Using simple statistics, without data about published research, Ioannidis argued that the results of large, randomized clinical trials — the gold standard of human research — were likely to be wrong 15 percent of the time and smaller,
less rigorous studies are likely to fare even worse.
A well conducted randomized trial is more likely to produce correct results, but
a less rigorous study might still satisfy a physician if the risks are low and its potential benefits are great, he says.
Promising Practices are also techniques that have a positive impact on students, but that also have some research data (from very rigorous to
less rigorous study designs) to support their claims of effectiveness.
Not exact matches
Preclinical
studies of vaccine candidates have typically shown post-infection virologic control, but protection against acquisition of infection has previously only been reported using
less rigorous viral challenges.
Other
studies have taken a
less sanguine view of these achievement gains, arguing that they are misleading because states have made their assessment systems
less rigorous over time.
To put it simply, multiculturalism has
less to do with any
rigorous study of other cultures than it does with ethnic, gender, racial, or other subgroup tension within the nations of the West, the United States in particular.
A
rigorous study by David Deming of Harvard, for example, found that Head Start graduates were
less likely to repeat grades or be diagnosed with a learning disability, and more likely to graduate from high school and attend college.»
While one case
study by Sarah Fairbanks and colleagues in 2007 suggests that office referrals decreased following implementation of RTI, and teachers rated student misbehavior to be
less intense and
less frequent, few
rigorous evaluations of RTI have been conducted.
Four recent
rigorous studies — in the District of Columbia, Louisiana, Indiana, and Ohio — used different research designs and reached the same result: on average, students that use vouchers to attend private schools do
less well on tests than similar students that do not attend private schools.
The challenge is expanding the students» excitement about native
studies to all subjects while fighting the perception that the curriculum is
less rigorous than in other public schools.
However, if the
study consists of a survey or self - reported data, educational leaders should immediately recognize the
study is likely to be
less rigorous.
A handful of
studies using
less rigorous methodologies have had more mixed results, and the report does not address English / language arts.
Each of these
studies is no
less rigorous for the relevance it bears on the pressing problems of education in our time.
First, a caveat: Although we know a great deal from
rigorous research about what distinguishes high - performing from low - performing schools, much
less scientific
study has been conducted to show how struggling schools become effective ones.
E3 Alliance's ground - breaking longitudinal
study on elementary through middle school math pathways revealed that our most academically prepared low - income and minority students are
less likely to enter
rigorous math pathways than their peers.
In fact, the results are even
less promising when, as the article's author, Lindsey Burke notes, it becomes clear the Department of Health and Human Services
study used
less rigorous standards when measuring data.
Programs such as Linked Learning, which according to its website, «integrates
rigorous academics that meet college - ready standards with sequenced, high - quality career - technical education, work - based learning, and supports to help students stay on track,» have seen positive outcomes for students.51 A seven - year longitudinal
study comparing students who participated in Linked Learning to those who did not showed that the program completers were
less likely to drop out and more likely to graduate from high school.
At best, his work is an interesting pilot
study — generating research questions for a more
rigorous,
less biased investigation.
The
study analyzes data from randomized controlled trials and
less rigorous evaluations to compare treatments, treated populations and findings across programs.
A lot of other
studies use
less rigorous methods.
In terms of how the design of a
study might compromise the credibility of its findings, it is important to note that effect sizes of parent support programs tend to be consistently higher for those
studies using
less rigorous designs (e.g. pre-post
studies without control groups) and consistently lower for randomized
studies.19 Despite these caveats, there are emerging themes that characterize many successful programs.