Hocker's Figure 2 shows a comparison of the observed and
modeled global ocean temperature anomaly:
Not exact matches
But climate
models predict reductions in dissolved oxygen in all
oceans as average
global air and sea
temperatures rise, and this may be the main driver of what is happening there, she says.
The
models must track how carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases cycle through the whole system — how the gases interact with plant life,
oceans, the atmosphere — and how this influences overall
global temperatures.
The resulting outburst of methane produced effects similar to those predicted by current
models of
global climate change: a sudden, extreme rise in
temperatures, combined with acidification of the
oceans.
However, in the 2013 Fifth Assessment Report (AR5), the IPCC concluded that «
Modelling indicates that SRM methods, if realizable, have the potential to substantially offset a
global temperature rise, but they would also modify the
global water cycle, and would not reduce
ocean acidification.»
Their findings, based on output from four
global climate
models of varying
ocean and atmospheric resolution, indicate that
ocean temperature in the U.S. Northeast Shelf is projected to warm twice as fast as previously projected and almost three times faster than the
global average.
«When we included projected Antarctic wind shifts in a detailed
global ocean model, we found water up to 4 °C warmer than current
temperatures rose up to meet the base of the Antarctic ice shelves,» said lead author Dr Paul Spence from the ARC Centre of Excellence for Climate System Science (ARCCSS).
«By prescribing the effects of human - made climate change and observed
global ocean temperatures, our
model can reproduce the observed shifts in weather patterns and wildfire occurrences.»
Climate
models show the absence of a
global atmospheric circulation pattern which bolsters high
ocean temperatures key to coral bleaching
The researchers paired MIT's
global circulation
model — which simulates physical phenomena such as
ocean currents,
temperatures, and salinity — with an ecosystem
model that simulates the behavior of 96 species of phytoplankton.
The diagnostics, which are used to compare
model - simulated and observed changes, are often simple
temperature indices such as the
global mean surface
temperature and
ocean mean warming (Knutti et al., 2002, 2003) or the differential warming between the SH and NH (together with the
global mean; Andronova and Schlesinger, 2001).
Bayesian estimation of climate sensitivity based on a simple climate
model fitted to observations oh hemispheric
temperature and
global ocean heat content.
But I would suppose that equilibrium climate sensitivity [background] and even
global mean surface
temperature on a decadal scale could be better nailed down by
model pruning and better
ocean data.
Bayesian estimation of climate sensitivity based on a simple climate
model fitted to observations of hemispheric
temperatures and
global ocean heat content
A new paper closely examining
ocean temperatures throws a twist into understanding of the pattern of
global warming seen in the 20th century, but does it throw established concepts and climate
models into question?
Kosaka and Xie made
global climate simulations in which they inserted specified observed Pacific
Ocean temperatures; they found that the
model simulated well the observed
global warming slowdown or «hiatus,» although this experiment does not identify the cause of Pacific
Ocean temperature trends.
A
model of the imperfections is needed to enable the compensation, and the teams who provide values of
global temperature each use a different
model for the imperfections (i.e. they make different selections of which points to use, they provide different weightings for e.g. effects over
ocean and land, and so on).
This is particularly significant because many climate - change alarmists conjecture that the reason
global temperatures of the 21st century are lower than their faulty climate
models originally predicted is that the Earth's
oceans are absorbing all the excess heat.
By comparing
modelled and observed changes in such indices, which include the
global mean surface
temperature, the land -
ocean temperature contrast, the
temperature contrast between the NH and SH, the mean magnitude of the annual cycle in
temperature over land and the mean meridional
temperature gradient in the NH mid-latitudes, Braganza et al. (2004) estimate that anthropogenic forcing accounts for almost all of the warming observed between 1946 and 1995 whereas warming between 1896 and 1945 is explained by a combination of anthropogenic and natural forcing and internal variability.
Forest 2006, along with several other climate sensitivity studies, used simulations by the MIT 2D
model of zonal surface and upper - air
temperatures and
global deep -
ocean temperature, the upper - air data being least influential.
[12] Magne Aldrin et al., «Bayesian Estimation of Climate Sensitivity Based on a Simple Climate
Model Fitted to Observations of Hemispheric
Temperatures and
Global Ocean Heat Content,» Environmetrics, Vol.
6, No. 6 (June 2013), pp. 415 — 416; Magne Aldrin et al., «Bayesian Estimation of Climate Sensitivity Based on a Simple Climate
Model Fitted to Observations of Hemispheric
Temperatures and
Global Ocean Heat Content,» Environmetrics, Vol.
«By prescribing the effects of man - made climate change and observed
global ocean temperatures, our
model can reproduce the observed shifts in weather patterns and wildfire occurrences.»
The
models used by the IPCC do not take into account or show the most important
ocean oscillations which clearly do affect
global temperatures, namely, the Pacific Decadal Oscillation, the Atlantic Multidecadal Oscillation, and the ENSO.
Its seven chapters discuss the
global climate
models, forcings and feedbacks, solar forcing of the climate, and observations on
temperature, the icecaps, the water cycle and
oceans, and weather.»
It seemsthe observed increase in trade winds lead to the surfacing of cooler waters in the Eastern Pacific
ocean and this phenomenon is found by
models to cause
global average
temperatures to cool.
GCMs, by their
global nature, are intended to
model global climate, whose
temperature is strongly dominated by the
oceans.
For example, Kosaka and Xie showed than when the El Niño - related changes in Pacific
ocean temperature are entered into a
model, it not only reproduced the
global surface warming over the past 15 years but it also accurately reproduced regional and seasonal changes in surface
temperatures.
Comparison of
global lower troposphere
temperature anomaly over the
oceans (blue line) to a
model based on the first derivative of atmospheric CO2 concentration at Mauna Loa (red line).
Figure 1:
Global temperatures from
models are calculated using air
temperatures above the land surface and also from the upper few meters of the
ocean.
- ARAMATE (The reconstruction of ecosystem and climate variability in the north Atlantic region using annually resolved archives of marine and terrestrial ecosystems)- CLIM - ARCH-DATE (Integration of high resolution climate archives with archaeological and documentary evidence for the precise dating of maritime cultural and climatic events)- CLIVASH2k (Climate variability in Antarctica and Southern Hemisphere in the past 2000 years)- CoralHydro2k (Tropical
ocean hydroclimate and
temperature from coral archives)-
Global T CFR (Global gridded temperature reconstruction method comparisons)- GMST reconstructions - Iso2k (A global synthesis of Common Era hydroclimate using water isotopes)- MULTICHRON (Constraining modeled multidecadal climate variability in the Atlantic using proxies derived from marine bivalve shells and coralline algae)- PALEOLINK (The missing link in the Past — Downscaling paleoclimatic Earth System Models)- PSR2k (Proxy Surrogate Reconstructi
Global T CFR (
Global gridded temperature reconstruction method comparisons)- GMST reconstructions - Iso2k (A global synthesis of Common Era hydroclimate using water isotopes)- MULTICHRON (Constraining modeled multidecadal climate variability in the Atlantic using proxies derived from marine bivalve shells and coralline algae)- PALEOLINK (The missing link in the Past — Downscaling paleoclimatic Earth System Models)- PSR2k (Proxy Surrogate Reconstructi
Global gridded
temperature reconstruction method comparisons)- GMST reconstructions - Iso2k (A
global synthesis of Common Era hydroclimate using water isotopes)- MULTICHRON (Constraining modeled multidecadal climate variability in the Atlantic using proxies derived from marine bivalve shells and coralline algae)- PALEOLINK (The missing link in the Past — Downscaling paleoclimatic Earth System Models)- PSR2k (Proxy Surrogate Reconstructi
global synthesis of Common Era hydroclimate using water isotopes)- MULTICHRON (Constraining
modeled multidecadal climate variability in the Atlantic using proxies derived from marine bivalve shells and coralline algae)- PALEOLINK (The missing link in the Past — Downscaling paleoclimatic Earth System
Models)- PSR2k (Proxy Surrogate Reconstruction 2k)
Christy is correct to note that the
model average warming trend (0.23 °C / decade for 1978 - 2011) is a bit higher than observations (0.17 °C / decade over the same timeframe), but that is because over the past decade virtually every natural influence on
global temperatures has acted in the cooling direction (i.e. an extended solar minimum, rising aerosols emissions, and increased heat storage in the deep
oceans).
Since then there are a number of papers published on why the warming was statistically insignificant including a recent one by Richardson et al. 2016 which tries to explain that the
models were projecting a
global tas (
temperature air surface) but the actual observations are a combination of tas (land) and SST
oceans, meaning projected warming shouldn't be as much as projected.
Science:
Models have successfully reproduced
global temperatures since 1900, by land, in the air and the
oceans.
Use of this type of
modeling allows for better understanding of the effects of OTEC deployment in
global phenomena (changes in water
temperature and its effect on atmosphere -
ocean interaction or
global warming, to name some).
Has someone
modeled the thermal characteristics of the
oceans + solar heat input and would that help explain recent trends in
global temperatures?
«The authors write that «the notorious tropical bias problem in climate simulations of
global coupled general circulation
models manifests itself particularly strongly in the tropical Atlantic,»... they state that «the climate bias problem is still so severe that one of the most basic features of the equatorial Atlantic
Ocean — the eastward shoaling thermocline — can not be reproduced by most of the IPCC assessment report
models,... as they describe it, «show that the bias in the eastern equatorial Atlantic has a major effect on sea - surface
temperature (SST) response to a rapid change in the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation (AMOC).»
Then you need the climate
model to respond accurately to all these radiative forcings, and by taking full account of the heat capacity of the atmosphere, land, and
ocean, to produce a time trend of the
global temperature.
And the climate
models seem to get the warming rate of sea surface
temperatures just right for the smallest portion of the
global oceans, the extratropical Northern Hemisphere (24N - 90N).
(07/08/2013) Warmer
ocean temperatures will increase the frequency and intensity of tropical cyclones, typhoons and hurricanes in «most locations» this century, concludes a new study based on simulations using six
global climate
models.
«Causes of differences in
model and satellite tropospheric warming rates» «Comparing tropospheric warming in climate
models and satellite data» «Robust comparison of climate
models with observations using blended land air and
ocean sea surface
temperatures» «Coverage bias in the HadCRUT4
temperature series and its impact on recent
temperature trends» «Reconciling warming trends» «Natural variability, radiative forcing and climate response in the recent hiatus reconciled» «Reconciling controversies about the «
global warming hiatus»»
By forcing a computer
model to have the correct surface
temperatures in that part of the
ocean, the authors were able to recreate the fits and starts of
global warming.
«In our mor recent
global model simulations the
ocean heat - uptake is slower than previously estimated, the
ocean uptake of carbon is weaker, feedbacks from the land system as
temperature rises are stronger, cumulative emissions of greenhouse gases over the century are higher, and offsetting cooling from aerosol emissions is lower.
Studies involving 28 million weather balloons, thousands of satellite recordings, 3,000
ocean buoys,
temperature recordings from 50 sites in the US and a 1,000 years of
temperature proxies suggest that the
Global Climate
Models overestimate positive feedback and are based on poor assumptions.
The analysis uses a
global energy budget
model that links ECS and TCR to changes in
global mean surface
temperature (GMST), radiative forcing and the rate of
ocean heat uptake between a base and a final period.
The new research uses multiple runs of a coupled
ocean - atmosphere computer
model to simulate
global temperature changes in response to climate forcing when the sea surface
temperature (SST) in the el Niño region follows its historically observed values.
All of these characteristics (except for the
ocean temperature) have been used in SAR and TAR IPCC (Houghton et al. 1996; 2001) reports for
model - data inter-comparison: we considered as tolerable the following intervals for the annual means of the following climate characteristics which encompass corresponding empirical estimates:
global SAT 13.1 — 14.1 °C (Jones et al. 1999); area of sea ice in the Northern Hemisphere 6 — 14 mil km2 and in the Southern Hemisphere 6 — 18 mil km2 (Cavalieri et al. 2003); total precipitation rate 2.45 — 3.05 mm / day (Legates 1995); maximum Atlantic northward heat transport 0.5 — 1.5 PW (Ganachaud and Wunsch 2003); maximum of North Atlantic meridional overturning stream function 15 — 25 Sv (Talley et al. 2003), volume averaged
ocean temperature 3 — 5 °C (Levitus 1982).
A slight change of
ocean temperature (after a delay caused by the high specific heat of water, the annual mixing of thermocline waters with deeper waters in storms) ensures that rising CO2 reduces infrared absorbing H2O vapour while slightly increasing cloud cover (thus Earth's albedo), as evidenced by the fact that the NOAA data from 1948 - 2008 shows a fall in
global humidity (not the positive feedback rise presumed by NASA's
models!)
The CO2 doubling response from CM2.6, over 70 - 80 years, shows that upper -
ocean (0 - 300 m)
temperature in the Northwest Atlantic Shelf warms at a rate nearly twice as fast as the coarser
models and nearly three times faster than the
global average.
Bayesian estimation of climate sensitivity based on a simple climate
model fitted to observations of hemispheric
temperature and
global ocean heat content.