What
kind of teacher feedback helps you?
Not exact matches
Tough also explores research suggesting once they're in school, many low - income students often find themselves in a
kind of «tension and conflict»
feedback loop with
teachers that's hard to overcome.
The mentors come to you with the depth and breadth
of knowledge necessary to offer you the most supportive, constructive and uplifting
feedback to transform yourself into the
kind of yoga
teacher you always wanted to be.
They provide simultaneous
feedback on the many different
kinds of issues worth raising about a reform — issues about the quality
of implementation, the meaning various actors ascribe to the reform, the primary and secondary effects
of the reform, its unanticipated side effects, and how different subgroups
of teachers and students are affected.
Just before each unit we [other
teachers in her grade level] sit down and we talk about what, what are the objectives, what do the students have to learn, what activities can we do to ensure... success
of all that... we were doing a graphing activity and the students graphed and we [other
teachers in her grade level] were discussing the graph out in the hallway and um, she happened to walk by and she just
kind of sat down and joined us and so then I just asked her... some
feedback on, you know, how my conversation went and what I could have [done] to... deepen the kids» understanding.
This 2012 report by the Northwest Evaluation Association and Grunwald Associates LLC describes
feedback from parents and
teachers on what
kinds of assessments are most useful, relevant, and cost effective, and makes recommendations for assessment developers, policymakers, and state and district leaders based on their findings.
A study by AIR and the Institute
of Education Sciences (IES) shows that even small amounts
of the right
kind of feedback to
teachers and principals can have an effect on student achievement in math.
In line with the MET report, I think some
kind of triangulation
of qualitative and quantitative data that utilizes student
feedback (with
teacher reflection),
teacher and / or Professional Learning Community evidence
of student learning and growth (with
teacher reflection), and supervisor
feedback from classroom observations (with
teacher reflection) would help to provide a balanced and multi-dimensional approach for more intentionally and comprehensively understanding teaching and learning.
This
kind of expertise is much rarer than it should be — in large part because
teacher preparation and professional training don't do the deliberate practice,
feedback, and working memory tasks needed to cultivate expertise.
Studies have shown that honest, timely
feedback is one
of the top ways to improve quality instruction in
teachers, yet many
teachers would claim that this
kind of feedback is inconsistent or not given.
At this year's Targeted
Feedback Institute (October 27 - 28 in Renton, Wash.), principals, instructional coaches, teacher leaders and central office leaders who supervise principals can learn and practice how to provide the kind of feedback teachers can implement immediately and indepe
Feedback Institute (October 27 - 28 in Renton, Wash.), principals, instructional coaches,
teacher leaders and central office leaders who supervise principals can learn and practice how to provide the
kind of feedback teachers can implement immediately and indepe
feedback teachers can implement immediately and independently.
These guidelines would not only increase
teacher awareness
of the purpose
of the VideoANT activity, but also formally guide them as they practice providing substantive
feedback to their peers and receiving it in
kind.
It's worth asking what
kind of feedback would be helpful to
teachers.
Multiple studies have demonstrated that organizations that prioritize a performance - management system that supports employees» professional growth outperform organizations that do not.25 Similar to all professionals,
teachers need
feedback and opportunities to develop and refine their practices.26 As their expertise increases, excellent
teachers want to take on additional responsibilities and assume leadership roles within their schools.27 Unfortunately, few educators currently receive these
kinds of opportunities for professional learning and growth.28 For example, well - developed, sustained professional learning communities, or PLCs, can serve as powerful levers to improve teaching practice and increase student achievement.29 When implemented poorly, however, PLCs result in little to no positive change in school performance.30
Studies show that
feedback from this
kind of evaluation improves student achievement because it helps
teachers get better at what they do.
But such comments — in which
teachers offer advice, praise, criticism, or evaluation — don't provide the
kind of descriptive
feedback that can help students improve their performance, writes Grant Wiggins in this article.
As well, this particular
kind of expertise requires leaders to know about how individual
teachers learn to teach more effectively; how to skillfully observe for those elements in the instructional process; and, how to craft
feedback to
teachers and principals about what is observed that supports their current practice, and at the same time challenges them to improve.
That
kind of detailed
feedback is what Youngman said she wishes she'd received in her first year as a Teach For America
teacher in San Jose, Calif..
Similarly, Beach and Friedrich (2008) have shown that the
kinds of feedback teachers give on student writing can enable and constrain students» opportunities for substantive revision.
Fitzgerald (1992) has observed that
teachers» conceptions
of writing shape the
kinds of feedback that they give to students.
The SWAP accomplishes this goal by making
teacher candidates privy to practicing secondary
teachers» decision - making (e.g., their rationales for giving certain
kinds of assignments and
feedback), as well as to the results
of those decisions (e.g., their assignment sheets and
feedback on student writing).
And considering the low - quality
of subjective classroom observations that are the norm for traditional
teacher evaluation systems, the state laws and collective bargaining agreements governing
teacher performance management discourage school leaders from providing more - ample
feedback, and that the use
of objective student test score growth data is just coming into play, few
teachers have gotten the
kind of feedback needed to build such expertise in the first place.
The interview includes questions about
teachers» assignment purposes, their
feedback practices (and the rationales behind them), and the
kinds of language - and content - level issues they planned to address in subsequent lessons based on observed patterns in students» writing.
Changing the common sense beliefs
of teachers about heterogeneous grouping effects on the learning
of struggling students requires those providing leadership to bring relevant evidence to the attention
of their colleagues in accessible and convincing ways, to encourage actual trials with heterogeneous groupings under conditions which include opportunities for practice,
feedback and coaching and to help
teachers generate «the
kind of assessment information that will make the impact
of tracking and detracking more visible» (Riehl, 2000).
Susan Brookhart has create a
teacher friendly guide that provides
teachers with the know how to give the right
feedback for all
kinds of assignments, in every grade level and subject area.
They also develop students» analytical skills — and, if
teachers give the right
kind of feedback, their writing skills, which are often far from adequate.
Michael: What's exciting about the use
of video is that it gets us out
of the need for things to happen between certain bell times within the four walls, and really
kind of opens up the world to how it works, and how we might get
teachers the
feedback.
One approach to portfolios is the Learning Record, which structures the
kinds of evidence
of learning
teachers and students assemble and provides a structure for evaluation and
feedback to students and parents.
A study conducted by American Institutes for Research (AIR) for the Institute
of Education Sciences (IES) shows that even small amounts
of the right
kind of feedback to
teachers and principals can have a positive effect on student achievement in math.