Any way you look at it, homebirth is more dangerous for
mothers than hospital birth.
Not exact matches
If these are not effective and the
mother wishes to have medication, we will transport to the
hospital (though of more
than 500
births, only 1 - 2 women have transported for pain relief).
Australian researchers found that new
mothers were more likely to be breastfeeding their newborns a few months after delivery if their
hospitals followed the Baby - Friendly
Hospital Initiative (BFHI) guidelines, than if they gave birth in a hospital accredited by the Ini
Hospital Initiative (BFHI) guidelines,
than if they gave
birth in a
hospital accredited by the Ini
hospital accredited by the Initiative.
There are no studies that demonstrate that homebirth with a US homebirth midwife is less likely to kill or permanently disable either
mother or baby
than hospital birth under the care of an ob.
With a mortality rate of almost 5x higher
than hospital birth, this is not that far off the 6 - 8 times higher we saw for the Oregon data collection, even though the Oregon group almost surely had significantly fewer criteria for risking
mothers out (no criteria in some places, I'm sure) as well as lower qualifications for the midwives as CPMs and DEMs.
So then why, in a country where most
births take place in
hospitals, are
mothers dying more frequently
than other countries?
Home
Birth on the Rise by a Dramatic 20 Percent One mother chose home birth because it was cheaper than going to a hosp
Birth on the Rise by a Dramatic 20 Percent One
mother chose home
birth because it was cheaper than going to a hosp
birth because it was cheaper
than going to a
hospital.
Mothers usually leave the
hospital less
than 2 days after giving
birth.
Studies there (sorry, don't have any references on hand, I'll try to get them posted later) show that home - birthing in this setting is just as safe for
mother and child for a first
birth, and safer for next
births,
than a
hospital setting.
None of this surprises me, but I think he's more likely to find stories of
mothers who went the home
birth route as the result of a negative
hospital birth than the other way around.
The perinatal (around the time of
birth) death rate of babies born in nonhospital settings is much higher
than for babies born in a
hospital, even though their
mothers are supposedly lower - risk.
Birth centers tend to be cheaper
than hospitals not only for the time that
mothers spend but because
hospitals use more resources, such as IV line, belly monitors, electricity, pain drugs, etc..
What floors me is how people continue to ignore the glaringly obvious fact, that homebirth, even under the best circumstances, continues to kill
mothers and babies at a rate that is far higher
than births that occur in
hospital settings.
Unless the
mother is too wooy or a midwife herself, it does seem that a free birthing
mother is more likely to go to a doctor or
hospital if there are complications which could explain why unassisted
births in either the Colorado or Oregon study showed a lower mortality rate for unassisted
than midwife attended.
However, studies show that even in those countries, it's less safe
than hospital birth, and it's important that
mothers understand that.
Hospitals are also being asked to encourage new
mothers to breastfeed their newborns right after
birth, rather
than offering them formula.
«
Hospitals tend to turn the
birth of a child into an organised, sanitised affaire over which the professionals, rather
than mothers have control.»
The most recent large scale study comparing outcomes for
mother and baby reported in the British Medical Journal last month showed that for women who had previously given
birth, adverse outcomes were less common among planned home
births (1 per 1,000)
than among planned
hospital births (2.3 per 1,000).
Home birthing is the newest parenting trend with more and more
mothers opting for a certified midwife
than a standard
hospital birth.
«The planned category of out - of -
hospital births is seen to be a generally low - risk group for neonatal mortality, with very few low -
birth - weight
births and fewer teenage, low - educational levels and unwed
mothers than found statewide, «the researchers said.
As
mother's opted to use physicians to give
birth in
hospitals or clinics, rather
than using a midwife for home
birth, the practice of routine circumcision of male infants blossomed and became nearly universal.
Planned home
births are less risky
than planned
hospital births, particularly for second - time
mothers, says research in the British Medical Journal.
Honestly, giving
birth at a
hospital with pain medication is far more about keeping a
mother comfortable
than an all natural
birth at home is.
«Breastfeeding twice as likely after home
births than hospital births: Study of
mothers in UK, Ireland may provide important clues to help improve breastfeeding rates.»
In such a case, would it not be better to allow gravity, i.e; the
birth mother standing and moving whilst in labour, to take charge rather
than the birthing
mother instead lying on her back in an ambulance and then
hospital along with the accompanying substantial increase in stress levels?I suppose all I am trying to say is that IF my partner and I were to have a second baby, I really would like to support my partner once more in having a home
birth.
Rather
than heralding this life - saving medical intervention as progress, she says, «
Hospitals tend to turn
birth into an organised, sanitised affair over which the professionals, rather
than mothers have control.»
The studies do not lie, it is just as safe to
birth at home
than it is in the
hospital for a low - risk healthy pregnancy /
mother.
In a previous study of 24 healthy women, vaginal microbiome composition became less diverse between the second and third trimesters of pregnancy and just before delivery was enriched with Lactobacillus species, likely contributing to vertical transmission of these bacteria during vaginal
birth.21 In a study of 10 newborns in Venezuela, within hours of delivery, the intestinal tracts of infants born vaginally were colonized by Lactobacillus and Prevotella, whereas infants delivered operatively acquired bacteria present on the
mother's skin and the
hospital environment, such as Staphylococcus, Proprionibacterium, and Corynebacterium.15 Quiz Ref ID Our findings, based on a large group of 6 - week - old infants, indicated that Lactobacillus also contributes to the microbial environment of the gut but to a lesser extent
than Bifidobacteria, Bacteroides, and Streptococcus.
This study, which tracked more
than 5,000
mothers in the United States and Canada, also reported that home
births with low - risk
mothers resulted in much lower rates of medical interventions when compared to the intervention rates for low - risk
mothers giving
birth in
hospitals.
In a
hospital water
birth, there is a lot of monitoring, AND a lot of staff around, so getting the
mother out quickly, as soon as there is a problem detected or suspected, is probably less of an issue
than at home.
It is much more disturbing that there can be so much variation within one
hospital: Going to Ein Karem was a totally reasonable choice for a
mother who wanted to be with her babies a lot — it worked for you and for many other people (myself included; when my son was born there I had him by my side from his
birth to our discharge other
than when I asked the nurses to watch him while I took a shower), but then you hear nightmare stories like this one.
Although having to go through IVF and gestational diabetes and 2 c - sections and Joey's NICU / nursery stays and both kids self weaning were all huge emotional and physical traumas for me (and my husband), now that they're in the past and I'm a mommy to two amazing toddlers, I can see that it all worked out how it was supposed to.And my advice to all new
mothers who hope / plan to nurse take a breastfeeding class when pregnant, have a breastpump in the house before the baby is born, buy nursing bras that have front panels that you can open easily (and bring some to the
hospital with you when you go to give
birth), don't be afraid to pump and let someone else give the baby a bottle of your milk when you need to sleep, hold off on introducing baby food until much closer to 1 year old
than 6 ohtnms, and be prepared for it to be hard and possibly painful at first (think cracked, bleeding nipples and breasts that are so full of milk you think they will explode so also have lanolin and / or nipple cream in the house, and nurse or pump well before you let yourself become engorged and in pain).
The researchers suggest, based on their analysis of the data, that screening compliance could be increased by focusing educational and outreach efforts on certain groups who were less likely to get their infants screened for congenital CMV: less educated
mothers, babies not born in a
hospital and infants who received hearing tests later
than 14 days after
birth.
I read some where that
hospital births had a higher mortality rate for
mothers and infants
than home
births.