First Capital wasn't entitled to costs for participating in four unsuccessful summary
judgment motions by the other defendants.
Not exact matches
If any other matters are properly presented for consideration at the 2018 Annual Meeting, including, among other things, consideration of a
motion to adjourn the 2018 Annual Meeting to another time or place, the persons named as proxy holders, Elon Musk, Deepak Ahuja and Todd Maron, or any of them, will have discretion to vote the proxies held
by them on those matters in accordance with their best
judgment.
On July 8, the public got its first view into how the U.S. Department of Labor will defend its fiduciary rule when it filed a cross
motion for summary
judgment, asking the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia to dismiss a law suit brought
by the National Association for Fixed Annuities.
On their
motion for summary
judgment, defendants argued that plaintiffs had not satisfied the loss causation requirement of Section 10 (b) because plaintiffs» losses were not caused
by the revelation that First Solar had committed fraud.
The
motion brought before the court
by Sheriff, requesting it to disqualify the other faction from appealing the
judgment of the Appeal Court was heard and argued, but the court asked the counsels to submit written arguments before the next date of hearing.
At the time plaintiff filed the
motion for default
judgment in default of defence, the defendants had not been served with any Statement of Claim as required under the Rules of Court in support of the amended Writ of Summons to which they could respond
by way of a statement of defence.
The Speaker and Deputy Speaker have been subject to the
judgment of the House
by substantive
motion on a number of occasions as shown in the following table.
He said that notwithstanding that «the
motion for stay of execution of the
judgment of the Honourable Justice Nnamdi Dimgba (of the Federal High Court in Abuja) delivered last week in the case of Senator Ovie Omo - Agege v The Senate has not been heard and determined
by the Federal High Court, the Senate resolved yesterday to comply with the terms of the
judgment».
Jolted
by the action, the EFCC returned to the court through a
motion asking for the stay of execution of the
judgment.
All parties have submitted
motions for summary
judgment, which means they are seeking to avoid a trial
by asking Judge Dewayne Thomas to rule on the briefs submitted.
A
motion to vacate is essentially an appeal of the
judgment entered
by the court.
As an existing
judgment reaches its expiration date, the person or business owed may renew the
judgment by filing a
motion with the court.
Although
judgment liens that impair an exemption can usually be avoided (removed)
by motion in a bankruptcy case, Courts are split as to whether a deficiency
judgment that results in a lien on real estate can be removed through bankruptcy.
If there are no alternative facts submitted
by the defendant, the case will be decided at the
motion for summary
judgment stage.
A scheduling decision, released last week
by Justice Brown of the Commercial List in Toronto, provides the first insight as to how summary
judgment motions may be changing on a practical level.
A
motion filed jointly on Friday
by the Barreau du Québec and the Montreal Bar, asking the Superior Court of Quebec to issue a declaratory
judgment that all of the province's laws, regulations and decrees are illegal because they were drafted and adopted in French only, has stunned politicians, lawyers and legal pundits the province.
The Divisional Court found the
Motion Judge was correct in dealing with the matter
by way of summary
judgment because the facts were not in dispute.
Duty Room Handles various matters including
motions for default
judgment, decisions concerning applications for warrants to search, applications
by the Clerk to strike improper or incomplete pleadings,
motions to dismiss filed
by the prosecutor pursuant to Criminal Rule 48, cognovit notes,
motions to excuse jurors, probable cause hearings, and performing civil wedding ceremonies.
[4] In the reasons for
judgment of the Court of Appeal, Justice Hourigan agreed with the
motions judge that the «occurrence» causing property damage in this case was the scratching of the windows caused
by the contractor's employees and not the presence of airborne cement debris.
Through post-verdict
motions, the Appellate Practice Group convinced the court that the releases were suspect, resulting in reduction of the
judgment by $ 20 million instead of the $ 4 million reduction sought
by the plaintiffs.
Summary
judgment motions can be filed
by either a plaintiff or defendant.
Considering what a mess the Monday testimony and lawyer argument on the effect of the new claim construction was (because, frankly, both parties had previously hedged their bets as they didn't know what the appeals court would do), the jury is probably now very confused about it (and Judge Koh did the right thing
by denying both parties»
motions for
judgment as a matter of law since there are reasonable arguments for and against infringement, for and against validity).
In the absence of expert testimony, there was no triable issue of material fact as to whether a defect in the speed control deactivation switch installed on a pickup truck was the proximate cause of a fire that damaged a brake shop, a federal court in Mississippi ruled, granting the pickup truck maker's
motions for summary
judgment on the business owner's products liability and negligence claims (the latter of which was subsumed
by the products liability claim), and on the punitive damages claim (Mildemont, Inc. v. Ford Motor Co., January 13, 2017, Ozerden, H.).
Acting on behalf of the defendant
by counterclaim's subrogating insurance company, Justin Anisman sucesfully dismissed the Allianze's counterclaim on summary
judgment motion.
We have also obtained countless defense verdicts for our clients
by winning
motions for summary
judgment and other dispositive
motions.
By order dated July 14, 2014, the
motion judge, the Honourable Justice Martin S. James of the Ontario Superior Court of Justice sitting at Ottawa, granted Mr. Arnone's
motion for summary
judgment and ordered Best Theratronics to pay (i) damages equal to the gross amount of the salary Arnone would have earned until he qualified for an unreduced pension, less payments made to him to satisfy the statutory obligations of the employer, (ii) $ 65,000 representing the present value of the loss of an unreduced pension, (iii) a retirement allowance equal to 30 weeks» pay, and (iv) costs totaling $ 52,280.09.
When a
motion for summary
judgment is made and supported as provided in this Code section, an adverse party may not rest upon the mere allegations or denials of his pleading, but his response,
by affidavits or as otherwise provided in this Code section, must set forth specific facts showing that there is a genuine issue for trial.
The decision replaces the previous decision
by the Ontario Court of Appeal in Combined Air Mechanical Services Inc. v. Flesch, a special five - judge panel to hear five appeals over Rule 20 which then created a «full appreciation test» for summary
judgment motions.
[5] In the months following the amendments to Rule 20, it has become a matter of some controversy and uncertainty as to whether it is appropriate for a
motion judge to use the new powers conferred
by the amended Rule 20 to decide an action on the basis of the evidence presented on a
motion for summary
judgment.
(a) a short form order dated April 23, 2003, issued and signed
by the Honorable M. Ritholtz, granting Mr. Kaufman's
motion for a default
judgment and referring the issue of damages to an inquest, (b) the defendant's order to show cause, signed
by the Honorable M. Ritholtz on September 12, 2003, seeking to set aside the default
judgment, accompanied
by defense counsel's signed affirmation and the defendant's signed, but not notarized, affidavit, (c) the respondent's affirmation in opposition to the defendant's order to show cause, dated October 8, 2003, (d) a preliminary conference stipulation and order dated March 17, 2004, signed
by the respondent and defense counsel, and (e) a notice of compliance / settlement conference scheduled for October 21, 2004, before the Honorable M. Ritholtz.
Judge Reiss granted the defendants»
motion for summary
judgment, finding that «the only reasonable interpretation of that language is that it requires Killington Ltd. to provide the designated passholder free use of all ski lifts operated
by Killington Ltd. at the Killington Ski Area so long as it operates in that area... «The term corporation, she wrote, «clearly refers to the named corporations, Sherburne and Killington Ltd.» and «reveals no intention to bind Killington Ltd's successors... To the contrary, Killington Ltd.'s obligations under the passes clearly terminate with its cessation of operations in the area.»
First Capital's costs would violate the principle of proportionality because they'd amount to more than 50 per cent of the substantial indemnity costs of $ 709,000 incurred
by the plaintiffs in defending all five summary
judgment motions.
A Superior Court judge granted the defendants»
motion for summary
judgment ruling that plaintiff's claims were preempted
by Federal statute and safety regulations promulgated thereunder.
The Superior Court allowed the defendant insurer's
motion for summary
judgment on the ground that plaintiff was covered only
by her husband's policy in this case.
Apple's winning streak continues for now: after (finally) obtaining a preliminary injunction against the Galaxy Tab 10.1 and winning
by a wide margin a battle over a long list of expert reports, Apple has just been cleared of infringement of one of the three Samsung patents it was attacking in its very focused summary
judgment motions.
As a young lawyer or intern, most attorneys will judge your lawyerly skills not
by reading your appellate briefs or summary
judgment motions — but
by reading your emails.
Con Edison filed a
motion for summary
judgment, arguing that Con Edison was not liable for the explosion because it was caused
by the ignition of gas leaking from a cracked flex hose connected to the stove in the Al Ghaithi family's apartment.
That test prevented a judge considering a summary
judgment motion from exercising newly conferred powers in Rule 20.04 (2.1) of the Rules of Civil Procedure to weigh evidence, evaluate credibility, and draw reasonable inferences unless he or she was satisfied a full appreciation of the evidence and issues could be achieved
by way of summary
judgment.
This practice, which was also suggested in Combined Air, is put forward
by the Supreme Court as being appropriate for challenging «lengthy, complex
motions» for summary
judgment that would «not sufficiently advance the litigation or serve the principles of proportionality, timeliness and affordability.»
While the Supreme Court is right to recognize the traditional balance struck
by extensive pretrial process and the conventional trial «needs to be re-adjusted,» it is arguable
by alluding to
motions for directions and sanctioning
motions to stay or dismiss improper summary
judgment motions, the more immediate re-adjustment brought about
by Hryniak will be an increased number of
motions in the run - up to summary
judgment.
Maybe the cases cited
by opposing counsel are procedurally distinguishable:
motion to dismiss vs. summary
judgment.
The court explained that a judge presiding over a summary
judgment motion must consider the evidence presented and arguments made
by counsel, but nothing else.
[Note 3] Though noting that the affidavits submitted
by the plaintiffs in opposition to summary
judgment may have contained hearsay, the judge took no action on the defendants»
motion to strike those affidavits.
Weinstein said, «While no partiality could be construed in rejecting defendant's
motion for summary
judgment based on timeliness, recusal now is desirable to avoid the appearance of partiality
by the undersigned judge in future decisions in the case.»
The recent Ontario Superior Court of Justice decision in 2337310 Ontario Inc. v. 2264145 Ontario Inc., 2014 ONSC 4370, addressed a partial summary
judgment motion brought
by the franchisee of a cafe seeking a declaration that it was entitled to exercise its right of rescission under the Arthur Wishart Act (Franchise Disclosure), 2000 («the Act»).
In addition to the change in approach signalled
by these rulings, the courts have recently leaned toward the use of summary
judgment motions, which in Toronto must be heard within 100 days of counsel's attendance at Civil Practice Court, formerly called
Motion Scheduling Court.
The court concluded that taking those two factors into account, as well as the fact that the plaintiff would not be unfairly prejudiced
by the reversal of the
motion, the court held that default
judgment should have been set aside.
But I think that to sue someone for simply writing something would be fairly easily dismissed through a
motion for summary
judgment by a competent attorney in the event you got sued.
January 11 — Quebec — Quebec v. Guérin Health law: Quebec's AG is applying for leave to appeal the
judgment of the Court of Appeal in October that dismissed the appeal from a Superior Court
judgment allowing the
motion for judicial review brought
by the respondent, Dr. Ronald Guérin.
For this reason, our Rules of Civil Procedure provide for the option of a summary
judgment motion, which allows the moving party to proceed «directly» to a judge and make a pitch that this particular case can be decided
by a
motion judge and does not require a full trial.