Of the diagrams, I like Ed Hawkins diagram the best: it does a good job of lining up the climate models and observations in a sensible way from 1960 - 1990, so as to show the growing discrepancy between
models and observations over the last decade.
Not exact matches
The strongest research methods for psychological studies are: qualitative findings versus quantitative; experimental rather than descriptive or correlational; controlled - experiment, meta - analysis,
and observation designs
over archival, case study, computational
modeling, content analysis, field experiment, interview, neuroimaging, quasi experiment, self - report inventory, random sample survey, or twin study;
and prospective (where subjects are recruited prior to the proposed independent effects being administered)
and longitudinal (where subjects are studied at multiple time points) rather than retrospective or cross-section study.
Computer
modeling and satellite
observations suggest that these tiny particles can increase storm - cloud cover
over certain regions of the North Pacific by 20 to 50 percent, enough to alter storm tracks in some cases.
Medvigy
and Jeong found that prediction
modeling for the entire United States indeed improves dramatically when the analyses include data from macro-scale
observations, meaning from multiple sites spread
over a large area.
Under the assumptions of their
model, the team quantified the dynamics all
over the exposed ocular surface,
and the results agreed well with in vivo
observations of the tear film gained from fluorescence imaging.
Working with the University of New South Wales, scientists have developed a computer
model which uses past wave
observations and beach assessments to forecast the erosion
and / or accretion of beach sediments
over the coming year.
A few of the main points of the third assessment report issued in 2001 include: An increasing body of
observations gives a collective picture of a warming world
and other changes in the climate system; emissions of greenhouse gases
and aerosols due to human activities continue to alter the atmosphere in ways that are expected to affect the climate; confidence in the ability of
models to project future climate has increased;
and there is new
and stronger evidence that most of the warming observed
over the last 50 years is attributable to human activities.
EWeLiNE combines these data with other atmospheric
observations — from ground - based weather stations, radar
and satellites —
and sophisticated computer
models predict power generation
over the next 48 hours or so.
There are some caveats with their study: The global climate
models (GCMs) do not reproduce the 1930 - 1940 Arctic warm event very well,
and the geographical differences in a limited number of grid - boxes in the
observations and the GCMs may have been erased through taking the average value
over the 90 - degree sectors.
FMI has been involved in research project, which evaluated the simulations of long - range transport of BB aerosol by the Goddard Earth Observing System (GEOS - 5)
and four other global aerosol
models over the complete South African - Atlantic region using Cloud - Aerosol Lidar with Orthogonal Polarization (CALIOP)
observations to find any distinguishing or common
model biases.
This involves a combination of satellite
observations (when different satellites captured temperatures in both morning
and evening), the use of climate
models to estimate how temperatures change in the atmosphere
over the course of the day,
and using reanalysis data that incorporates readings from surface
observations, weather balloons
and other instruments.
Rather than use a
model - based estimate, as did Hansen (2005)
and Trenberth (2009), the authors achieve this by calculating it from
observations of ocean heat content (down to 1800 metres) from the PMEL / JPL / JIMAR data sets
over the period July 2005 to June 2010 - a time period dominated by the superior ARGO - based system.
In fact, the calculation has been done very carefully by Hansen
and co-workers, taking all factors into consideration,
and when compared with
observations of ocean heat storage
over a period long enough for the observed changes to be reliably assessed,
models and observations agree extremely well (see this article
and this article.).
Over the last five years, the BAMS report has examined more than 100 events as part of a burgeoning sub-field of climate science that uses
observations and climate
models to show how human - caused warming has already affected the odds or severity of many of the weather extremes we experience now.
Over five days, the conference will offer a fruitful meeting of observers involved in various ground -
and space - based programs with modelers
and theoreticians, in order to raise new
observations and new
models to improve our comprehension
and knowledges of exoplanets.
Based on our
model,
and our
observations near greenhouses, it is probable that destructive pathogens have been spilling
over into wild bee populations since the collapse of commercial B. occidentalis during the late 1990s,
and this has contributed to the ongoing collapse of wild Bombus sensu stricto.
The photodetector array camera
and spectrometer (PACS) aboard the Herschel Space Observatory allows imaging
observations in the far infrared at unprecedented resolution, i.e. at better than 6» to 12»
over the wavelength range of 60 -LCB- \ mu -RCB- m to 210 -LCB- \ mu -RCB- m. Together with the results from ground - based
observations, these spatially resolved data can be
modelled to determine the nature of the debris
and its evolution more reliably than would be possible from unresolved data alone.
They used a combination of field
observations and data from local weather stations to test a
model of glacier change
over the past 50 years.
The statistics of the weather make short term climate prediction very difficult — particularly for climate
models that are not run with any kind of initialization for
observations — this has been said
over and over.
In Gersten
and Kelly (1992), «limited»
modeling by the teacher leader accompanied classroom
observations and feedback to the teacher
over a six - week period.
The coaching
model demands shorter, more frequent
observations and a focus on tracking growth
over time.
Using a unique identification strategy that employs grade - level turnover
and two classes of fixed - effects
models, this study estimates the effects of teacher turnover on
over 850,000 New York City 4th
and 5th grade student
observations over eight years.
The bottom line is that while there is remaining uncertainty in the tropical trends
over the last 30 years, there is no clear discrepancy between what the
models expect
and the
observations.
There are some caveats with their study: The global climate
models (GCMs) do not reproduce the 1930 - 1940 Arctic warm event very well,
and the geographical differences in a limited number of grid - boxes in the
observations and the GCMs may have been erased through taking the average value
over the 90 - degree sectors.
... a pronounced strengthening in Pacific trade winds
over the past two decades — unprecedented in
observations / reanalysis data
and not captured by climate
models — is sufficient to account for the cooling of the tropical Pacific
and a substantial slowdown in surface warming through increased subsurface ocean heat uptake.
This is something seen in many
observations and over many timescales,
and is not something to climate
models.
Abstract:... Here we show that a pronounced strengthening in Pacific trade winds
over the past two decades — unprecedented in
observations / reanalysis data
and not captured by climate
models — is sufficient to account for the cooling of the tropical Pacific
and a substantial slowdown in surface warming through increased subsurface ocean heat uptake.
This is odd, not because it's not true (
and is the principle reason why the attribution of more intense hurricanes to GW is not yet set in stone), but because Landsea has previously been much more of a champion of favoring
observations over modelling.
Given some good
observations and a suitable
model one could hope to do so for a brief distance, but inevitably chaos would take
over and we would fail to predict the exact point where the bubble would surface.
The constraining of the atmospheric
model affect the predictions where there are no
observations because most of the weather elements — except for precipitation — do not change abruptly
over short distance (mathematically, we say that they are described by «spatially smooth
and slowly changing functions»).
An important point with reanalyses, is that the
model used doesn't change
over the time spanned by the analysis, but reanalyses are generally used with caution for climate change studies because the number
and type of
observations being fed into the computer
model changes
over time.
There is one major caveat with these products though,
and that is that while the
model isn't changing
over time, the input data is
and there are large variations in the amount
and quality of
observations — particularly around 1979 when a lot of satellite
observations came on line, but also later as the mix
and quality of data has changed.
See Stowasser & Hamilton, Relationship between Shortwave Cloud Radiative Forcing
and Local Meteorological Variables Compared in
Observations and Several Global Climate
Models, Journal of Climate 2006; Lauer et al., The Impact of Global Warming on Marine Boundary Layer Clouds
over the Eastern Pacific — A Regional
Model Study, Journal of Climate 2010.
Data manipulation to support favored
models of reality
over experimental
observations of reality were in fact routine in the period between the end of the Second World War
and the release of Climategate emails
and documents (1945 - 2009).
This Nature Climate Change paper concluded, based purely on simulations by the GISS - E2 - R climate
model, that estimates of the transient climate response (TCR)
and equilibrium climate sensitivity (ECS) based on
observations over the historical period (~ 1850 to recent times) were biased low.
These
models have correctly predicted effects subsequently confirmed by
observation, including greater warming in the Arctic
and over land, greater warming at night,
and stratospheric cooling.
The GRACE
observations over Antarctica suggest a near - zero change due to combined ice
and solid earth mass redistribution; the magnitude of our GIA correction is substantially smaller than previous
models have suggested
and hence we produce a systematically lower estimate of ice mass change from GRACE data: we estimate that Antarctica has lost 69 ± 18 Gigatonnes per year (Gt / yr) into the oceans
over 2002 - 2010 — equivalent to +0.19 mm / yr globally - averaged sea level change, or about 6 % of the sea - level change during that period.
In equivalent in science is the conflicts
over viewpoints, policies etc. built on top of the underlying scientific
observations and models.
However,
models would need to underestimate variability by factors of
over two in their standard deviation to nullify detection of greenhouse gases in near - surface temperature data (Tett et al., 2002), which appears unlikely given the quality of agreement between
models and observations at global
and continental scales (Figures 9.7
and 9.8)
and agreement with inferences on temperature variability from NH temperature reconstructions of the last millennium.
So what we did with the
model is: stretch the input of the carbon
over longer
and longer periods of time until we get a match between the
observations and the carbon cycle
and climate
models.
Huh, dirty pool like the way increasing confidence has been decidedly promoted
over, lets say, the increasing divergence between
observation and model prediction?
To that end, an NSF - funded $ 21 million initiative called Southern Ocean Carbon
and Climate
Observations and Modeling (SOCCOM) run by Princeton University,
and including Climate Central, MBARI, Scripps, University of Washington, University of Arizona
and others, was launched in 2014 with the goal of deploying
over a six - year period a fleet of autonomous, robotic floats, capable of observing the Southern Ocean (for the first time) year - round
and across the entire expanse.
These
observations, together with computer
model simulations
and historical climate reconstructions from ice cores, ocean sediments
and tree rings all provide strong evidence that the majority of the warming
over the past century is a result of human activities.
There's a lot in there, but, the authors write, the compilation of peer - reviewed scientific
observations and models together «tell an unambiguous story: the planet is warming,
and over the last half century, this warming has been driven primarily by human activity.»
Using data from 9,000
observations collected
over the course of the 11 trials
and 30 years, the researchers developed a
model to simulate how rises in temperature could affect sorghum yields.
The true difference between the
models and observations is somewhat masked because Figure 9.3 recentres each plot to its own average value
over the period.
Overall, this results in an impressively small
model spread around
observations over the historical record
and a relatively constrained spread for each of the individual future projections.
California's coastal
observations and global
model projections indicate that California's open coast
and estuaries will experience rising sea levels
over the next century.
To investigate the relationship between SL
and BP on climate scales, we considered interannual time series from satellite
observations and a general circulation
model ranging
over 2005 - 2010
and smoothed
over scales of 750 km.
It's been fascinating
over my career to look at ever - better satellite
observations and ever - better
model simulations
and see that fingerprint pattern of human effects literally emerging from the noise.