●
The jury instructions say or the judge said that jury nullification is invalid.
Not exact matches
The 2d Circuit
said that in the absence of a proper
instruction it was impossible to tell whether the
jury convicted on the basis of something that qualified as an official act, or something that didn't.».
Acting U.S. Attorney Joon Kim
said he was confident the result would be the same at a planned re-trial on Silver's «decades long corruption» in which the
jury gets correct
instructions.
Legal experts
said the impact of the McDonnell decision would make it harder for the feds to convict Silver a second time, because revised
jury instructions could exclude some of the most damning evidence from consideration.
«I think [Skelos lawyer Alexandra Shapiro] is right that in the
instructions I gave the
jury and in arguments made by counsel to the
jury, there is a danger that the
jury decided the case based on a rationale that may be rejected by the Supreme Court,» Wood
said.
«We see no reasonable possibility, in light of the record as a whole, that that flaw affected the outcome of the case,» the court
said of Boyland's complaints about his
jury instructions.
Kim
says the only issue in the appeals panel decision is that the
jury instructions were incorrect, because of the recent Supreme Court decision, which involved former Virginia Governor Bob McDonnell and his wife.
He
said the judge might have treated the
instructions to the
jury differently, and prosecutors «would have been even more careful» about making sure their summation and rebuttal arguments «completely conformed» with the court's new interpretation of the federal theft of honest services law.
When the appeals court overturned Silver's corruption conviction, it
said that many people would view the facts that came out in the case «with distaste,» but the
instructions to the
jury did not track with the U.S. Supreme Court's decision in 2016 in a corruption case against former Virginia Gov. Bob McDonnell.
Mayor Bill de Blasio and top police brass offered details today on an NYPD retraining initiative that he has repeatedly heralded in the wake of the Eric Garner grand
jury decision — but he stopped short of
saying the new
instruction would have prevented Garner's death.
On Friday, Azrack
said while hearing arguments from the attorneys about the wording of
instructions on the law that jurors will get, that she had read
jury instructions from the corruption trials of Sheldon Silver, the former state Assembly speaker convicted for a second time on Friday, and Joseph Percoco, former aide to Gov. Andrew M. Cuomo.
An appeals court used a recent Supreme Court precedent to
say the
jury had been given incorrect
instructions in the case.
A New York federal judge ruled Senate Majority Leader Dean Skelos and his son can stay free on bail while appealing their convictions on corruption charges,
saying jury instructions in their trial could be flawed in light of a recent U.S. Supreme Court ruling.
A federal appeals court on Thursday overturned the 2015 corruption conviction of Sheldon Silver, once the powerful speaker of the New York State Assembly,
saying the judge's
jury instructions were in error in light of a United States Supreme Court decision that has since narrowed the legal definition of corruption.
The 2nd Circuit
said the
instructions given to the Silver
jury by the trial judge were consistent with precedential rulings in other cases prior to the Supreme Court decision in the McDonnell case.
«Although finding that the Supreme Court's McDonnell decision issued after Silver's conviction required a different legal
instruction to the
jury, the Second Circuit also held that the evidence presented at the trial was sufficient to prove all the crimes charged against Silver, even under the new legal standard,» Kim's statement
said.
Kim
said the only issue in the appeals panel decision is that the
jury instructions were incorrect, because of the recent Supreme Court decision, which involved former Virginia Gov. Bob McDonnell and his wife.
Supreme Court Justice Steven L. Barrett dismissed the manslaughter indictment against Haste in May because he
said prosecutors»
instructions to the grand
jury who indicted Haste were faulty.
«When the second grand
jury was presented with all of the evidence and was issued the proper
instructions in deciding the case, they courageously came to the right and proper decision,» he
said in a statement.
Haste, who was indicted by a grand
jury but had the case tossed out because of improper
jury instructions from the Bronx District Attorney's Office,
said he believed Graham had a gun in his possession at the time.
Supreme Court Justice Steven L. Barrett
said the grand
jury may have received misleading
instructions.
Robert McDonnell, which the NY federal appeals court
said resulted in flawed
instructions to the
jury.
Lawyers for Selivanov and Berkovich
said the couple were convicted on laws that should not have applied to them and incorrect
instructions given to the
jury.
A report from the UK
says juries are reasonably fair, report's Slaw's Simon Fodden, but adds that they usually don't understand the judge's
instructions.
Ms. Deluhery, a partner at Todd & Weld, told the publication in its Feb. 19 issue that» [a] sking an appellate court to
say that using the Supreme Court's phraseology of the law in a
jury instruction is wrong is going to be a tough sell.»
Raeder
says pretrial discovery procedures and
jury instructions must be changed to prevent forensic analysts from «fudging» the results of lab tests and «overreaching» when they testify.
Voith explained in his reasons that there were additional problems with Harding's submissions, and that any attempt to address them «would overwhelm and confuse my own
instructions to the
jury, and would not, in result, ensure that the defendant received a fair trial,» he
said.
The Queen, [1980] 1 S.C.R. 527, at p. 529, Chouinard J. resolved an issue respecting
jury instructions by reference to an earlier decision of this Court and
said:
While the lawyers have some
say in what
instructions are to be given in their «charge conference,» the judge decides what the
jury hears.
They
said that the trial judge erred in not asking the Crown to address the relevance of referring to her as a prostitute, did not provide
instructions to the
jury to address the «widespread racial bias» invoked by referring to her as they did and «wrongly
said a factor important to consent was that Gladue was a prostitute,» wrote the Court of Appeal judges in their decision.
This is what Judge Koh's tentative final
jury instructions would
say about the relevant factors and how to consider them:
In connection with Apple not addressing the real claim construction issue (the
jury instructions on infringement), Samsung's reply brief
says: «That is Hamlet without the Prince.»
Well, the point being: Microsoft was made to «share» — Apple
jury found Samsung guilty (appealing)... someone has
said the judge made a mistake, and that
instructions to
jury were poor, and that the
jury had no (tech) skills.