In 2009, CREDO reported that charter students performed somewhat worse in reading and substantially worse in
math than their district school counterparts.
CREDO found that students who attended a public charter received one additional month of learning in reading and five additional months of learning in
math than their district schools friends.
Not exact matches
More
than 71,000 elementary and middle
school students refused to take the state Common Core
math test yesterday in 80 of Long Island's 124
school districts that responded to a Newsday survey — nearly 53 percent of those eligible for the exam in those systems.
In just the D.C.
district ANet
schools, the increases were smaller — 4 percent in English and 6.6 percent in
math — but still better
than the improvement of less
than 2 percent posted by
district schools that didn't partner with ANet.
Since 2007, the proportion of D.C. students scoring proficient or above on the rigorous and independent National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) more
than doubled in fourth grade reading and more
than tripled in fourth grade
math, bringing Washington up to the middle of the pack of urban
school districts at that grade level, while the city's black students largely closed gaps with African American students nationwide.
And it seems to be working: In spring 2007, Enota students scored higher in
math on the Criterion - Referenced Competency Test (CRCT, Georgia's annual standardized exam)
than any other
school in the
district.
In a 2015 report, Stanford University's Center for Research on Education Outcomes (CREDO) found that the average charter -
school student in the Bay Area attained significantly more growth in reading and
math than similar students in nearby
district schools — and that this difference increased the longer he or she stayed in a charter
school.
A recent investigation of achievement in one large Tennessee
school district (in which I am collaborating with Sanders and Paul Wright of the SAS Institute) has found that 20 percent of
math teachers are recognizably better or worse
than average by a conventional statistical criterion.
Specifically, I pointed out that gains on the National Assessment of Educational Progress under Rhee's tenure were much larger
than average gains for the other ten urban
school districts participating in the assessment in 8th grade
math and in 4th grade reading and
math.
A Brookings Institution study released in September 2002 concluded that student performance in charter
schools was significantly lower
than that of
district schools on state tests in reading and
math.
According to the Global Report Card, more
than a third of the 30
school districts with the highest
math achievement in the United States are actually charter
schools.
Viewed as a group,
schools managed by our CMOs achieve rates of proficiency on state assessments in reading and
math that average about 9 percentage points higher
than those of
schools in their local
districts (see Figure 2).
Conversely, late entrants at
district schools had dramatically lower average 4th - grade test scores
than on - time enrollees: 0.30 and 0.32 standard deviations lower in reading and
math, respectively (in both cases, 0.29 standard deviations below the
district average).
The CREDO analysis also shows that Michigan's low - income students, who comprise the vast majority of charter students in Detroit, make modest achievement gains (less
than a month of additional learning in
math each year) compared to
district schools, as do black and Hispanic students.
School and district administrators can apply these suggestions to their own goals, including reminding parents and the community at large that the world is more technologically complex than it was when they studied math in high school and that the typical career is much more likely to require not only competency in statistics and analytics but also problem - solving s
School and
district administrators can apply these suggestions to their own goals, including reminding parents and the community at large that the world is more technologically complex
than it was when they studied
math in high
school and that the typical career is much more likely to require not only competency in statistics and analytics but also problem - solving s
school and that the typical career is much more likely to require not only competency in statistics and analytics but also problem - solving skills.
In a randomized experiment in more
than 500
schools within 59
districts for the reading portion of the project, 57
districts for the
math portion, and seven states, approximately half of the participating
districts were randomly offered quarterly benchmark student assessments and received extensive training on interpreting and using the data to guide reform.
The study found that after multimedia technology was used to support project - based learning, eighth graders in Union City, New Jersey, scored 27 percentage points higher
than students from other urban and special needs
school districts on statewide tests in reading,
math, and writing achievement.
Charter
schools in the NewSchools» portfolio achieve proficiency rates in reading and
math that are about 9 percentage points higher, on average,
than those achieved by
schools in their host
districts.
For example, some states prohibited
districts from spending Title I on
school climate supports, counselors, science, or other costs other
than reading and
math, even though that wasn't required by federal law and didn't reflect state policy priorities.
In 2013, the year before students transferred, fewer
than 20 percent of students in the two unaccredited
school districts were proficient in reading or
math.
Students in
district schools with three or more charter
schools within a one - mile radius perform significantly better in
math than students with just one charter in the neighborhood, and they are also significantly less likely to be retained.
Approximately 95 percent of CSGF's member
schools enable students to outperform comparable
district schools in both
math and reading; nearly 70 percent of
schools enable their students to outperform state averages in both
math and reading, although they serve much higher
than average percentages of low - income and minority students.
The students lucky enough to win the lottery and be admitted to a charter
school subsequently scored higher on
math and reading tests
than did those who lost the lottery and remained in
district schools.
At
schools under for - profit management, students learned on average 25 percent of a standard deviation more in
math each year of the six years of the intervention
than they would have had the
school been under
district management.
At
schools under nonprofit management, students learned, on average for the six years, 21 percent of a standard deviation less in
math each year
than they would have had their
school remained under
district management.
According to interviews with more
than a dozen teachers and
school administrators in five different
districts, students in New York are taking more practice tests, and they're spending more time on
math and reading — and less on other subjects — since Common Core was put into place.
In a ranking of 30 American urban
school districts, 18 others performed better in
math than Dallas, including Houston and New York City.
The Boston study of just over 2,000 students in the public
school district's universal program for 4 - to -5-year-olds found greater gains in vocabulary and
math for participating students compared with nonparticipants, after one year,
than seen in any other study of other large - scale pre-K programs around the US.
On recent New York State tests, students in city charter
schools, serving a population of more
than 90 percent African - American and Latino students, exceeded
district - wide proficiency rates in
math by 13 percentage points and by 5 percent in English.
Even in
school districts such as Howard County, where students have generally done well, less
than half of students passed
math.
• Compared to 41 other regions nationwide, Newark has the second - highest performing charter sector based on charter students» high growth rates in reading and
math relative to similar students in
district schools, according to a 2015 CREDO study • 30 % of students now attend a charter
school, a figure that more
than doubled in this period.
Similarly, English teachers in Miami - Dade County Public
Schools demonstrate a persistent effect on
math that is 46 percent as large as their effect on English, while
math teachers in the
district have a persistent effect on English that is less
than five percent as large as their persistent effect on
math.
Rep. Rosa Gill, a Democrat from Wake County and a former high
school math teacher, likened Bryan and Brockman's achievement
schools districts to little more
than a «tangent» and a «knee - jerk» reaction to chronically struggling
schools.
If states or
districts tested
math or literacy proficiency in more
than one grade in elementary or in secondary
schools, we averaged the percentages across the grades within the building level, resulting in a single achievement score for each
school.
The I - Zone
schools showed some of the highest gains on reading and
math tests in the state last year, higher
than both the rest of the
district and the ASD.
Four years later, Dara Holt, the curriculum director for Valdosta City
Schools (VCS), reports that DreamBox continues to boost achievement rates in K — 5 schools across the district, «We do universal screening three times a year and our math scores are higher than our rating scores every singl
Schools (VCS), reports that DreamBox continues to boost achievement rates in K — 5
schools across the district, «We do universal screening three times a year and our math scores are higher than our rating scores every singl
schools across the
district, «We do universal screening three times a year and our
math scores are higher
than our rating scores every single time.
CREDO released a 2014 report (http://credo.stanford.edu/pdfs/LA2014ReleaseFinal.pdf) finding that the typical LA charter
school student gains more learning in a year
than his / her
district school peer, amounting to about 50 more days of learning in reading and an additional 79 days of learning in
math.
The
school's English and
math test scores were higher
than the
district average.
Across that period, charter
schools statewide consistently provided greater academic growth
than their
district peers: on average, charter students over the course of the study saw the equivalent of 34 additional days in reading and 63 in
math each year.
URBAN NAEP COVERAGE EdWeek: NAEP: Urban
School Districts Improving Faster
Than the Nation Baltimore Sun: Baltimore students score near bottom in reading,
math on key national assessment Cleveland Plain Dealer: Vast poverty differences create unfair comparisons on Nation's Report Card Miami Herald: Miami and Florida students outperform peers on national test
On Long Island, which has 124
school districts, more
than 20,000 students did not take this spring's English and
math exams.
As a teacher, Brig learned the power of the PLC process firsthand, as his
math team grew students more
than any other team in any grade, in any tested subject in his 22,000 - student
school district.
Each year,
districts and
schools were rated based on whether their elementary
school kids performed better
than the prior year's students in
math and English.
the typical student in a New York City public charter
school gains more learning in a year
than his or her peer in a
district public
school, amounting to about one more month of learning in reading and five more months of learning in
math.
Its graduation rate rose from 64.3 percent in 2007 to 78.8 percent in 2012, according to data provided by the
district, and it narrowed the achievement gaps between the
district's Hispanic students and Texas» white students by more
than 50 percent on state tests in high
school math and science.
The Coalition, representing more
than two dozen national education organizations, calls for establishing meaningful public reporting and accountability requirements regarding student achievement beyond reading,
math, and science at the
school,
district, and state levels.
The results for the typical student in a Harlem public charter
school — approximately 25 percent of the city's charter students — were even more pronounced in
math, on average gaining seven more months
than his or her peer in a
district public
school, but less
than a full additional month in reading.
Students attending charter
schools affiliated with a Charter Management Organization have better learning gains
than district school peers in both reading and
math.
Traditional
district schools, particularly Forest Hill and Cramer Elementary, more
than doubled their proficiency in
math.
But the majority of charter
districts statewide perform even worse
than the city
school district for African - American students in eighth - grade
math, the report noted.