Stefan Schwietzke, a research associate at the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration's Earth System Research Laboratory in Boulder, Colo., said Howarth may be overestimating methane emissions from shale gas because his 12 percent
leakage rate estimate is based mostly on a single satellite study.
Not exact matches
If current
estimates are correct that the
leakage rate is around 3 percent, then we calculated that switching all coal plants to average - efficiency natural gas plants would have little effect on the power sector's contribution to climate change.
As a proportion of the total oil and gas produced at these fields, this represents a
leakage rate of about 10 % for both fields, in good agreement with previous
estimates for several other leaky formations around the United States.
The paper finds that just 1.2 percent overall methane emissions are attributable to the U.S. natural gas industry, based on the most recent EPA methane emission
estimate of 1.2 percent of production, which is in line with a number of studies that find low U.S.
leakage rates between 1 and 1.8 percent.
Estimates of
leakage rates for action under the Kyoto Protocol ranged from 5 to 20 % as a result of a loss in price competitiveness, but these
leakage rates were viewed as being very uncertain.
UT's sampling of well sites
estimates the national
leakage rate associated with the production phase of natural gas extraction to be equivalent to less than half of one percent of total natural gas produced.
Why not focus on the central questions: What's the
estimated size of the Arctic carbon reservoir that's susceptible to warming, and what's the maximum
estimate rate of
leakage to the atmosphere?
Although the study's
estimated leakage rate for production operations was in line with EPA's
estimate, several processes leaked more than previously thought, while another (well completions) emitted much less due to the effectiveness of recent EPA rules.
Some of the research found lower
rates of
leakage — though the lowest
estimates tended to come from
estimates provided by industry, or from examinations of the best - performing wells.
1 ton = ~ 7.3 barrels oil
estimated Gulf oil
leakage rate ~ 21600 barrels / day (5 - 40,000 depending on who's
estimating) or 3000 tons / day methane emission = 1.5 e3 ton / day = 1.5 e9 g / day at 50 % methane by weight in the leak (probably a high
estimate) Gulf area = 1.5 e6 km ^ 2 = 1.5 e12 m ^ 2 Gulf average depth = 1.62 e3 m Gulf volume = ~ 2.4 e15 m ^ 3
Republicans and the oil and gas industry argue that the methane
leakage rate has been
estimated to be 50 times lower than the EPA's
estimate.