"Merit selection" refers to a process where individuals are chosen for a position or opportunity based on their qualifications, abilities, and achievements, rather than favoritism or arbitrary factors. It focuses on selecting the most deserving or competent person for a specific role.
Full definition
Other types
of merit selection involve gubernatorial appointment or legislative appointment.
None of the judges interviewed said they had enough information to take a stance
on merit selection.
The biggest concern expressed by judges at the meeting was
what merit selection would mean for racial diversity on the bench.
So, as you can see, the selection processes will provide a hybrid
of merit selection, ethical conduct requirements and election processes.
The nominating commission has long been described as the key to the judicial
merit selection process, and we hope that its supporters in the thirty - three states that use nominating commissions will work to preserve their crucial role.
Tags: F.P. Segars - Andrews, Judicial Elections, Judicial
Merit Selection Commission Posted in Miscellaneous, Of Interest to General Public, South Carolina Specific 3 Comments»
O'Connor Advisory Committee member Sandy D'Alemberte served in the Florida legislature in the late 1960s and early 1970s and helped to craft the legislation that established the state's
judicial merit selection process.
Judges and magistrates in Vermont's Supreme and Superior Courts are all appointed initially via
merit selection with senate confirmation.
Member, Federal Magistrate Judge
Merit Selection Panel for the U.S. District Court, Southern District of Florida, appointed by Chief U.S. District Judge K. Michael Moore for term December 23, 2016 through May 1, 2017
Pennsylvania: Hearing on
merit selection plan set for today, membership of nominating commission unclear UPDATE: Vote delayed
The Brennan Center for Justice at NYU School of Justice, a nonpartisan law and policy institute, has monitored judicial elections and other state court issues for almost two decades and published an extensive report last year
about merit selection.
In 2005, Hawaii had the first Republican governor since statehood with the power to appoint judges
via merit selection, a legislature made up of a supermajority of Democrats (41 to 10 in the House, 20 to 5 in the Senate), and several members of the state's courts up against the mandatory retirement age of 70.
Efforts to
end merit selection for the Supreme Court, which requires a constitutional amendment, cleared the Senate but could not get the two - thirds majority in the House.
Contemporary judicial selection concerns include the controversy
over merit selection of judges vs. the election of judges, the need for judicial election reform, and the effect of the method of judicial selection on the number of minorities and women seated on the bench.
Arizona: plan calls for public financing of Superior Court races in counties not
using merit selection system, however bill would eliminate public financing for all other races
We began with a detailed report on why states
adopted merit selection in the first place, how the structure and operation of nominating commissions differ across the country, and what some of the best practices appear to be in building public trust in the process.
I'm not sure why
Taylor merited this selection, but given the club involved in the final, there were other options that would have taken away any but the kookiest claims of bias and impropriety.
Keynote Speaker, Luzerne County, Bench - Bar Conference, «Ethics —
Merit Selection vs. Election of the Judiciary, 1997
Alaska: changes to Judicial Council /
merit selection out of House Judiciary Committee; change to selection method of Council members also at play
Unlike merit selection systems in Missouri and elsewhere, Massachusetts governors can ignore or entirely disband their commissions at will.
Arkansas: Supreme Court could
get merit selection if all other judicial races go back to being partisan ones
Mr. Hueston previously served as a Central District of
California Merit Selection Panel member to assist the U.S. District Court with the appointment and reappointment of magistrate judges.
In that state governors use a
voluntary merit selection system; they are not bound by or to the names submitted by the Judicial Nominating Commission.
Oklahoma Speaker puts forth judicial agenda:
keep merit selection but change nominating commission, term limits but only for Court of Civil Appeals, mandatory retirement age for all appellate judges, several «placeholder» bills
A 1994 amendment
added merit selection, permitting the Governor to nominate only from those names submitted by an independent non-partisan judicial nominating commission.
Minnesota is pushing forward with an effort to get a constitutional amendment on the 2014 ballot
putting merit selection in place for all state judges.
Appointment to
Merit Selection Committee by U.S. District Court, Northern District of Ohio, for selection of U.S. Magistrate Judge
denied, 133 S. Ct. 312: The Eighth Circuit affirmed a district court's decision that Iowa's
merit selection program did not violate the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment.
State Supreme Court Chief Justice Mark Martin called for
merit selection earlier this summer, but other than that, the topic hasn't been publicly discussed much.
Some are uncomfortable about an «either - or» conversation
pitting merit selection versus judicial redistricting, but also happy to finally be included in the conversation.
The nonprofit organization hired lobbyists Chuck Neely and Rick Zechini, both of Williams Mullen, earlier this month and Neely brought Berger's chief of staff Jim Blaine to a meeting of the group's board of governors last Friday to
discuss merit selection.
He is a past member of the Boston Bar Association Diversity Leadership Task Force, a past member of the US District Court Civil Justice Advisory Board, a past Chairman of the US District Court for the District of
Massachusetts Merit Selection Panel and a past member of the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court's Working Group on Practicing with Professionalism.
Tags: Charleston Post & Courier, F.P. Segars - Andrews, Judicial Elections, Judicial
Merit Selection Commission Posted in Miscellaneous, Not South Carolina Specific, Of Interest to General Public 13 Comments»
The successful 1976 version focused exclusively on
merit selection with Senate confirmation for appellate courts only.
Melissa Price Kromm, Director of North Carolina Voters for Clean Elections, has been following bills this session aimed at changing the judiciary and expressed concern about Berger's
merit selection plan.
Chief Justice Lawton Nuss has spoken out against efforts to end Kansas»
merit selection process for appellate judges and...
Phrases with «merit selection»