E.P.A. has not yet had the opportunity to fully review the PNAS study on methane emissions; however we are encouraged that more
methane emissions measurement data are now available to the public.
Gavin, the methanetracker.org website says this: «All
the methane emissions measurements come from the Infrared Atmospheric Sounding Interferometer (IASI) instrument, aboard of the MetOp series of polar orbiting satellites of the European Space Agency (ESA).
Not exact matches
Direct
measurements of
methane emissions are not available for all sources of
methane..
Global annual
emissions calculated from laboratory
measurements could reach 1.5 x 1014 grams of
methane and 5 x 1016 grams of carbon dioxide.
Field
measurements of
methane emissions from two termite nests in Guatemala corroborated the laboratory results.
The study team hopes its
measurements of liquid unloadings and pneumatic devices will provide a clearer picture of
methane emissions from natural gas well sites and about the relationship between well characteristics and
emissions.
The study is the second phase of the team's 2013 study, which included some of the first
measurements for
methane emissions taken directly at hydraulically fractured well sites.
In late March, the Obama administration released guidance directing U.S. EPA to address
methane emissions from the oil and gas industry, after a number of studies measuring
emissions from the air, known as «top - down»
measurements, showed that the agency's
emissions estimates for the industry were too low (ClimateWire, March 31).
In the new paper, published in the journal Environmental Research Letters, Höglund - Isaksson estimated global
methane emissions from oil and gas systems in over 100 countries over a 32 - year period, using a variety of country - specific data ranging from reported volumes of associated gas to satellite imagery that can show flaring, as well as atmospheric
measurements of ethane, a gas which is released along with
methane and easier to link more directly to oil and gas activities.
David Allen, a University of Texas researcher who conducted
measurements from natural gas fields to measure
methane emissions, called the study an «important contribution.»
Geochemical records from
measurements of the foraminifera shells and fauna analyses will help us evaluate the changes in
methane emissions, while studies of living and fossil species distribution and abundance of the benthic foraminifera community in
methane seep areas will indicate the degree of
methane release through time.
The best way to estimate the magnitude of fossil
methane emissions is by using
measurements of
methane isotopes, such as carbon.
That meant, for example, traveling the globe to the various natural
emissions sources — such as wetlands and land seeps — and conducting
measurements and calculations of the
methane emitted.
This work presents direct
measurements of
methane emissions from multiple sources at onshore natural gas production sites incorporating operational practices that have been adopted or become more prevalent since the 1990s.
We find (i)
measurements at all scales show that official inventories consistently underestimate actual CH4 [
methane]
emissions, with the natural gas and oil sectors as important contributors; (ii) many independent experiments suggest that a small number of «super-emitters» could be responsible for a large fraction of leakage; (iii) recent regional atmospheric studies with very high
emissions rates are unlikely to be representative of typical natural gas system leakage rates; and (iv) assessments using 100 - year impact indicators show system - wide leakage is unlikely to be large enough to negate climate benefits of coal - to - natural gas substitution.
As NOAA's Mauna Loa
measurement of atmospheric
methane concentrations are only currently increasing at a rate of approximately 0.25 % per year (or 12.5 % change in 50 - years); how could anyone be concerned that the change in atmospheric
methane burden in 50 - years could be 300 % (as per Isaken et al (2011) case 4XCH4; which would require an additional 0.80 GtCH4 / yr of
methane emissions on top of the current rate of
methane emissions of 0.54 GtCH4 / yr)?
Almost all of the
methane leakage calculated from the Texas research «could be affected by this
measurement failure,» according to the paper; «their study appears to have systematically underestimated
emissions.»
A major call from our April 2011 paper was for direct
measurements of
methane emissions by independent scientists.
Ditto with the rapid increase in
methane emissions from the Arctic region as flask
measurements indicate, as well as satellite
measurements.
«In addition, we are currently developing a method that also allows for high - precision hydrogen isotopic
measurements on
methane in ice cores, which will further improve our
emission flux constraints,» revealed Fischer.
Measurement of the 13C isotopic signature of
methane emissions from Northern European wetlands.
The Trump administration has killed NASA's Carbon Monitoring System, which was responsible for compiling data from separate satellite and aircraft
measurements of CO2 and
methane emission across the Earth.
In the short - term, a key issue that needs resolving is the mismatch between global
methane budgets from top - down (derived from atmospheric
measurements) and bottom - up (derived from
measurements of
methane emissions at the land surface from different
methane producing environments) approaches.
The paper is based on an analysis of global
methane emissions examining almost 20,000 field data
measurements collected from 70 sites across Arctic, temperate and tropical regions.
Using SCIAMACHY satellite data as well as ground - based
measurements from 2003 to 2009, researchers found that the region where Arizona, New Mexico, Colorado, and Utah intersect had atmospheric
methane concentrations equivalent to about 1.3 million pounds of
emissions a year.
This report found that direct
measurements of
methane emissions from 190 onshore natural gas sites in the United States indicate that
methane emissions from completed wells are are lower than commonly thought although the report also acknowledged that
emissions from pneumatic controllers and other equipment associated with natural gas production facilities were higher than previously estimated.
Aircraft
measurements confirm that
methane emissions from northern European wetlands exhibit a uniform regional carbon isotopic signature, despite considerable ground - level heterogeneity.
Using
measurements from the first years of SCIAMACHY it had already been demonstrated prior to the start of this project that regional
methane emissions can be well constrained via inverse modelling approaches.
This parallels a recent NOAA study of atmospheric
methane measurements that found that «
methane emissions from natural gas as a fraction of production have declined from approximately 8 per cent to approximately 2 per cent over the past three decades» — with production soaring in recent years.
Schwietzke S., G. Pétron, S. Conley, C. Pickering,..., C. W. King, A. B. White, L. Bianco and R. C. Schnell (May 2017): Improved Mechanistic Understanding of Natural Gas
Methane Emissions from Spatially Resolved Aircraft
Measurements.
Present
measurement and accounting of fugitive
emissions of
methane from unconventional gas extraction is inadequate.
Translating across discipline - specific vocabularies was essential to understanding mismatches in estimates of
methane emissions from permafrost based on field
measurements and on atmospheric data.
To do this, countries and their oil and gas industry partners need to significantly improve
measurement and accounting of
methane emissions from the sector.
What the NYT fails to mention is the fact that the National Academy of Sciences (NAS) report actually recommended regulators use a combination of facility - level (bottom - up), aircraft and tower
measurements (top - down) and satellite
measurements in order to improve accuracy of
methane emission inventories.
It will be essential for countries to integrate better
measurement and management of oil and gas
methane emissions into the development, assessment and implementation of long - term GHG mitigation plans to maximize GHG reductions from those policies.
There aren't many long term
measurements of seepage so we don't really know how
methane emissions are changing (other than the slow rise shown at measuring stations).
This report summarizes the current state of understanding of
methane emission sources and the
measurement approaches and evaluates opportunities for methodological and inventory development improvements.
The most significant is that the UT Austin study looked only at the production stage of natural gas, while the Harvard study used atmospheric
measurements to estimate
methane emissions from all sources.
This work emphasizes the need for top - down identification and component level and event driven
measurements of
methane leaks to properly inventory the combined
methane emissions of natural gas extraction and combustion to better define the impacts of our nation's increasing reliance on natural gas to meet our energy needs.
The results of the new
measurement studies are distressing, but they are also frustrating — not just because natural gas comprises a growing share of U.S. energy, but because we know how to rein in
methane emissions.
The Department of Energy can use its role as the research and development arm of the federal government to improve the effectiveness and reduce the costs of
emissions measurement and control technologies, such as
methane isotope analyzers, infrared cameras, and portable compressors.