On the heels of a study about an ineffective program in Chicago
linking student test scores to teacher pay, here's another one, with the same results, from a New York program.
RTTT has cash - strapped school systems engaged in wasteful «jumping through government orchestrated hoops»... How many school systems spent untold time vying for this RTTT money only to be denied it anyway because they weren't pro charter, or weren't in favor of
linking student test scores to teacher evaluations?
States interested in competing for a slice of $ 4.35 billion in stimulus money had to prepare plans that satisfied the administration's education - reform criteria, which included encouraging the growth of charter schools and
linking student test scores to teacher evaluations.
Many states rushed in recent months to change their laws to better position themselves to win, such as by expanding their charter school sector, or
linking student test scores to teacher evaluations.
While the Hawaii State Teachers Union has been locked in a battle with the state over a new contract that would
link student test scores to teacher ratings and pay, education reformers have praised the state for creating a merit pay pilot program and funding charter schools.
The civic group also endorsed including value - added analysis — a statistical method that
links student test scores to their teachers — in teacher performance reviews and cited a Times series on the subject as one reason they decided to weigh in.
Not exact matches
Using longitudinally
linked,
student - level data collected from two urban school districts, New York City and Washington, DC, Mathematica estimated the impacts of five EL middle schools on
students» reading and math
test scores.
Adding to their frustration, parents said, is the state's controversial teacher evaluation system, which
links educators» performance to
student test scores.
This would have delayed
linking teacher evaluations to
students»
test scores.
But in recent weeks, Cuomo has indicated he will begin to emphasize a new direction in education after a legislative session that saw yet more changes to the state's teacher evaluation system that
linked performance reviews to tenure as well as
student test scores and in - classroom observation.
Should the group decide that
student test scores are invalid for rating teachers — and many Albany insiders expect that to be the case — it would be up to Gov. Andrew M. Cuomo and lawmakers to decide whether to rescind a state law that now
links scores and evaluations.
She said her run against Cuomo would be built on a critique of his use of high - dollar campaign donations and his support for
linking teacher performance evaluations to
student test scores.
The governor's Common Core Task Force unveiled the plan in its final report, which recommends a moratorium on
linking teacher evaluations to
student test scores until the 2019 - 20 school year in order to «avoid the errors caused by the prior flawed implementation,» according to an official press release.
A major study of 415,000 school
students conducted over five years to 2012, «
Student Attendance and Educational Outcomes: Every Day Counts», has
linked increasing rates of absenteeism with declining
scores in national literacy and numeracy
tests.
Yet there are surprisingly few studies that make this
link explicitly, and none that ask whether schools that respond to accountability pressure by increasing
students»
test scores also make those
students more likely to attend and complete college, to earn more as adults, or to benefit in the long - run in other important ways.
The state is piloting an additional component that
links the
test -
score growth of each graduate's
students to his or her teacher - preparation program.
Principals who rotate their faculty by strength during the year, or augment classroom teachers with online lessons, will find their staffing models a poor fit for evaluation systems predicated on
linking each
student's annual
test scores to a single teacher.
Well, I've been making the argument for a while now that there is remarkably little evidence
linking near - term changes in
test scores to changes in later life outcomes for
students, like graduating high school, enrolling in college, completing college, and earnings.
And building
test -
score - based
student achievement into teacher evaluations, while (in my view) legitimate for some teachers, has led to crazy arrangements for many teachers whose performance can not be properly
linked to reading and math
scores in grades 3 — 8.
First, misaligned assessments undermine the critical
link between what is reported in accountability systems (
test -
score and teacher - evaluation data) and what districts purport to value (Common Core — aligned instruction,
student success with the new standards).
The department should remember that while many states permit
linking teachers to
student test scores, few districts actually do so, and that while Virginia and Mississippi have each had a charter law for more than a decade, combined they have only five charter schools.
(Sometimes the calls to parents are supplemented with teacher calls to
students) These parent relationships seem to be
linked to very high parent - satisfaction ratings, and in turn we have thought those were related to our high
test -
score growth.
Officials from purveyors of the nation's two most widely used admissions
tests linked lagging
scores in different sections of the exams to high school
students» failure to take enough of the core classes needed to prepare them for higher education.
Linking students»
test scores with evaluations was one of the «best practices» that high - performing schools serving
students in grades 6 to 8 have in common, the report found.
Our analyses were based on the approximately 125,000
students in grades four through seven within these districts who completed the surveys in spring 2015 and whose responses we can
link to data on
test scores in grades three through eight from spring 2013 to spring 2016.
This year, a state court judge ruled in favor of a Long Island teacher, determining that the «ineffective» rating she had received on the growth -
score portion of her evaluation (the part
linked to
student test results) was «arbitrary and capricious.»
On the left, some of the opposition to Common Core and its assessments is related to broader resistance to high - stakes
testing, the
linking of
student scores to teacher evaluations, and other reform measures such as school choice, which some see as «corporate school reform.»
They include nearly 1.6 million
test -
score growth records for
students (where a growth record consists of a
linked current and prior
score) covering the five - year time span from 2007 to 2011 (2006
scores are used as prior - year
scores for the 2007 cohort).
A successful undergraduate teacher in, say, introductory biology, not only induces his or her
students to take additional biology courses, but leads those
students to do unexpectedly well in those additional classes (based on what we would have predicted based on their standardized
test scores, other grades, grading standards in that field, etc.) In our earlier paper, we lay out the statistical techniques [xi] employed in controlling for course and
student impacts other than those
linked directly to the teaching effectiveness of the original professor.
Performance metrics tied directly to
student test -
score growth are appealing because although schools and teachers differ dramatically in their effects on
student achievement, researchers have had great difficulty
linking these performance differences to characteristics that are easily observed and measured.
Less than a year after Cuomo wanted to
link 50 percent of a teacher's evaluation to
student test scores, he called for a «total reboot» of the system and formed the Common Core task force to investigate.
The two national teachers» unions mounted a vigorous lobbying campaign this week to rewrite language
linking teacher bonuses to
student test scores and other incentive - pay provisions contained in a draft bill for reauthorizing the No Child Left Behind Act.
Attention to
test scores in the value - added estimation raises issues of the narrowness of the
tests, of the limited numbers of teachers in
tested subjects and grades, of the accuracy of
linking teachers and
students, and of the measurement errors in the achievement
tests.
And policies tethering teacher evaluations to
student test scores are based on studies that
link high - performing teachers to long - term improvements in the lives of
students, particularly the most disadvantaged.
So they changed their talking points: Now the teachers were upset about evaluations that would
link their performance reviews with
students»
test scores.
First, misaligned assessments undermine the critical
link between what is reported in accountability systems (
test -
score and teacher - evaluation data) and what districts purport to value (Common Core — aligned instruction and
student success with the new standards).
The common sense rationale for
linking teacher evaluations to
student test scores is to hold teachers accountable for how much their
students are learning.
We also
linked the lottery data to publicly available CPS data on
students» middle schools, including the percentage of 8th graders who
scored proficient or better on the math section of the Illinois Standards Achievement
Test (ISAT), the percentage
scoring proficient or better on the reading section, and the percentage of black or Hispanic
students.
See LA School Report (Ratliff Supports Proposal
Linking Teacher Pay to
Test Scores) and LA Times (Deasy and new board member Ratliff laud teacher report, Group urges teachers» raises based on
student achievement).
And in Louisiana, pending legislation to
link at least half a teacher's evaluation to
student test scores — a priority under the Race to the Top — has come under intense fire from the Louisiana Association of Educators, an NEA affiliate, which has turned to automated phone calls and newspaper ads to rally opposition.
Teachers in Connecticut are expected to get a one - year pass on having
student test scores linked to their evaluations.
Patricia Gandara, an educational psychologist at UCLA, said
students in bilingual programs often go to schools with higher concentrations of poverty, which is
linked to lower
test scores.
One of the shibboleths of the political class pushing for «stricter accountability» is that teacher evaluation must be increasingly
linked to
student test scores.
Reports - Assessments Dashboards (Teaching, School Performance), Multi-level Reporting (
Student, Group, Class, School, District), Custom Filters, Instructional Recommendations (with
links to resources),
Test Scores, Standards Mastery (Intervention Alert and Development Profile),
Test Sets (Multi-
Test, Benchmark, Formative,
Student Assessment History),
Test Monitoring,
Test Properties (
Test Blueprints, Item Analysis, Item Parameters), Progress Monitoring (Categorical Growth,
Student Growth and Achievement), Custom
Test Reports, External
Tests
In his speech he said: «Firing teachers and closing schools if
student test scores and graduation rates do not meet a certain bar is not an effective way to raise achievement across a district or a state...
Linking student achievement to teacher appraisal, as sensible as it might seem on the surface, is a non-starter... It's a wrong policy [emphasis added]... [and] Its days are numbered.»
Now he is not only continuing it but trying to
link teacher evaluation to
student test scores.
Race to the Top began in 2009, requiring states interested in competing for a slice of $ 4.35 billion in stimulus money to prepare plans that satisfied the Obama administration's education - reform criteria, which include the growth of charter schools and
linking student standardized
test scores to teacher evaluations.
Due to the current lack of data
linking individual
students» attendance patterns and truancy referrals with their
test scores, that contention is difficult to either prove or disprove.
Conceptually,
linking salaries to
student outcomes seems like a logical way to improve teachers» efforts or to attract those teachers most likely to produce
student test score gains.
This is important because the research found a
link between professional community and higher
student scores on standardized math
tests.25 In short, the researchers say, «When principals and teachers share leadership, teachers» working relationships with one another are stronger and
student achievement is higher.