With a growing body of research showing that teachers are the most important determinant of student achievement, new and
more rigorous teacher evaluation systems and policies have been implemented across the country.
With a growing body of research showing that teachers are the most important determinant of student achievement, new and
more rigorous teacher evaluation systems and policies have been implemented ac... Read More...
Should the state impose
more rigorous teacher evaluation standards, perhaps outside of collective bargaining, and should those standards be based substantially on students» standardized test scores?
Though Mr. Cuomo, a Democrat, offered up $ 1.1 billion in new school aid, he attached strings that could kill the deal for allies of the teachers» unions in the Assembly: a much
more rigorous teacher evaluation system to replace the current one, new hurdles for teachers on the path to tenure, and an expansion by 100 of the limit on the number of charter schools statewide.
It also appears that the advocates and donors to the governor who praised his call last winter for
a more rigorous teacher evaluation system would not criticize him if it were now unwound.
What has this bold — but fiscally and politically expensive — experiment with
more rigorous teacher evaluation brought us?
But anyone who expects the UFT to accept
more rigorous teacher evaluations, or to clear a path for firing bad teachers, simply hasn't been paying attention for the past decade.
Research supported by the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation, which has advocated for
more rigorous teacher evaluations, suggests that using two evaluators tends to yield more accurate assessments than using one.
Both teach in Tennessee — a state that has invested in a wide array of teaching reforms, including training for standards - based instruction, as well as implementing
more rigorous teacher evaluations.
What's surprising in a new survey published today by 50CAN, a reform - oriented advocacy group that supports
more rigorous teacher evaluations and early education, is the relatively lukewarm response to some of the most favored ideas for improving the school system among education advocates and many elected officials.
Speaking of the rest of the state, Timothy Daly, the president of the New Teacher Project, an education reform group that advocates
more rigorous teacher evaluations, said, «Many districts appear to have completely botched this.»
In exchange, states were forced to agree to a US DOE school improvement agenda that focused on overhauling low performing schools, adopting
more rigorous teacher evaluations and new college and career ready academic standards known as Common Core.
Helping struggling teachers improve has become a big concern — and a big business — across the country, especially as more states, including New York, introduce
more rigorous teacher evaluations.
Not exact matches
The Republicans are tapping into an anger among many parents in New York state over the botched rollout of a
more rigorous curriculum that relies
more on standardized tests, and is tied to
teacher evaluations.
Tisch, who served nearly 20 years as a Regent and six as the Chancellor, led the controversial movements to adopt
rigorous Common Core standards and tie a portion of
teacher evaluations to student test scores, and also implemented
more difficult state exams during her tenure.
He talks about
more rigorous standards and
evaluations for
teachers and students, even while the charter schools he champions function without any effective oversight.
Absent persuasive evidence on the impact of efforts to raise the bar, some people have speculated that the rise of test - based accountability associated with NCLB and the ongoing push to establish
more -
rigorous teacher evaluation systems have made teaching less attractive and thereby contributed to further decline in the quality of the teaching corps.
More promising is the possibility of tracing teacher evaluation ratings back to the institution, particularly in states that have embraced more rigorous evaluation syst
More promising is the possibility of tracing
teacher evaluation ratings back to the institution, particularly in states that have embraced
more rigorous evaluation syst
more rigorous evaluation systems.
That work rested on a particular theory of action — that
more rigorous evaluation systems would empower districts to make better decisions about which
teachers to put at the front of the room and thereby improve student outcomes.
The waiver application contains the same commitments that all states seeking waivers were required to meet: implementing Common Core or other
rigorous standards preparing students for college and careers, developing a
teacher evaluation process that includes the results of local and state tests, and creating an accountability system that recognizes that success is
more than students» test scores.
Still other changes, such as
more rigorous evaluation of
teachers, are still emerging, and thus too new to understand how they may have affected student outcomes.
We have seen urban public schools successfully adopt many charter school «secrets,» including the nine - hour school day (e.g., United for Success Academies in Oakland); a
rigorous, standard curriculum (e.g., the
more than a dozen Chicago public schools that offer the International Baccalaureate); merit pay (e.g., the Washington, D.C., system); and the regular use of
teacher video in professional development and
evaluation (e.g., the Houston system, which was using video in this way as early as the 1980s).
Yet the major sticking points are Mr. Corbett's school reforms that would eliminate
teacher seniority rights and base future pay increases on
more rigorous evaluations that include student learning.
The new
teacher and principal
evaluations will be
more rigorous, moving from the limited choice between «unsatisfactory» or «meets expectations» to a four - tiered structure offering
more rounded, useful assessments.
In August, the Obama administration said states could ask for a delay in tying student test scores on new,
more rigorous exams to
teacher evaluations — though some states don't need it.
U.S. Education Secretary Arne Duncan, who described overall performance as modest, credited those particularly large gains in some states to the introduction of the new,
more rigorous «Common Core» standards and other initiatives the Obama administration has promoted, including new
teacher evaluations.
This guide offers succinct recommendations for
more frequent and
more rigorous evaluation of
teacher professional development to improve both the quality of professional learning and its results.
Thankfully,
more school systems are instituting
rigorous evaluations to understand how both students and
teachers are performing.But, as in teaching, there is also always room for improvement in
evaluation methods.
Yet many local, state, and national union leaders have not pressed for
more rigorous evaluation systems for fear that such systems may result in the dismissal of additional
teachers for poor performance and may strengthen the case for performance - based pay at the expense of the single - salary schedule.
If you remove Common Core from everything else — the new
teacher evaluation plan, the perceived charter - Pearson - TFA cabal, increased testing, whatever — I can't see why anyone would oppose a
more rigorous curriculum that holds students to a higher standard.
With the recent Race to the Top mandates,
evaluation systems may be
more rigorous than ever, though they often judge
teachers by a rigidly and often inaccurate value - added measure of their effectiveness in raising test scores (Özek & Xu, 2015; Raudenbush, 2015).
But the program also has prompted a number of states to lift arbitrary caps on charter schools and, perhaps most importantly, has gotten 36 states and the District of Columbia to introduce
more rigorous teacher -
evaluation systems.
Teacher prep programs must get
more rigorous,
evaluations aligned with student outcomes (not I said outcomes not test scores so don't put words in my mouth)...
I will concede the solutions would need
more funding, but the solutions include changing the teaching profession, requiring different expectations at
teacher prep programs, reinventing professional development, having a
more rigorous human capital department (from hiring to
evaluations),
more choice,
more parent engagement... I also think teaching is not a right, but something you must earn, you should have a society that invests in the teaching profession and
teachers investing in it too.
(The paper, though, did not look at new
teachers after 2008 — so it doesn't account for people who started after the
more rigorous evaluations took effect.)
Under new state and federal policies, most high - need schools we work with at the Community Training and Assistance Center are implementing
more rigorous approaches to
teacher support and
evaluation.
Colorado, while mandating that 50 percent of a
teacher's
evaluation be based on student growth, allows districts to choose their own student learning measures — including state assessment results — and decide how to weight them.66 In addition to adjustments to how much student growth factors into
evaluations, some states, including Georgia and Connecticut, have opted to delay full implementation of their
evaluation systems while they transition to the
more rigorous Common Core standards.67 68
But, even
more than general
evaluation ratings,
teachers want to ensure that the feedback itself is «
rigorous, tied to a clear vision for instruction and viewed... as credible.»
Andrew Cuomo signaled his intentions to make
teacher evaluations more «
rigorous» just before the election with newspaper interviews and public statements.
And yet the push for higher academic standards,
more rigorous evaluation methods (of both
teachers and students) and mandated reforms have not resulted in higher student outcomes.
In an
evaluation of efforts to introduce
more rigorous algebra lessons to Los Angeles high school students,
teachers reported that pressure to keep up with the pacing guide frustrated their attempts to immerse students in challenging tasks (David & Greene, 2007).
But his tenure wasn't without its criticisms: He was also responsible for shepherding
more contentious policies such as the
rigorous standards tied to RTTT and the
teacher evaluation systems that accompanied NCLB waivers.