Further, the standards movement must not limit learning
by narrowing curricula, nor inhibit creative teaching and learning that is grounded in effective practice and sound research and inquiry.
As a consequence, practices such
as narrowing the curriculum to the tested areas and drilling students to prepare them for the tests have too often become the norm.
But the intense focus on test scores has left many parents concerned
about narrowing curriculum and what they call a classroom concentration on testing well instead of learning.
The following concerns have been expressed about performance - based assessments: teachers might teach only to the test,
thereby narrowing the curriculum and reducing the test's value.
«My overwhelming impression is that most of our kids around the city are getting a very,
very narrow curriculum,» she says.
The NRC, instead of considering these actual costs, suggests that implicit costs in the form
of narrowed curricula are the most important, but it provides no evidence for its view.
Standardized tests force teachers to spend too much time preparing the students for the test which results
in narrowing the curriculum.
«The negative consequences of the current overwhelming focus on preparation for standardized tests
include narrowed curricula, developmentally inappropriate instructional practices, decreases in student engagement, stagnant achievement gaps and rising minority dropout rates,» said subcommittee member and Winchester second grade teacher David Krane.
While critics blame the Common Core for
further narrowing curriculums, the authors of the standards actually saw them as a tool to counteract that trend.
The Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA) replaced No Child Left Behind, a much - criticized law whose emphasis on high - stakes testing
frequently narrowed the curriculum to the content and format of low - level multiple - choice reading and math tests, especially in low - income schools.
Our goal with this measure is to ensure that schools do not excessively
narrow the curriculum at the cost of non-tested subjects and opportunities for enrichment.
PAA opposes excessive reliance on standardized exams,
which narrows the curriculum, promotes teaching to the test and leads to unfair and unreliable evaluations of students, teachers and schools.
«In terms of equity — when you look at what is happening in our urban districts, we're getting an extremely
narrow curriculum because of the pressure on teachers to focus on tested subjects.»
Even before Common Core, many schools, in response to No Child Left Behind laws, had
already narrowed their curricula mostly to the subjects being tested by their states.
The real threat to national security is squeezing the democracy out of our schools with such «reform school» approaches replacing efforts at real school reform, and with standardized testing
narrowing the curriculum so that our schools are simply no longer able to produce informed citizens.
Second, I shared how many teachers fear that they or their colleagues will be pressured to «teach to the test,»
narrowing the curriculum almost beyond recognition.
Despite national concerns around the
EBacc narrowing the curriculum, Liverpool school, The Studio, is proving student passion for creative subjects is still in full force.
Paul Whiteman, the general secretary of NAHT, warned that «inadequate funding, combined with a high - stakes accountability regime, is
actively narrowing the curriculum available to pupils in our schools».
The report is the first of its type since No Child Left Behind became law in 2001, when state standards and assessments to measure student and school
performance narrowed curricula.
High - Stakes Testing: Excessive reliance on standardized
exams narrows the curriculum, promotes teaching to the test and leads to unfair and unreliable evaluations of students, teachers and schools.
Because an
increasingly narrow curriculum wrapped around standardized tests will produce citizens with narrow, standardized knowledge — not the creative, innovative thinkers America needs to compete in the global 21st century economy.
They feel that my position may lead to the clock being turned back and a reversion to the days of multiple - choice tests and
narrow curricula devoid of the things that engage students and make them think deeply.
REALITY: In districts with mandated, scripted curriculums, or in schools that
inevitably narrow the curriculum in order to prepare for high - stakes testing, students are covering less content in ways that do not require higher - order thinking skills.
However, the implementation of NCLB has perverted standards - based accountability
by narrowing the curriculum, limiting the ways in which student performance is assessed, and constraining pedagogy.
SBA is leading to an increased emphasis on student achievement, and many educators laud this focus, but a single - minded emphasis on student proficiency on tests has some potentially negative consequences such
as narrowing curriculum and declining staff morale.
Among the findings were these: • The sole reliance on the on - demand MCAS tests has had the unintended outcome
of narrowing curriculum, modifying instructional approaches without consideration of what is developmentally appropriate, and has resulted in notable decreases in student engagement.
Race to the Bottom Michael McGill Focusing on the push over the past few decades to «save» the nation's schools by applying rigorous business strategies, Michael McGill, M.A.T.» 67, C.A.S.» 70, Ed.D.» 72, a former superintendent, argues that corporate reform has actually weakened public schools,
with narrower curriculums and a slashing of «nonessentials» like art and languages.
The result is very low teacher morale, plummeting applications to schools of education, the need to recruit too many of our teachers from the lowest levels of high school graduates, a testing regime that has
narrowed the curriculum for millions of students to a handful of subjects and a very low level of aspiration.
Another non-negotiable for me is that the system must
not narrow the curriculum in a way that does not support the whole child or a student pursuing his or her interest.
The results of this survey are predictable: protests
about narrowing the curriculum, teaching to the test, inadequate professional development, unfairness toward disadvantaged and minority youngsters — and toward hard - working teachers themselves.
An antidote to the
frequently narrowed curricula we see in modern school culture, school librarians introduce young people to a rich world of books and literature, options they can select themselves.
And the law continues to encourage schools to
narrow curriculum at the expense of important subjects such as history, civics, science, the arts and physical education.
As parents we oppose the current obsession with high - stakes standardized tests,
which narrows the curriculum and fuels punitive policies that diminish student, teacher and school morale without improving achievement.
There are warnings from teachers that an excessive emphasis on
testing narrows the curriculum and reduces creativity, with the pressure of school league tables taking precedence over the needs of individual pupils.
The Union argues that changes proposed by the Government would have a detrimental impact on education services,
narrow the curriculum and lead to real difficulty in attracting and retaining high - calibre individuals to the profession.
«The CBI is right to call for a move away from the damaging system of crude performance tables which provide perverse incentives,
narrows the curriculum and denies parents and the public access to quality information on schools» strengths, weaknesses and opportunities for development.