeking an order that, among other things, the father pay child support
based on the Child Support Guidelines, an order that the father pay his share of the child's section 7 expenses, and that the father settle unpaid child support (i.e. arrears).
The
motions judge also subsequently awarded costs against Affinia on a «substantial indemnity»
basis, relying on a rule in Ontario's rules of civil procedure which applies where a party has acted unreasonably in responding to a
motion for summary
judgment.
Whether it's a subpoena duces tecum, a
motion for summary
judgment, or a complaint — the very foundational document on which a civil lawsuit is
based — law students don't get much hands - on
[5] In the months following the amendments to Rule 20, it has become a matter of some controversy and uncertainty as to whether it is appropriate for a
motion judge to use the new powers conferred by the amended Rule 20 to decide an action on the
basis of the evidence presented on a
motion for summary
judgment.
The appellate court reasoned that a lower court couldn't grant summary
judgment on a
basis not presented in the
motion.
The first surgeon then brought a
motion for summary
judgment on the
basis that the plaintiff discovered her claim prior to January 1, 2004, and as a result, the one - year limitation period established in s. 89 (1) of the Health Professions Procedural Code, S.O. 1991 applied.
In this slip and fall action, the trial court granted Appellee Wal - Mart's
motion for summary
judgment based on the nonexistence of any genuine issue of material fact that Wal - Mart had actual or constructive notice of a dangerous condition.In this slip and fall action, the trial court granted Appellee Wal - Mart's
motion for summary
judgment based on the nonexistence of any genuine issue of material fact that Wal - Mart had actual or constructive notice of a dangerous condition.
2008)-- Denial of manufacturer defendant's
motion for summary
judgment in cases arising from explosion at facility in Groton, Connecticut on grounds that there existed genuine issues of fact as to product liability and recklessness counts of case against manufacturer
based on its claimed failure to account for and disclose relevant safety and storage information of risks involved in the transport and storage of chemical reagent at ambient temperatures.
Weinstein said, «While no partiality could be construed in rejecting defendant's
motion for summary
judgment based on timeliness, recusal now is desirable to avoid the appearance of partiality by the undersigned judge in future decisions in the case.»
The Court hearing the case agreed with the defendant and granted the defendant's
motion for summary
judgment,
based on the legal principle of assumption of the risk.
The Appellant Dr. James objected to the procedure followed by the
Motion Judge on the basis that the common issue question was devised by the motion judge himself without the benefit of submissions from counsel and after the conclusion of the hearing of the summary judgment m
Motion Judge on the
basis that the common issue question was devised by the
motion judge himself without the benefit of submissions from counsel and after the conclusion of the hearing of the summary judgment m
motion judge himself without the benefit of submissions from counsel and after the conclusion of the hearing of the summary
judgment motionmotion.
Based on that determination, Brooks Kushman filed a
motion for summary
judgment and on April 21, 2016, U.S. District Judge Norma L. Shapiro granted the
motion ending all claims against Ford on the grounds that the TMC patent did not cover the accused Ford vehicles.
The insured brought a
motion for summary
judgment on the
basis that the malpractice claim was statute - barred.
The appellate court was tasked with determining if the trial court was proper to grant the defendant's
motion for summary
judgment based on the plaintiff's failure to establish that the defendant was negligent.
Oh, they also
based their
motion for summary
judgment on the non-justiciability of plaintiff's claim — because there was no pending ethics action!
The defendant did not file a statement of defence, and this decision was
based on a
motion for default
judgment.
With respect to the Appellant's first ground, the Court of Appeal found the argument summary
judgment should not have been granted on the
basis proceedings were still at an early stage in their development «overlooks the direction provided by the Supreme Court of Canada in Hryniak v. Mauldin, 2014 SCC 7 (CanLII), [2014] S.C.J. No. 7 (S.C.C.), at paras. 49 and 66, that summary
judgment is to be granted where the record enables to
motion judge to reach a fair and just determination on the merits and to do so in a timely, more affordable and proportionate manner.»
The defendant insurer brought a summary
judgment motion on the
basis that the limitation period had expired.
Allstate denies Araujo third - party coverage and brings two
motions for summary
judgment: one to dismiss Fernandes» claim as against Almeida (
based on a theory of vicarious liability), the other to dismiss Araujo's claim on the ground she was not entitled to coverage (as she drove the ATV without a proper licence).
Even after the reasons for
judgment were released and the defendants brought a
motion for a mistrial, they did not
base it on the drowsiness of the trial judge, or even raise the issue.
To generate predicted probabilities, we held all variables at their means (or modal values if dichotomous) aside from the difference in readability score variable, which we varied from -4 to 4
based on the spectrum of our data.102 The results for the predicted probability that a moving party prevails on a
motion for summary
judgment based on a given readability score are presented in Figure 1 below.103
For those of you who aren't familiar with the Ontario rules, a summary
judgment motion is a
motion brought by a party to obtain
judgment without a trial on the
basis that the result is so clear cut that a full trial is not necessary.
Whether it's a subpoena duces tecum, a
motion for summary
judgment, or a complaint — the very foundational document on which a civil lawsuit is
based — law students don't get much hands - on experience with litigation documents in traditional law school courses.
The difference in the predicted probability of success on a
motion for summary
judgment based on a brief's readability score is much less stark in our state court sample than in our federal court sample.
Since joining FLR, Andrea has worked on numerous pleadings and memoranda involving
motions to dismiss, to compel discovery, and for summary
judgment on issues such as contracts (including personal services contracts), a wide variety of tort -
based claims, punitive damages, privilege and sovereign immunity, insurance coverage, family law, Florida Deceptive and Unfair Trade Practices Act, Health Care Quality Improvement Act immunity and peer review, and estates and trusts.
The Court of Appeal for Ontario reversed the decision of the
motion judge and granted summary
judgment for rescission in favour of the franchisee purchaser, Mendoza,
based on the disclosure deficiencies in AGR's disclosure document.
On this
basis, having viewed the
motion picture in question, I think the State acted within permissible limits in condemning the film, and would affirm the
judgment of the Ohio Supreme Court.
In Hoskins v. Co-operators, the insurer brought a summary
judgment motion seeking to dismiss the plaintiff's claim for post-104 income replacement benefits on the
basis of section 281 (2) of the Insurance Act:
Argued
motion successfully limiting claims
based on Hazen Paper Co. v. Biggins and summary
judgment motion that was eventually granted on all disparate treatment claims for the entire collective action.
The Court of Appeal determined both that the
Motion Judge did not err in deciding the case by way of summary
judgment, and that there was no
basis to intervene in the decision itself.
Apart from a small correction to the partial summary
judgment, the Court of Appeal finds no
basis to interfere with the
Motion Judge's decision.
Certainly, motor vehicle accidents continue to happen, but foisting onto
motion judges the responsibility to determine summary
judgment motions on the
basis of assessing credibility on affidavit evidence, rather than viva voce testimony, does little to instill confidence in the minds of litigants that they have had their «day in court».
In cases that call for multiple findings of fact on the
basis of conflicting evidence emanating from a number of witnesses and found in a voluminous record, a summary
judgment motion can not serve as an adequate substitute for the trial process.
However, while writing his reasons, the
motion judge decided to resolve the
motions on a fifth
basis: he would grant a notional cross-
motion by the respondents for partial summary
judgment of their claim for breach of fiduciary duty and order a trial or additional summary
judgment motions to prove victimization, harm and causation of harm, and to quantify the individual respondents» damages, if any.
Students will be assessed on the
basis of two writing assignments, a Markman / claim construction brief and a summary
judgment motion, and on an oral argument on their brief.
The
motion judge dismissed the
motion for summary
judgment on the
basis that the limitation period did not commence until February 2013, when the respondent received the diagnosis from Dr. Patel.
Consistent with this, Williams brought its summary
judgment motion solely on the
basis that it could not be found to be vicariously liable for that correspondence.
The
motions judge granted
judgment dismissing part of the claim on the
basis of a signed release.
Successfully defeating a preliminary injunction
motion and obtaining summary
judgment dismissing trade secrets claims against board members of a nonprofit library and archive who were sued in Colorado and Virginia by the Church of Scientology for copyright and trade secrets violations
based upon posting of church materials to the Internet.
After certification of the class action, Maple Leaf brought a summary
judgment motion seeking dismissal of certain claims on the
basis that Maple Leaf owed no duty of care to the class.
In their notices of
motion, the appellants stated that the
motions were for «[s] ummary
judgment dismissing this action as against the defendant physicians [and as against the Crown] on the
basis there is no genuine issue requiring a trial as the action against them [and the Crown] is statute - barred» or, in the alternative, is «barred by the doctrine of laches».
[57][58] Unless there is an actual trial or
judgment, if there is only pre-trial
motion practice such as motions to dismiss, attorney fee shifting can only be awarded under FRCP Rule 11 and it requires that the opposing party file a Motion for Sanctions and that the court issue an order identifying the sanctioned conduct and the basis for the san
motion practice such as
motions to dismiss, attorney fee shifting can only be awarded under FRCP Rule 11 and it requires that the opposing party file a
Motion for Sanctions and that the court issue an order identifying the sanctioned conduct and the basis for the san
Motion for Sanctions and that the court issue an order identifying the sanctioned conduct and the
basis for the sanction.
The summary
judgment motion was argued
based on a paper record without any oral evidence being adduced.
«In May 2007, mother unilaterally terminated access and father had not had access since that time — Father brought
motion to vary order to give him sole custody with no access to mother
based on parental alienation, and finding was made that mother alienated M from father — Issue arose as to whether
judgment could be released to public — As full names of parties and child were not referred to in
judgment,
judgment could be released to public.»
270 A.D. 2d 489, 705 N.Y.S. 2d 281), that it can not be said that the Supreme Court's determination [to grant father's
motion to change the custody provisions of the parties»
judgment of divorce from joint custody to sole custody in his favor] lacked a sound and substantial
basis (see Eschbach v. Eschbach, supra).»
Kling Real Estate, Ltd. v. DePalma (306 A.D. 2d 445)- summary
judgment motion dismissing broker's complaint affirmed; broker's suit for commission
based upon two binder agreements fails where unilateral modification of the proposed contracts of sale by the prospective purchasers constituted a counter offer which the seller rejected; no cause of action exists for commission against buyer in second transaction where sellers agreed to pay the brokerage commission